Joint NOMA for Improved SER of Cell-Edge Users in Multi-Cell Indoor VLC

Uday Thummaluri, Abhinav Kumar, Lakshmi Natarajan

TL;DR

This paper introduces a simplified Non-Orthogonal Multiple Access (NOMA) scheme for multi-cell indoor Visible Light Communication (VLC). By jointly serving cell-edge users from multiple transmitters and utilizing Joint Maximum Likelihood (JML) decoding, the researchers significantly improve reliability for the most vulnerable users without the need for complex-domain processing or inefficient DC biasing.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Visible Light Communication (VLC) turns indoor LED lighting into a high-speed data network. However, as users move between the "cells" created by different light fixtures, those at the edges (cell-edge users) suffer from heavy interference from neighboring lamps.

Existing solutions often use NOMA combined with Optical OFDM (like DCO-OFDM). While effective, these methods require "Hermitian symmetry" to convert complex signals into real ones that LEDs can transmit. This process effectively cuts the data rate in half. Furthermore, they require adding a Direct Current (DC) bias to ensure the signal is always positive, which is power-inefficient and complicates real-time hardware implementation. The authors aim to create a NOMA system that is simpler to implement and specifically protects the performance of users caught between two cells.

Methods

The authors propose a power-domain NOMA scheme designed for a two-cell, three-user scenario:

  • The Setup: Two transmitters (Tx1, Tx2). User 1 is close to Tx1, User 3 is close to Tx2, and User 2 is at the "cell-edge," receiving signals from both.
  • Real-Domain Encoding: Unlike OFDM-based approaches, this scheme operates entirely in the real domain. It maps data directly to constellation points (power levels), avoiding the mathematical overhead of Inverse Fast Fourier Transforms (IFFT) and Hermitian symmetry.
  • Joint Transmission: The cell-edge user ($U_2$) is served by both transmitters simultaneously.
  • Advanced Decoding:
    • The "center" users ($U_1$ and $U_3$) use Successive Interference Cancellation (SIC) to peel away the stronger signal intended for the edge user.
  • The "edge" user ($U_2$) employs Joint Maximum Likelihood (JML) decoding. Instead of treating the other users' signals as pure noise, JML looks at all possible combinations of transmitted points from both cells to find the most likely match, significantly boosting accuracy.

Datasets

The paper does not use external datasets. Instead, it evaluates the proposed scheme using numerical simulations based on standard VLC channel models. They use the Lambertian radiation pattern to model how light propagates from LEDs and calculate DC channel gains based on physical parameters like room height (4m), LED semi-angle ($60^\circ$), and photodiode field-of-view.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Turning Interference into a Signal: In traditional systems, a cell-edge user sees the neighboring cell as a source of noise. By using joint transmission and JML decoding, the system treats the second cell as a second source of the desired signal, turning a disadvantage into a diversity gain.
  • Simplicity is Key: By avoiding the complex domain and DC biasing, the design becomes much more "hardware-friendly." It removes the need for the high-speed signal processing required to manage OFDM subcarriers.
  • The JML Trade-off: The researchers highlight a clear engineering trade-off. While JML decoding provides superior error performance for the edge user, it requires more computational power (searching through more constellation combinations) than simple SIC.

Key Results

  • Edge User Superiority: The Symbol Error Rate (SER) for the cell-edge user ($U_2$) is significantly lower (better) using the proposed NOMA with JML compared to both standard Orthogonal Multiple Access (OMA) and NOMA using only SIC.
  • Minimal Average Penalty: While the average SER across all users is slightly higher than OMA, the "marginal degradation" is a small price to pay for the massive reliability boost given to the weakest user in the system.
  • Analytical Validation: The authors derived closed-form expressions for the SER, and their simulation results (plotted between 110 dB and 160 dB Transmit SNR) matched these theoretical predictions almost perfectly.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Scalability: The study focuses on a relatively simple 2-cell, 3-user model. In a large office or warehouse with dozens of LEDs, the complexity of JML decoding could grow exponentially (the "curse of dimensionality").
  • Perfect CSI Assumption: The analysis assumes "Perfect Channel State Information," meaning the receivers know exactly how the signal is being attenuated. In real-world moving environments, tracking this perfectly is difficult.
  • Future Directions: The authors suggest that future work could explore lower-complexity versions of JML or adaptive power allocation strategies to further optimize the balance between computational cost and error performance.

Summary updated

Abstract

In this letter, we propose a non-orthogonal multiple access (NOMA) based scheme for multi-cell indoor visible light communications (VLC), where cell-edge user is jointly served by multiple cells. Unlike the typical designs in NOMA-VLC literature, the proposed scheme doesn’t involve complex domain and direct current bias addition, which makes the design simple and feasible for real time implementation in indoor VLC. The symbol error rate (SER) of the proposed NOMA scheme is analysed using simulation results, and is compared with orthogonal multiple access (OMA). It is observed that the average SER of the users with the proposed NOMA is marginally degraded as compared to OMA. However, the SER of cell-edge user with the proposed NOMA is significantly improved with joint maximum likelihood decoding, and outperforms successive interference cancellation based decoding and OMA, with trade-off on computational complexity.
BibTeX
@article{thummaluri2022joint,
  author = {Uday Thummaluri and Abhinav Kumar and Lakshmi Natarajan},
  title = {{Joint NOMA for Improved SER of Cell-Edge Users in Multi-Cell Indoor VLC}},
  journal = {IEEE Wireless Communications Letters},
  year = {2022},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=T5XtwG-LIn},
}

Loading related content...

Figure