Investigation and Modeling of Multi-Node Body Channel Wireless Power Transfer

Yuxuan Huang, Jian Zhao, Wenyu Sun, Huazhong Yang, Yongpan Liu

TL;DR

This paper tackles the challenge of powering multiple devices in wireless body area networks (WBANs) by investigating body channel wireless power transfer (BC-WPT). The authors develop an empirical circuit model to accurately predict power transfer to multiple harvesters, addressing the "inter-degeneration" effect where devices interfere with each other, and provide design guidelines for future BC-WPT systems.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Wireless Body Area Networks (WBANs) are becoming increasingly prevalent for health monitoring, with numerous wearable sensors collecting vital data. A significant hurdle for these devices is their power supply. Miniaturized sensor nodes often have limited battery capacity, leading to frequent charging or replacement, which is inconvenient and can compromise the continuous operation of the WBAN. Traditional wireless power transfer (WPT) methods, like inductive coupling, often require bulky coils and precise alignment, making them unsuitable for small, flexible WBAN nodes.

Body Channel Wireless Power Transfer (BC-WPT) offers a promising alternative. It leverages the human body itself as a transmission medium, requiring only small electrodes and avoiding the need for large antennas or coils. This makes it ideal for miniaturized WBAN nodes. However, research on BC-WPT, particularly in scenarios with multiple power receivers (harvesters) operating simultaneously, is limited. A key challenge in multi-node BC-WPT is the "inter-degeneration" effect, where the presence and operation of one harvester can negatively impact the power received by others. This paper aims to investigate and model this inter-degeneration mechanism to enable efficient multi-node BC-WPT.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-faceted approach combining theoretical analysis, simulation, and experimental validation.

  • Theoretical Analysis: They started by analyzing the behavior of single-source single-harvester (SSSH) BC-WPT systems using simplified equivalent circuit models. This analysis helped identify key factors influencing power transfer, such as distance, frequency, and electrode area. They then extended this to the multi-node scenario, specifically the single-source multi-harvester (SSMH) case, to understand the inter-degeneration mechanism.
  • Co-Simulation: To model the complex interactions within the human body and the BC-WPT system, they utilized a co-simulation platform combining Computer Simulation Technology (CST) for modeling the human body's electromagnetic properties and Cadence for circuit simulation. This allowed them to create an S-parameter model of the body channel.
  • Empirical Circuit Model: Recognizing the limitations of black-box S-parameter models for understanding design parameters, the authors developed an empirical circuit model. This model aims to capture the relationship between key physical factors (distance, frequency, electrode area) and the received power. Circuit parameters were extracted from simulation data.
  • Experimental Validation: To confirm their simulation results and the validity of their empirical model, they conducted experiments using a physical setup that mimicked the simulation environment. They measured received power under various conditions and compared it with simulation outcomes.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on simulated human body models and experimental measurements rather than pre-existing datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Inter-degeneration is Real and Significant: The study confirms that in multi-node BC-WPT, harvesters indeed interfere with each other, reducing the power received by individual devices. This effect is more pronounced when harvesters are closer together.
  • Backward Path Dominance: The "backward path" (coupling between ground electrodes) plays a more significant role in power transfer and inter-degeneration than the "forward path" (coupling through the body). This highlights the importance of ground electrode placement and design.
  • Key Factors Identified: Distance between source and harvester, source frequency, and the area of ground electrodes are identified as critical parameters influencing BC-WPT performance and the inter-degeneration effect.
  • Frequency Optimization: There's an optimal frequency range (40-80 MHz) for BC-WPT, where received power is maximized. Frequencies too low or too high lead to reduced efficiency.
  • Ground Electrode Area Matters: Larger ground electrode areas generally lead to higher received power, making them a crucial design consideration, especially for miniaturized systems.
  • Empirical Model's Value: The developed empirical circuit model provides a more intuitive understanding of how design parameters affect BC-WPT performance compared to black-box S-parameter models, while still offering good accuracy.

Key Results

  • The empirical circuit model achieved an average relative error of 12.0% compared to experimental measurements, while the S-parameter model had an average error of 8.7%. The empirical model's advantage lies in its faster simulation speed and better interpretability.
  • Experiments and simulations showed that increasing the distance between the source and harvesters consistently reduces received power.
  • The study demonstrated that for SSMH cases, the received power of one harvester can increase as another harvester moves further away, indicating a reduction in inter-degeneration.
  • Optimal frequencies were found to be in the 40-80 MHz range, with power rising quickly and then plateauing.
  • Larger ground electrode areas (up to 100mm x 100mm tested) significantly improved received power.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Experimental Setup: The authors acknowledge that factors like battery power supply instability and varying contact resistance between electrodes and skin during experiments contributed to relative errors.
  • Human Body Model: While sophisticated, the CST model of the human body is a simplification. Real-world variations in body composition and posture could influence results.
  • Generalization: The study primarily focused on two-harvester scenarios. Extending the empirical model to systems with a larger number of harvesters would be valuable.
  • Optimization Guidelines: The paper provides a sample application of the empirical model for source placement optimization. Further research could develop more comprehensive optimization algorithms for multi-node BC-WPT systems.
  • Dynamic Environments: The current work assumes a relatively static environment. Future work could explore the impact of body movement and dynamic changes in the channel.

Summary updated

Abstract

Insufficient power supply is a huge challenge for wireless body area network (WBAN). Body channel wireless power transfer (BC-WPT) is promising to realize multi-node high-efficiency power transmission for miniaturized WBAN nodes. However, the behavior of BC-WPT, especially in the multi-node scenario, is still lacking in research. In this paper, the inter-degeneration mechanism of a multi-node BC-WPT is investigated based on the intuitive analysis of the existing circuit model. Co-simulation in the Computer Simulation Technology (CST) and Cadence platform and experiments in a general indoor environment verify this mechanism. Three key factors, including the distance between the source and the harvester, frequency of the source, and area of the ground electrodes, are taken into consideration, resulting in 15 representative cases for simulation and experiments studies. Based on the simulation parameters, an empirical circuit model to accurately predict the received power of multiple harvesters is established, which fits well with the measurement results, and can further provide guidelines for designs and research on multi-node BC-WPT systems.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{huang2020investigation,
  author = {Yuxuan Huang and Jian Zhao and Wenyu Sun and Huazhong Yang and Yongpan Liu},
  title = {{Investigation and Modeling of Multi-Node Body Channel Wireless Power Transfer}},
  booktitle = {Sensors},
  year = {2020},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=OK8Un7uvpE},
}
Figure