Abstract
In recent years, plastic pipes have become preferred in heating systems due to their lightweight nature and resistance to corrosion. Selecting the appropriate pump for a heating installation requires determining the total pressure loss of the critical circuit alongside the water flow rate at the boiler outlet. While friction pressure drop gradient (SBKG) tables for steel pipes at various temperature differences ($\Delta T$) are well-established, there is a lack of similar high-resolution data for plastic pipes, particularly at $\Delta T = 10^\circ C$. This study generates these necessary charts using standardized plastic pipe diameters and compares the pressure loss values between steel and plastic pipe implementations in a sample installation.
Introduction
In HVAC engineering, sizing a pump correctly is a critical balancing act. An undersized pump fails to deliver heat to the furthest radiators, while an oversized pump leads to energy waste and acoustic issues within the piping. Accurate calculation of the "critical circuit" pressure drop is essential for optimal pump selection.
While traditional steel pipes have long-standing reference charts, the industry is increasingly adopting plastic pipes (such as PEX or PP-R). These materials offer significant advantages, including ease of installation and immunity to the internal corrosion that eventually restricts flow in steel systems. Furthermore, the prevalence of high-efficiency condensing boilers has shifted standard operating temperature differences toward $\Delta T = 10^\circ C$. Most legacy engineering literature provides data for $\Delta T$ of $1^\circ C$ or $20^\circ C$, leaving a practical data gap for modern system designs.
Methodology
The researchers developed a numerical approach to generate precise friction loss tables for plastic pipes. The methodology centered on two fundamental fluid dynamics equations: the Darcy-Weisbach equation for defining the pressure drop gradient ($R$) and the Colebrook-White equation for determining the friction factor ($f$).
Because the Colebrook equation is implicit—with the friction factor appearing on both sides—an iterative numerical solution is required. The authors implemented a computational algorithm to solve this until the relative error reached a negligible threshold ($<10^{-9}$).
The calculations utilized standardized pipe dimensions from DIN 8077 for plastic and DIN 2440 for steel. To validate the utility of these new charts, a comprehensive head-loss calculation was performed for a sample multi-story building project, comparing plastic and steel performance while accounting for modern components like heat cost allocators.
Key Results and Discussion
The study successfully produced detailed reference tables mapping heat load ($Q$) and water velocity ($u$) against the pressure drop gradient ($R$) for a wide array of pipe diameters (14mm to 160mm).
The comparative analysis yielded several key findings:
- Reduced Pressure Drop: In the sample building project, the total pressure drop for the plastic pipe system was 2.85 mSS (meters of water column), compared to 3.19 mSS for the steel system. This represents an approximate 12% reduction in pressure loss.
- Surface Smoothness: The primary driver for this efficiency is the significantly lower absolute roughness ($\varepsilon$) of plastic pipes compared to steel. This inherent "smoothness" directly translates to lower pumping power requirements.
- Economic Considerations: Beyond hydraulic efficiency, the authors noted that for smaller diameters (under 30mm internal diameter), plastic is often more cost-effective in terms of material. For larger diameters, while steel material costs may be lower, plastic often remains the superior choice when labor and installation speed are factored in.
Conclusion
This research provides a vital tool for modern HVAC design by filling the data gap for plastic pipe friction losses at $\Delta T = 10^\circ C$. The resulting charts allow engineers to select smaller, more energy-efficient pumps with greater confidence. While the study assumes constant pipe roughness over time, the immediate hydraulic benefits of switching to plastic—demonstrated by a 12% reduction in critical circuit pressure loss—are clear. Future work could further refine these models by investigating the long-term effects of biofilm or mineral scaling on the friction gradients of various polymer materials.
Summary updated