Keep Your Friends Close and Your Facebook Friends Closer: A Multiplex Network Approach to the Analysis of Offline and Online Social Ties

Desislava Hristova, Mirco Musolesi, Cecilia Mascolo

TL;DR

This paper introduces a multiplex network approach to measure the strength of social ties by combining multiple communication channels—specifically phone calls, text messages, and physical proximity. Applying this model to a dataset of college students, the authors demonstrate that while strong offline ties are highly homogeneous, online social networks (like Facebook) actually foster greater diversity in political and musical viewpoints.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Homophily—the classic "birds of a feather flock together" phenomenon—is a fundamental aspect of human behavior. While associating with like-minded individuals provides comfort and social support, it can also trap us in information silos and "filter bubbles."

With the rise of social media, researchers have debated whether online networks expand our horizons or further isolate us. However, comparing online and offline social circles has traditionally been difficult because relationships are multi-dimensional. Relying on a single metric (like how often two people text) fails to capture true "tie strength." This paper tackles the challenge of accurately modeling multi-channel real-world interactions to determine whether our online friends are more diverse than our offline ones.

Methods

The authors propose a multiplex graph model to analyze social interactions. Instead of flattening all interactions into a single network, they represent the social structure as an ensemble of layers, where each layer corresponds to a distinct type of interaction (e.g., phone calls, SMS, and Bluetooth-detected physical proximity).

Key methodological components include:

  • Layer Aggregations: They define Union graphs (interactions present in at least one layer) and Intersection graphs (interactions present across all layers) to evaluate how communication channels overlap.
  • Multiplex Edge Weight ($mw_{ij}$): A normalized metric calculated as the fraction of available communication channels utilized between two individuals. This serves as a proxy for tie strength.
  • Profile Similarity: The authors use cosine similarity to compare user profiles across four categories: politics, music, health, and situational factors (dorm location and college year).
  • Diversity Metric ($\Delta sim$): To determine whether online or offline circles are more diverse, they calculate the difference between a student's average offline neighborhood similarity and their online (Facebook) neighborhood similarity.
Figure 1: Union and Intersection aggregations are shown on the right, where α indicates the layer; the original networks/layers of the multiplex are shown on the left.

Datasets

The study utilizes the open-access MIT Social Evolution dataset, which tracks the daily lives of 74 college students living in adjacent residence halls from October 2008 to May 2009. The dataset includes:

  • Behavioral tracking: Continuous logs of phone calls, SMS messages, and physical proximity (monitored via Bluetooth proximity scans).
  • Surveys: Periodic self-reported data on political orientation, music preferences, health habits, and situational data.
  • Ground truth relationships: Survey responses where students explicitly explicitly stated who their close friends were, who they regularly socialized with, and who they were friends with on Facebook.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Media Multiplexity in the Pocket: The sociological theory of "media multiplexity"—which states that stronger ties use more communication channels—holds true for mobile data. If two students call, text, and spend time together physically, there is a 75% probability they are close friends.
  • The Facebook Paradox: Facebook friendships are structurally dependent on offline situational constraints (students are far more likely to be Facebook friends with people in their own year or dorm floor). Yet, despite this baseline bias, Facebook circles expose students to more diverse political opinions and musical tastes than their offline interactions.
  • Homogeneity vs. Homophily: The paper distinguishes between a community being homogeneous (everyone is similar overall) and exhibiting homophily (similarity is driven by network proximity). The student community was found to be generally homogeneous regarding politics and health, but showed true homophily in music and situational factors.

Key Results

  • Predicting Tie Strength: Single-layer communication is highly indicative of weak ties or purely online relationships. Conversely, the intersection of all three mobile layers successfully identifies 75% of close friendships.
  • Multiplexity Correlates with Similarity: Stronger multiplex ties strongly correlate with higher profile similarity, particularly for political orientation ($C = 0.6$) and health factors ($C = 0.6$).
  • Quantifying Online Diversity: More than 50% of students showed higher political diversity within their Facebook networks than their offline networks. Music preferences also showed a wide spread toward online diversity. Conversely, situational factors (year and floor) were significantly less diverse online, confirming that physical proximity drives Facebook friending patterns.
Figure 3: Probability mass function P(X = x) for each declared relationship x within each graph aggregation. None (None) means there was no declared relationship in the directed pair; Facebook Only (FB) means that there was only a Facebook friendship declared between the pair; Socialize (SC) means that the pair declared they socialize twice per week in addition to being friends on Facebook; and Close Friends (CF) means that there was a declared close friendship in addition to all other social relationships.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations inherent to the study's environment:

  • The "College Bubble": A university campus is a highly specific, socio-demographically homogeneous environment. The baseline similarity among students makes it harder to generalize these findings to the broader public.
  • Potential vs. Actual Exposure: While the paper proves that Facebook networks are structurally more diverse, it cannot account for algorithmic filtering (the Facebook News Feed algorithm) or user attention. A user might have politically diverse friends but never actually see their posts.

Future work includes scaling this multiplex model to larger, more diverse populations outside of university campuses and incorporating actual content analysis of online feeds to measure true information consumption.

Summary updated

Abstract

Social media allow for an unprecedented amount of interaction between people online. A fundamental aspect of human social behavior, however, is the tendency of people to associate themselves with like-minded individuals, forming homogeneous social circles both online and offline. In this work, we apply a new model that allows us to distinguish between social ties of varying strength, and to observe evidence of homophily with regards to politics, music, health, residential sector & year in college, within the online and offline social network of 74 college students. We present a multiplex network approach to social tie strength, here applied to mobile communication data - calls, text messages, and co-location, allowing us to dimensionally identify relationships by considering the number of communication channels utilized between students. We find that strong social ties are characterized by maximal use of communication channels, while weak ties by minimal use. We are able to identify 75% of close friendships, 90% of weaker ties, and 90% of Facebook friendships as compared to reported ground truth. We then show that stronger ties exhibit greater profile similarity than weaker ones. Apart from high homogeneity in social circles with respect to political and health aspects, we observe strong homophily driven by music, residential sector and year in college. Despite Facebook friendship being highly dependent on residence and year, exposure to less homogeneous content can be found in the online rather than the offline social circles of students, most notably in political and music aspects.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{hristova2014keep,
  author = {Desislava Hristova and Mirco Musolesi and Cecilia Mascolo},
  title = {{Keep Your Friends Close and Your Facebook Friends Closer: A Multiplex Network Approach to the Analysis of Offline and Online Social Ties}},
  booktitle = {ICWSM},
  year = {2014},
}
Figure