Investment Decisions of CCUS Projects in China Considering the Supply–Demand Relationship of CO2 from the Industry Symbiosis Perspective

Bo Sun, Jiajia TaoSustainability 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper explores investment decisions for Carbon Capture, Utilization, and Storage (CCUS) projects in China, focusing on how industrial symbiosis between coal-fired power plants (CFPPs) and oil companies can overcome high costs and uncertainties. By modeling CCUS projects through the lens of industrial symbiosis and using real options theory, the study finds that collaboration significantly lowers investment thresholds and increases project value, especially when CO2 supply and demand are balanced.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

China, a major carbon emitter, aims for carbon neutrality by 2060. Coal-fired power plants (CFPPs) are significant contributors to emissions, making Carbon Capture, Utilization, and Storage (CCUS) technology crucial for their decarbonization. However, CCUS projects are capital-intensive, technologically complex, and face policy uncertainties, hindering independent investment. This paper addresses the challenge of promoting CCUS adoption by investigating how industrial symbiosis—where CFPPs capture CO2 and oil companies utilize it for Enhanced Oil Recovery (EOR)—can create a more economically viable pathway. The study aims to quantify the benefits of this symbiotic approach compared to independent investments by CFPPs (for Carbon Capture and Storage - CCS) and oil companies (for EOR), considering the interplay of CO2 supply-demand, carbon and oil prices, and technological advancements.

Methods

The study employs real options theory (RO) to model investment decisions under uncertainty. This approach treats investment opportunities as options, allowing for flexibility in timing. The authors develop distinct decision models for:

  1. Independent CFPP investment: A CCS project where the CFPP captures and stores CO2.
  2. Independent oil company investment: An EOR project where the oil company purchases CO2 for enhanced oil recovery.
  3. Cooperative CCUS investment: A symbiotic model where a CFPP and an oil company collaborate, with the CFPP supplying CO2 to the oil company for EOR.

Key to the cooperative model is the consideration of the CO2 supply-demand relationship between the CFPP and the oil company. The models incorporate uncertainties in carbon and oil prices, technological progress, and investment subsidies. The mathematical framework involves solving second-order partial differential equations derived from the real options framework to determine optimal investment thresholds and option values.

Datasets

The study uses a case study of a CCUS project in Guangdong Province, China, for empirical analysis. Specific parameters for the CFPP (600 MW capacity, 15-year operation) and the EOR project are drawn from existing literature and industry data. This includes:

  • Initial CCS investment cost: USD 60.22 million
  • CO2 transportation and storage costs: 14.08 USD/t and 7.04 USD/ton, respectively
  • Carbon trading price: Initial 7.8 USD/ton, volatility 0.03, growth rate 0.025
  • Initial EOR investment cost: USD 27.25 million
  • Oil price: Average WTI price in 2021-2022 (initial 80.9 USD/barrel), volatility 0.21, growth rate 0.04

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Industrial symbiosis is a game-changer: The core idea is that by linking CFPPs and oil companies, the entire CCUS value chain becomes more efficient and less risky. This collaboration unlocks value that neither entity can achieve alone.
  • CO2 supply-demand balance is optimal: The study highlights that a perfect match between CO2 captured by the CFPP and CO2 needed by the oil company (λ=1) significantly reduces investment thresholds and maximizes option values. Imbalances create inefficiencies and increase costs.
  • Price volatility is a double-edged sword: While stable carbon and oil prices are preferred for investment, the study shows that industrial symbiosis can mitigate the negative impacts of price volatility, making CCUS projects more resilient.
  • Technological progress is critical: Reductions in CCS technology costs, driven by R&D, are essential for lowering initial investment barriers, especially since carbon capture is a significant cost component.

Key Results

  • Reduced Investment Thresholds: Industrial symbiosis reduces the investment threshold for CCUS projects by at least 25.42% compared to independent investment modes.
  • Increased Option Value: The option value of CCUS projects increases by at least 12.94% under industrial symbiosis.
  • Impact of CO2 Balance: When CO2 supply and demand are balanced (λ=1), the investment threshold is lowest. For example, with a carbon trading price of 45.95 USD/ton, the oil price threshold for immediate investment is 75.72 USD/barrel.
  • Price Volatility Effects: Increased carbon trading price volatility (σc) and oil price volatility (σo) lead to higher investment thresholds for both independent and symbiotic CCUS projects. However, symbiosis consistently lowers these thresholds. For instance, as σc increases from 0.01 to 0.05, the CCUS project's investment threshold (λ=1) increases from 17.21 to 35.74 USD/ton.
  • Technological Progress Impact: CCS technological progress (α) and EOR technological progress (β) negatively affect investment thresholds, meaning higher progress leads to lower thresholds. For example, an increase in α from 2% to 10% decreases the CCUS project's investment threshold (λ=1) from 34.81 to 23.83 USD/ton.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Ecological Benefits Not Quantified: The study focuses on economic aspects and does not quantify the broader ecological benefits of industrial symbiosis. Future research could incorporate these.
  • Fixed Industrial CO2 Price: The model assumes a fixed price for industrial CO2, whereas in reality, this price is also subject to uncertainty. Future work could employ stochastic models to account for this.

The study suggests that governments should:

  • Encourage industrial symbiosis through subsidies or penalties.
  • Build industrial collaboration networks to balance CO2 supply and demand.
  • Invest in R&D to accelerate technological progress in carbon capture.
  • Implement policies to stabilize oil and carbon trading prices to enhance investor confidence.

Summary updated

Abstract

Carbon capture, utilization, and storage (CCUS) technology is vital for China to achieve its carbon neutrality goal. However, the high cost of CCUS projects, multiple processes, and insufficient policy support make it difficult for firms to invest independently. As an innovative way to achieve waste resource utilization, industrial symbiosis can effectively break through this dilemma. Based on the real options theory, this study establishes decision models for independent investment in a carbon capture and storage project by a coal-fired power plant (CFPP) and independent investment in an enhanced oil recovery project by an oil company. Then, from the perspective of industrial symbiosis, the decision models of cooperative investment in a CCUS project by a CFPP and an oil company are constructed. The models consider the supply–demand relationship of CO2, the correlation between carbon and oil prices, and technological uncertainty. The differential equation method is used to solve the models to obtain the investment thresholds and option values. Finally, all models are applied to a CCUS project in Guangdong Province, China, for simulation analyses. Based on the simulation results of the CCUS project in Guangdong Province, our major findings are as follows: (1) Industrial symbiosis can effectively promote the development of CCUS projects. Compared with the independent investment mode, industrial symbiosis reduces the investment threshold of the project by at least 25.42% and increases the option value by at least 12.94%. (2) It is more likely to trigger the project’s investment when CO2 supply and demand are balanced. The CCUS project’s investment threshold increases with the imbalance between CO2 supply and demand. (3) Stable carbon and oil prices can promote the project’s investment, and increasing the positive correlation coefficient of the prices will increase the project’s investment threshold.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{sun2024investment,
  author = {Bo Sun and Jiajia Tao},
  title = {{Investment Decisions of CCUS Projects in China Considering the Supply–Demand Relationship of CO2 from the Industry Symbiosis Perspective}},
  booktitle = {Sustainability},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.3390/su16125273},
}
Figure