Abstract: GPwSIs in respiratory medicine in China could have a relatively low level of knowledge and awareness regarding nicotine, NRT, and e-cigarettes. The study highlights the need for smoking cessation training among GPwSIs to improve their knowledge and provide better assistance to patients who want to quit smoking.
Introduction
China faces a significant public health challenge with an adult smoking prevalence of approximately 26.6%. General practitioners (GPs) serve as the frontline for smoking cessation efforts. Specifically, General Practitioners with a Special Interest (GPwSIs) in respiratory medicine—those who have undergone additional training—are expected to lead these clinical interventions. However, if these specialized providers hold inaccurate beliefs about the safety and efficacy of cessation tools, they may inadvertently discourage patients from using effective treatments. This study quantifies the knowledge, attitudes, and awareness of these key medical influencers regarding nicotine, Nicotine Replacement Therapy (NRT), and electronic cigarettes.
Methodology
Researchers conducted a cross-sectional study between October 2021 and February 2022, recruiting 102 GPwSIs through the Western General Practice Network in Sichuan Province, China. Participants completed an online survey assessing demographics, perceived health risks of various products (tobacco, NRT, e-cigarettes) via Likert-type scales, knowledge of NRT protocols, attitudes toward e-cigarettes, and self-reported confidence in cessation counseling.
Results
Perceptions of Health Risks
The study revealed a significant disconnect between the practitioners' specialized roles and their clinical knowledge. While tobacco was correctly identified as high-risk, there was substantial "unfamiliarity" and an overestimation of risk regarding NRT and oral medications. As shown in the figure below, many practitioners view cessation aids with a level of skepticism or lack of awareness that may hinder their clinical application.
The Nicotine-Carcinogen Misconception
A critical finding was that 77.5% of respondents believed nicotine plays an active role in the development of lung cancer. While nicotine is the primary addictive component of tobacco, it is not classified as a carcinogen. This misconception represents a major barrier to recommending NRT to patients. Furthermore, practitioners frequently attributed the occurrence of other organ cancers to nicotine, contradicting current toxicological understanding.
Knowledge Gaps in Cessation Tools
- NRT Dosing: Although over 90% of GPs knew nicotine patches and gum were approved tools, only 27.5% correctly identified the proper dosage protocol (starting with a high dose and tapering down).
- E-cigarette Skepticism: Perceptions were highly fragmented; 71.6% would not recommend e-cigarettes to patients, and 25.5% reported being completely "unfamiliar" with them, reflecting a lack of clinical guidance.
- The Physician-Smoker Paradox: Approximately 17.6% of these respiratory-focused GPs were current smokers. Data suggests that physicians who smoke are statistically less likely to advocate for cessation to their patients.
Discussion and Conclusion
The findings highlight a critical need for standardized training. Despite their specialized focus, only 5.9% of GPwSIs felt "very confident" in providing cessation services, and 94.1% explicitly stated they require further training.
While limited by its geographic scope (Sichuan Province) and sample size (n=102), the study underscores that even specialized frontline doctors require significant standardized education to effectively combat China's high smoking prevalence. Future efforts should focus on mandatory smoking cessation training programs to bridge the gap between practitioner roles and their clinical knowledge.
Summary updated