Jordan Matsuo algebras over fields of characteristic 3

Takahiro Yabe

TL;DR

This paper completes the classification of finite-dimensional Jordan Matsuo algebras by solving the "missing case" of fields with characteristic 3. It proves that these algebras are Jordan if and only if their underlying geometric structure (a Fischer space) is either an affine space of order 3 or associated with a symmetric group.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In the world of nonassociative algebra, Matsuo algebras are fascinating structures built from "partial triple systems"—sets of points and lines where every line contains exactly three points. These algebras are closely tied to Fischer spaces, which are the geometric counterparts to 3-transposition groups (groups generated by elements of order two whose products have order at most three).

A major goal in this field is identifying when a Matsuo algebra qualifies as a Jordan algebra. Jordan algebras are a well-studied class of commutative nonassociative algebras that satisfy a specific identity: $(x^2y)x = x^2(yx)$. While previous researchers (De Medts and Rehren, 2017) had classified these for most fields, they hit a snag with fields of characteristic 3 (where adding 1 to itself three times equals 0). This paper fills that gap, correcting a previous omission and providing a complete classification.

Methods

The author employs a mix of algebraic identity manipulation and geometric characterization:

  1. Linearization of Identities: In characteristic 3, the standard Jordan identity is difficult to work with directly. The author proves a helpful lemma: if a commutative algebra is spanned by idempotents (elements where $x^2 = x$), then the Jordan identity is equivalent to its "linearized" version. Since Matsuo algebras are naturally spanned by idempotents, this simplifies the verification process significantly.
  2. Geometric Characterization: The author provides a novel characterization of affine spaces $AG(n-1, 3)$ using the properties of transpositions (automorphisms) within the Fischer space.
  3. Inductive Classification: The proof proceeds by examining Fischer spaces of low rank (up to rank 4) and then using inductive arguments to show that any higher-rank space must be built from these specific "building block" subspaces if the resulting algebra is to remain Jordan.

Datasets

As a paper in pure mathematics, no external datasets were used. The "objects" of study are abstract algebraic and geometric structures defined within the text.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "3=0" Advantage: Interestingly, the characteristic 3 setting is what allows the affine space $AG(n-1, 3)$ to produce a Jordan algebra. In other characteristics, the calculation results in a non-zero factor that breaks the Jordan identity. Specifically, the author points out a calculation error in previous literature involving a factor of $3/32$; in characteristic 3, this factor becomes 0, "saving" the identity.
  • Idempotent Spanning: The insight that Matsuo algebras are generated by idempotents is crucial. It allows the author to move from a complex non-linear identity to a linear one, which is much easier to check across the basis of the algebra.
  • Geometric-Algebraic Duality: The paper reinforces the deep link between the geometry of the Fischer space (how points and lines intersect) and the algebraic properties of the Matsuo algebra. If the geometry isn't "just right" (either a symmetric group type or an affine type), the algebra fails to be Jordan.

Key Results

  • The Main Theorem: For a connected Fischer space $(P, L)$ over a field of characteristic 3, the Matsuo algebra $M((P, L), 1/4, \mathbb{F})$ is Jordan if and only if $(P, L)$ is isomorphic to:
  • The Fischer space associated with the symmetric group $Sym(n+1)$.
  • The $(n-1)$-dimensional affine space $AG(n-1, 3)$ of order three.
  • Completion of Classification: By proving this, the author completes the classification of finite-dimensional Jordan Matsuo algebras for all fields with characteristic not equal to 2.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Characteristic 2: The paper (and the field in general) excludes characteristic 2, where the definitions of these algebras and identities often break down or require entirely different frameworks.
  • Infinite Dimensions: While the paper focuses on finite-dimensional cases, Remark 5.3 suggests that the results could be generalized to infinite-dimensional Fischer spaces, such as those associated with inductive limits of symmetric groups.
  • Connectedness: The results assume the Fischer space is "connected." While disconnected spaces can be treated as direct sums of connected ones, the nuances of that decomposition in characteristic 3 aren't the primary focus here.

Summary updated

Abstract

The Matsuo algebra associated with a connected Fischer space is shown to be a Jordan algebra over a field of characteristic 3 if and only if the Fischer space is isomorphic to either the affine space of order 3 or the Fischer space associated with the symmetric group. The proof uses a characterization of the affine spaces of order 3 and equivalence of Jordan and linearized Jordan identities over a field of characteristic 3 in case the algebra is spanned by idempotents.
BibTeX
@article{yabe2018jordan,
  author = {Takahiro Yabe},
  title = {{Jordan Matsuo algebras over fields of characteristic 3}},
  journal = {Journal of Algebra},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.1016/j.jalgebra.2018.07.018},
}
Figure