Investigation on the Melting Performance of a Phase Change Material Based on a Shell-and-Tube Thermal Energy Storage Unit with a Rectangular Fin Configuration

Meng Yu, Xiao Wei Sun, Wenjuan Su, Defeng Li, Jun Shen, Xuejun Zhang, L. JiangEnergies 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper investigates the melting performance of a novel shell-and-tube thermal energy storage unit enhanced with rectangular fins, using paraffin wax as the phase change material (PCM). The study demonstrates that these fins significantly improve melting efficiency, with higher inlet heat transfer fluid (HTF) temperatures being more impactful than flow rate for faster charging.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The increasing demand for renewable energy sources, coupled with the inherent mismatch between energy supply and demand, highlights the critical need for effective thermal energy storage (TES) solutions. Latent heat thermal energy storage (LTES) using phase change materials (PCMs) is particularly promising due to its high energy storage density and stable discharge temperature. However, a major bottleneck for PCMs, especially paraffin wax, is their low thermal conductivity, which retards melting and solidification processes, thus limiting TES efficiency. While fins are a common enhancement strategy, research on specific fin geometries and their interaction with operating parameters in shell-and-tube configurations, particularly with experimental visualization, remains an active area. This paper addresses this gap by experimentally investigating a shell-and-tube LTES unit with a novel rectangular fin configuration and analyzing the influence of key operating parameters (HTF temperature and flow rate) on its melting performance.

Methods

The researchers designed and manufactured a shell-and-tube LTES unit featuring a novel rectangular fin configuration. Paraffin wax was used as the PCM, and circulated water served as the heat transfer fluid (HTF). The experimental setup included a hot water tank, circulating pump, PCM unit, flow meter, and thermocouples for temperature monitoring at various points within the unit.

Key experimental procedures and analyses included:

  • Material Characterization: Differential Scanning Calorimetry (DSC) was used to determine the thermophysical properties of the paraffin wax, including its phase change temperature and latent heat.
  • Experimental Setup: A detailed schematic and photographic representation of the experimental setup are provided, highlighting the placement of thermocouples for temperature field monitoring.
  • Experimental Procedure: The unit was filled with melted paraffin wax, and experiments were conducted by circulating hot water at controlled temperatures and flow rates. Melting photographs were taken at different stages to visualize the process.
  • Performance Evaluation: TES characteristics indexes, specifically total charging time ($t_{ch}$) and average charging rate ($P_{ch}$), were used to quantitatively evaluate the melting performance.
  • Uncertainty Analysis: A root mean square method was employed to estimate the uncertainty in the experimental results.
  • Parameter Variation: Case studies were performed by varying the inlet HTF temperature (57 °C and 68 °C) and HTF flow rate (4, 7, and 10 L/min) while keeping other parameters constant.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on experimental data collected from the designed LTES unit.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Rectangular Fins Enhance Melting: The presence of rectangular fins significantly improves the melting performance of the shell-and-tube LTES unit compared to a finless design. This is attributed to the increased heat transfer area provided by the fins.
  • Conduction to Convection Transition: The melting process initially starts with heat conduction, but as more liquid PCM forms, natural convection becomes a dominant factor, accelerating the melting rate.
  • HTF Temperature is King: The inlet HTF temperature has a much more significant impact on melting performance than the HTF flow rate. Higher temperatures lead to faster melting and shorter charging times.
  • Optimal Operating Conditions: A higher inlet HTF temperature and a lower HTF flow rate are recommended for improved energy storage efficiency and reduced energy consumption.

Key Results

  • Significant Improvement with Fins: While not quantified against a finless baseline in this specific paper, the visual evidence and discussion strongly suggest substantial performance gains due to the rectangular fins.
  • Impact of HTF Temperature: Increasing the inlet HTF temperature from 57 °C to 68 °C resulted in:
  • A 62.38% reduction in total charging time.
  • A 165.51% increase in the average charging rate.
  • Limited Impact of HTF Flow Rate: Varying the HTF flow rate between 4, 7, and 10 L/min showed negligible influence on the melting performance. For instance, increasing the flow rate from 7 to 10 L/min only reduced the charging time by 2.63% and increased the average charging rate by 0.53%.
  • Visual Confirmation: Melting photographs clearly illustrate the progression of PCM melting, showing the initial solid-liquid interface and the subsequent expansion of the liquid phase, driven by conduction and then convection.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Single Tube Unit: The study focused on a single-tube shell-and-tube unit. The authors plan to extend this research to multi-tubular heat exchanger devices for practical applications in heat pump systems.
  • Paraffin Wax Specifics: While paraffin wax is a common PCM, its specific properties (e.g., melting point) might limit its applicability in certain temperature ranges.
  • No Finless Comparison Data: While the benefits of fins are discussed, direct quantitative comparison data against an identical unit without fins is not presented in this paper.

Future work will involve applying the rectangular fin configuration to multi-tubular heat exchangers and further optimizing TES systems for various applications.

Summary updated

Abstract

A case study on the melting performance of a shell-and-tube phase change material (PCM) thermal energy storage unit with a novel rectangular fin configuration is conducted in this paper. Paraffin wax and circulated water are employed as the PCM and heat transfer fluid (HTF), respectively. It can be observed that the melting performance could be significantly improved by using rectangular fins. Melting photographs demonstrate that the melting of the PCM is firstly dominated by heat conduction; then, the melting rate is improved further due to natural convection. Moreover, the results illustrate that the influence of the inlet HTF temperature on the melting performance is significantly greater than that of the inlet HTF flow rate. The liquid fraction of paraffin wax in the PCM unit with a higher inlet HTF temperature is always higher than that with a lower inlet HTF temperature at the same time. The total charging time is reduced by 62.38% and the average charging rate is increased by 165.51% when the inlet HTF temperature is increased from 57 °C to 68 °C. As a result, a higher value of the inlet HTF temperature and a lower value of the HTF flow rate are able to improve the energy efficiency of the PCM unit with a rectangular fin configuration.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{yu2022investigation,
  author = {Meng Yu and Xiao Wei Sun and Wenjuan Su and Defeng Li and Jun Shen and Xuejun Zhang and L. Jiang},
  title = {{Investigation on the Melting Performance of a Phase Change Material Based on a Shell-and-Tube Thermal Energy Storage Unit with a Rectangular Fin Configuration}},
  booktitle = {Energies},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3390/en15218200},
}
Figure