Isospin magnetic texture and intervalley exchange interaction in rhombohedral tetralayer graphene

Nadav Auerbach, S. K. Dutta, Matan Uzan, Yaar Vituri, Yaozhang Zhou, Alexander Y. Meltzer, Sameer Grover, Tobias Holder, Peleg Emanuel, M. E. Huber, Y. Myasoedov, Kenji Watanabe, Takashi Taniguchi, Yuval Oreg, Erez Berg, E. ZeldovNature Physics 2025 · DOI

TL;DR

Researchers have developed a nanoscale imaging technique to map the intricate "isospin" magnetic textures in tetralayer graphene. This allows them to experimentally determine the strength of fundamental interactions, revealing crucial insights into the exotic electronic states and phase transitions in this promising material.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Graphene, particularly in its multilayer forms like rhombohedral tetralayer graphene (RMG), exhibits fascinating "correlated electronic states." These states arise from the complex interplay of electron spin, their "valley" degree of freedom (a property related to their momentum), and interactions like spin-orbit coupling and Hund's exchange. These interactions can lead to "isospin order," where spin and valley degrees of freedom align in specific ways, creating magnetic textures. However, a major challenge has been the lack of experimental methods to directly visualize these local isospin textures and precisely measure the energies of the underlying interactions. This paper aims to bridge that gap by developing and applying a technique to map these textures and quantify these crucial interaction energies.

Methods

The core of this work lies in the application of a nanoscale superconducting quantum interference device (SQUID-on-tip, SOT). This highly sensitive probe allows for local magnetic imaging with exquisite spatial resolution. The researchers used this SOT to map the stray magnetic fields generated by the magnetic textures within the graphene. By carefully modulating the carrier density in the graphene with gate voltages and applying external magnetic fields, they could induce and probe sharp magnetic phase transitions. They also employed transport measurements, specifically measuring the longitudinal resistance (Rxx), to identify different electronic phases and their transitions. Furthermore, they utilized self-consistent Hartree-Fock (scHF) calculations to model the electronic behavior and compare theoretical predictions with experimental observations. A key aspect of their analysis involved reconstructing the local differential magnetization from the measured stray magnetic fields, allowing them to infer the underlying magnetic textures.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Visualizing the Invisible: The development and application of the SOT technique for mapping local isospin textures in graphene is a significant advancement, moving beyond bulk measurements to spatially resolved imaging.
  • Unraveling Interaction Strengths: The ability to experimentally determine bounds on spin-orbit coupling and intervalley Hund's exchange energies provides crucial quantitative data for understanding the complex electronic correlations in RMG.
  • Phase Transition Hierarchy: The work sheds light on the sequence of symmetry-breaking transitions in RMG, from a metallic phase to half-metal and quarter-metal phases, and how these are influenced by interactions and external fields.
  • Isospin Anisotropy: The study reveals a stark difference in magnetic anisotropy between the half-metal (nearly isotropic) and quarter-metal (strongly anisotropic) phases, offering clues about the underlying physics.
  • Hund's Coupling Dominance: The findings suggest that intervalley Hund's exchange plays a dominant role in shaping the low-energy physics of RMG, particularly in suppressing spin anisotropy in the half-metal phase.

Key Results

  • Sharp Magnetic Phase Transitions: The SOT imaging revealed sharp magnetic phase transitions, indicating spontaneous time-reversal symmetry breaking.
  • Bound on Spin-Orbit Coupling: In the quarter-metal phase, the close alignment of spin and orbital moments provided a bound on the spin-orbit coupling energy, estimated to be at least 120 μeV.
  • Lower Bound on Hund's Exchange: The half-metal phase exhibited very small magnetic anisotropy, which allowed researchers to experimentally determine a lower bound for the intervalley Hund's exchange interaction energy of > 6.5 meV. This value is significantly larger than previously assumed.
  • Isotropic vs. Anisotropic Magnetism: The 1/2M phase was found to be nearly isotropic in its magnetism, while the 1/4M phase showed strong easy-axis anisotropy.
  • Agreement with Theory: The experimental results showed good agreement with theoretical predictions from scHF calculations, validating the models used.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Strain Effects: The authors acknowledge that the impact of strain on local magnetization orientation is generally limited but not fully understood. They suggest that while strain-induced variations in anisotropy are likely small, they could be a factor in future studies.
  • Momentum-Dependent Coupling: The analysis assumed momentum-independent Hund's coupling. Future work could explore the effects of k-dependent coupling.
  • Further Exploration of Phases: The paper hints at the existence of more complex phases and transitions within the main phases (e.g., PSP-M, PVP-1/2M). Further investigation into these finer details could provide deeper insights.
  • Superconducting Phases: While this paper focuses on magnetic textures, the authors note that RMG is a platform for exploring superconducting phases, and understanding the magnetic correlations is crucial for unraveling the mechanisms behind superconductivity in these systems.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract The tunable band structure and non-trivial topology of multilayer rhombohedral graphene lead to a variety of correlated electronic states with isospin orders—meaning ordered states in the combined spin and valley degrees of freedom—dictated by the interplay of spin–orbit coupling and Hund’s exchange interactions. However, methods for mapping local isospin textures and determining the exchange energies are currently lacking. Here we image the magnetization textures in tetralayer rhombohedral graphene using a nanoscale superconducting quantum interference device. We observe sharp magnetic phase transitions that indicate spontaneous time-reversal symmetry breaking. In the quarter-metal phase, the spin and orbital moments align closely, providing a bound on the spin–orbit-coupling energy. We also show that the half-metal phase has a very small magnetic anisotropy, which provides an experimental lower bound on the intervalley Hund’s exchange interaction energy. This is found to be close to its theoretical upper bound. The ability to resolve the local isospin texture and the different interaction energies will allow a better understanding of the phase transition hierarchy and the numerous correlated electronic states arising from spontaneous and induced isospin symmetry breaking in graphene heterostructures.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{auerbach2025isospin,
  author = {Nadav Auerbach and S. K. Dutta and Matan Uzan and Yaar Vituri and Yaozhang Zhou and Alexander Y. Meltzer and Sameer Grover and Tobias Holder and Peleg Emanuel and M. E. Huber and Y. Myasoedov and Kenji Watanabe and Takashi Taniguchi and Yuval Oreg and Erez Berg and E. Zeldov},
  title = {{Isospin magnetic texture and intervalley exchange interaction in rhombohedral tetralayer graphene}},
  booktitle = {Nature Physics},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.1038/s41567-025-03035-z},
}
Figure