Iterative feature selection in least square regression estimation

Pierre Alquier

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel iterative feature selection algorithm for regression estimation that works in both inductive and transductive settings. The algorithm leverages PAC (Probably Approximately Correct) inequalities to iteratively refine an estimator, guaranteeing that each step improves performance. This approach achieves optimal convergence rates in Sobolev and Besov spaces, offering a statistically grounded alternative to existing greedy methods.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Estimating regression functions, especially in high-dimensional settings, often involves selecting the most relevant features from a large dictionary of potential predictors. Traditional methods like greedy algorithms can be prone to overfitting and lack strong theoretical guarantees. The authors address this by proposing an iterative feature selection algorithm that is statistically motivated, providing theoretical guarantees against overlearning. They tackle both the inductive setting (where the data distribution is known) and the transductive setting (where it's not), arguing that the latter is a more natural application for their method and has practical relevance in scenarios like quality control or sample surveys.

Methods

The core of the paper is a new algorithm for regression estimation that iteratively refines an estimator. The estimator is a linear combination of functions from a given dictionary. The key innovation lies in the selection of features and the update of coefficients. This is achieved by projecting the current estimator onto simple confidence regions derived from PAC inequalities. The algorithm guarantees that each projection step improves the estimator's performance. The authors provide theoretical bounds (PAC inequalities) for the estimator's risk in one-dimensional models, which then form the basis for the iterative selection procedure. They also establish a connection to oracle inequalities, allowing them to prove that their estimator achieves minimax rates of convergence in Sobolev and Besov spaces.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on theoretical development and algorithmic guarantees rather than empirical evaluation on specific datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Statistically Motivated Feature Selection: Unlike many existing greedy algorithms that are driven by algorithmic efficiency, this method's iterative updates are based on statistical guarantees (PAC inequalities), providing a stronger theoretical foundation against overfitting.
  • Transductive Setting Advantage: The algorithm is particularly well-suited for the transductive setting, where the distribution of the design (input features) is unknown. This makes it more broadly applicable in real-world scenarios where such information is often unavailable.
  • Guaranteed Improvement: Each step of the algorithm is proven to improve the estimator, ensuring a progressive refinement towards a better solution.
  • Optimal Convergence Rates: The connection to oracle inequalities allows the authors to demonstrate that their method achieves minimax rates of convergence in function spaces like Sobolev and Besov, a significant theoretical achievement.

Key Results

The paper presents several key theoretical results:

  • PAC Inequalities: The authors derive PAC inequalities for the risk of their estimators in one-dimensional models, providing probabilistic bounds on the error.
  • Iterative Algorithm Guarantees: They prove that their iterative feature selection algorithm, both in the inductive and transductive settings, guarantees that each projection step improves the estimator's performance.
  • Adaptivity to Regularity: The algorithm is shown to be adaptive to the unknown regularity of the true regression function, achieving optimal convergence rates (up to a log factor) in Sobolev and Besov spaces. For instance, in Sobolev spaces, the convergence rate is shown to be $N^{-2\beta/(2\beta+1)} \log N$, where $\beta$ is the unknown regularity.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Computational Complexity: While the algorithm is statistically grounded, the paper mentions that choosing the best feature at each step can be computationally intensive, suggesting the use of heuristics or skipping the maximization step.
  • Generalization to Higher Dimensions: The paper focuses on one-dimensional models for deriving the core inequalities but discusses the potential for generalization to higher dimensions, with some results presented.
  • Empirical Validation: The paper is primarily theoretical. While it mentions connections to existing methods and provides pseudo-code, extensive empirical validation on diverse datasets is not presented. Future work could involve a thorough empirical study to compare its performance against state-of-the-art methods.
  • Parameter Selection: The choice of parameters like $\epsilon$ and $m$ (number of features considered) can influence performance and might require further investigation for optimal practical application.

Summary updated

Abstract

Cette article présente un nouvel algorithme d’estimation de régression, dans les contextes inductifs et transductifs. L’estimateur est défini par une combinaison linéaire de fonctions choisies dans un dictionnaire donné. Les coefficients de cette combinaison sont calculés par des projections successives sur des ensembles simples. Ces ensembles sont définis comme des régions de confiance données par une inégalité de déviation (ou inégalité PAC). On démontre en particulier que chaque projection au cours de l’algorithme améliore effectivement l’estimateur obtenu. On donne tout d’abord les résultats dans le contexte inductif, où l’algorithme nécessite la connaissance de la distribution du design, puis dans le contexte transductif, plus naturel ici puisque l’algorithme s’applique sans la connaissance de cette distribution. On établit finalement un lien avec les inégalités d’oracle, permettant de montrer que notre estimateur atteint les vitesses optimales dans les espaces de Sobolev et de Besov.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{alquier2008iterative,
  author = {Pierre Alquier},
  title = {{Iterative feature selection in least square regression estimation}},
  booktitle = {Annales},
  year = {2008},
  doi = {10.1214/07-aihp106},
}
Figure