Isometric spiracular scaling in scarab beetles—implications for diffusive and advective oxygen transport

Julian M. Wagner, Jaco Klok, Meghan Duell, John J. Socha, Guohua Cao, Hao Gong, Jon F. Harrison

TL;DR

This study reveals that insect spiracles scale isometrically with body size, meaning their dimensions increase proportionally with mass. This geometric scaling enhances advective (bulk flow) oxygen transport but diminishes diffusive transport, forcing larger beetles to rely heavily on bulk airflow for respiration, especially during high-demand activities like flight.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

A fundamental question in biology is how animals manage to supply oxygen to their tissues as they increase in size. As an animal grows, its volume (and thus oxygen demand) increases cubically with linear dimensions, while its surface area (a potential site for gas exchange) increases quadratically. This creates a "surface area to volume" problem. For gas exchange, this means that diffusion alone may become insufficient for larger animals. While this scaling problem has been extensively studied in vertebrates, it's less understood in invertebrates, which represent the vast majority of animal species. Insects, with their unique tracheal respiratory system, offer a particularly interesting case. This paper specifically investigates how the spiracles – the external openings to the insect tracheal system – scale with body size and what implications this has for oxygen transport, particularly in large scarab beetles.

Methods

The researchers employed X-ray microtomography (micro-CT) to create detailed 3D reconstructions of the spiracles of 10 species of scarab beetles, spanning a significant range of body masses. From these scans, they measured the cross-sectional area and depth of each of the eight spiracles per beetle. Using these measurements, they calculated the diffusive and advective capacities of the spiracles. Diffusive capacity was modeled using Fick's law, relating it to area and depth. Advective capacity was modeled using Poiseuille's law, considering area, depth, and fluid viscosity. Statistical analyses, including phylogenetic generalized least squares (pGLS) and Bayesian regression, were used to determine scaling relationships while accounting for evolutionary relatedness between species.

Datasets

The study utilized data from 17 individual scarab beetles across 10 species, with body masses ranging from 0.097 g to 18 g. The specific species included: Goliathus goliathus, Coelorrhina hornimani, Dicronorrhina derbyana, Mecynorrhina torquata, Eudicella euthalia, Protaetia orientalis, Popilia japonica, Trypoxylus dichotomus, Dynastes hercules, and Cyclocephalis borealis. This collection represents some of the largest extant insect species.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Geometric Isometry is Key: The most striking finding is that spiracle dimensions (area and depth) scale isometrically with body mass. This means that as a beetle gets bigger, its spiracles get proportionally bigger in a simple geometric way, rather than scaling in a way that would try to compensate for the surface-area-to-volume problem.
  • Diffusion Becomes a Bottleneck: Because diffusive capacity scales with a lower exponent than metabolic rate, diffusion alone becomes increasingly insufficient for oxygen supply in larger beetles. This implies that larger beetles require significantly steeper oxygen gradients across their spiracles to meet their metabolic demands via diffusion.
  • Advection is the Hero: In contrast to diffusion, advective (bulk flow) capacity scales similarly or even more steeply than metabolic rates. This suggests that larger beetles are well-equipped to move air in and out of their bodies via bulk flow, which is crucial for meeting high oxygen demands.
  • Flight Demands Advection: While diffusion might suffice for resting metabolism in even large beetles, it's clearly insufficient for the high metabolic rates required during flight. This reinforces the idea that advective transport is essential for active, larger insects.
  • No Size Limit Imposed by Spiracles: The study concludes that the scaling of spiracles doesn't inherently limit insect size. Instead, the enhanced advective capacity, coupled with muscle-driven ventilation, allows larger animals to achieve high metabolic rates.

Key Results

  • Spiracle area and depth scaled with geometric isometry (slopes close to 0.67 for area and 0.33 for depth, respectively, when considering mass).
  • The combined diffusive capacity of all spiracles scaled with a slope of approximately 0.39, which was significantly lower than typical metabolic scaling exponents (around 0.75 for resting metabolism).
  • The required partial pressure gradient for oxygen (ΔPO2) across spiracles to support diffusive gas exchange increased by an order of magnitude from the smallest to the largest beetles studied.
  • For flight, the required ΔPO2 could exceed atmospheric oxygen levels (21 kPa) in larger beetles, indicating diffusion is impossible under these conditions.
  • The advective capacity of the spiracles scaled with an exponent of approximately 1.1, which matches or exceeds typical flight metabolic rate scaling exponents.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Simplified Model: The spiracles were modeled as simple cylinders, which may not fully capture the complex morphology and potential for active valve control in living insects.
  • Static vs. Dynamic: Measurements were made on sacrificed specimens. Studying living insects could reveal how dynamic control of spiracle shape and valves influences airflow.
  • Tracheal System Unknowns: This study focused solely on spiracles. The resistance and scaling of the internal tracheal system (tracheae and tracheoles) are largely unknown and could significantly impact overall gas exchange efficiency.
  • Phylogenetic Signal Uncertainty: While phylogenetic analyses were attempted, the degree of phylogenetic signal was non-identifiable, leading the authors to rely more on nonparametric bootstrapping.

Future work could involve investigating the internal tracheal system's scaling, exploring the role of active spiracle control in living insects, and examining a wider range of insect taxa to see if these isometric scaling patterns are universal. Understanding how tracheal collapse contributes to advective airflow in different species and sizes is also a promising avenue.

Summary updated

Abstract

The scaling of respiratory structures has been hypothesized to be a major driving factor in the evolution of many aspects of animal physiology. Here, we provide the first assessment of the scaling of the spiracles in insects using 10 scarab beetle species differing 180× in mass, including some of the most massive extant insect species. Using X-ray microtomography, we measured the cross-sectional area and depth of all eight spiracles, enabling the calculation of their diffusive and advective capacities. Each of these metrics scaled with geometric isometry. Because diffusive capacities scale with lower slopes than metabolic rates, the largest beetles measured require 10-fold higher <i>P</i><sub>O2</sub> gradients across the spiracles to sustain metabolism by diffusion compared to the smallest species. Large beetles can exchange sufficient oxygen for resting metabolism by diffusion across the spiracles, but not during flight. In contrast, spiracular advective capacities scale similarly or more steeply than metabolic rates, so spiracular advective capacities should match or exceed respiratory demands in the largest beetles. These data illustrate a general principle of gas exchange: scaling of respiratory transport structures with geometric isometry diminishes the potential for diffusive gas exchange but enhances advective capacities; combining such structural scaling with muscle-driven ventilation allows larger animals to achieve high metabolic rates when active.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{wagner2022isometric,
  author = {Julian M. Wagner and Jaco Klok and Meghan Duell and John J. Socha and Guohua Cao and Hao Gong and Jon F. Harrison},
  title = {{Isometric spiracular scaling in scarab beetles—implications for diffusive and advective oxygen transport}},
  booktitle = {eLife},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.7554/elife.82129},
}
Figure