Intra-operative consult for cystic struma ovarii—An experience in an academic medical center: A study of 53 cases over 21 years

M. Ruhul Quddus, Jinjun Xiong, Shanaz Begum, Michele M. Lomme, Katrine Hansen, Chih‐Wei Sung, W. Dwayne LawrenceOpen 2013 · DOI

Abstract

Struma ovarii is a rare ovarian tumor that often eludes detection during intraoperative consultation due to its subtle gross appearance and lack of clinical suspicion. This study reviews 53 cases over 21 years at an academic medical center to evaluate the efficacy of intraoperative diagnostic techniques. While gross inspection alone failed to identify any cases of struma ovarii, frozen section analysis achieved an 83% accuracy rate. These findings underscore the importance of microscopic evaluation in guiding surgical management for adnexal masses.

Introduction

When a surgeon encounters an ovarian mass, the intraoperative consultation is a critical juncture. A diagnosis of a benign lesion allows the primary gynecologic surgeon to proceed as planned, whereas a malignant finding often necessitates the involvement of a gynecologic oncologist and a change in surgical scope.

Struma ovarii, a "monodermal teratoma" composed predominantly of thyroid tissue, presents a significant diagnostic challenge. Accounting for less than 3% of ovarian teratomas, it lacks a pathognomonic clinical or radiological signature. Preoperative imaging often misidentifies it as a common serous or mucinous cyst. This study aims to quantify the diagnostic performance of intraoperative consultations for this "chameleon" tumor in a real-world academic setting.

Methods and Materials

Researchers at the Warren Alpert Medical School of Brown University conducted a retrospective analysis of cases at the Women & Infants’ Hospital of Rhode Island from January 1991 to March 2011. The study identified 53 cases of struma ovarii, representing 5.2% of the 1,019 mature cystic teratomas diagnosed during that period.

The evaluation included a review of:

  • Intraoperative Consultation Reports: The immediate feedback provided to surgeons.
  • Gross Descriptions: Visual and tactile characteristics of the specimens.
  • Frozen Sections: Rapid microscopic analysis performed during surgery.
  • Final Pathology: Definitive diagnosis using H&E staining and, where necessary, thyroglobulin immunohistochemistry.

Key Results and Case Analysis

The study revealed a stark contrast between visual inspection and microscopic analysis. In 24 cases where only a gross examination was performed, the detection rate for struma ovarii was 0%. Pathologists frequently misidentified these masses as simple benign cysts or serous cystadenofibromas.

Table 1: Clinical and pathological characteristics of struma ovarii cases 1-22.

In contrast, when a frozen section was requested and performed (24 cases), the diagnostic accuracy rose to 83% (20 out of 24 cases). The median age of patients was 45 years, with a wide range from 12 to 81.

Table 1 (continued): Clinical and pathological characteristics of struma ovarii cases 23-53.

Discussion: The "Deceptive" Gross Appearance

A primary reason for the failure of gross inspection is the tumor's variable appearance. While textbook descriptions emphasize greenish or brown-green gelatinous fluid (indicative of thyroid colloid), this study found such features in only 7.5% of cases. The majority (34%) presented with clear or yellow serous fluid, mimicking common, harmless cysts.

The clinical implications of a correct intraoperative diagnosis are significant. Because struma ovarii is a teratoma, there is an 8–15% risk of bilateral involvement—significantly higher than the 2–3% risk associated with the simple cysts it mimics. A correct diagnosis prompts the surgeon to perform a more thorough inspection of the contralateral ovary.

Conclusion

Struma ovarii remains a diagnostic pitfall during surgery due to its deceptive gross morphology. While visual inspection is unreliable, the frozen section remains a highly effective tool for intraoperative identification. Even when the specific diagnosis of struma ovarii is missed, the intraoperative consultation generally succeeds in its primary goal: providing the surgeon with enough information to manage the case appropriately as a benign or malignant process.

Summary updated

Abstract

Struma ovarii often escapes recognition during intraoperative consultation because of its rarity, subtle characteristic gross appearance, and lack of clinical suspicion. An intraoperative diagnosis of benign struma ovarii enables the general gynecologic surgeon to continue the planned surgery. However, a diagnosis of malignnancy in a struma ovarii would alter the course of surgery with the involvement of a gynecologic oncology surgeon. We present here that our experience with intraoperative consultation for preoperatively undiagnosed struma ovarii presenting as an adnexal cystic or solid mass at our teaching hospital. Fifty-three cases of struma ovarii, 5.2% of all cystic teratoma of the same period, were diagnosed between January 1991 and March 2011. All intraoperative consultation reports, gross descriptions and final pathology reports were reviewed. The H&E stained slides and in selected cases, immunohistochemistry stained slides, were reviewed. Of the 53 cases of struma ovarii, intraoperative consultation was requested on 48 cases. Frozen section was done on 24 cases and only gross examination was felt appropriate in remaining 24 cases. 83% cases were diagnosed when a frozen section was done. None of the remaining 24 cases were recognized as struma by gross inspection. Our findings reveal that in a large number of cases the diagnosis of struma ovarii remained unrecognized during intraoperative consultation, indicating its often subtle/deceptive gross morphologic appearance. However, the purpose of the intraoperative consultation was served, as appropriate information was provided to the surgeon to guide the surgical management.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{quddus2013intra,
  author = {M. Ruhul Quddus and Jinjun Xiong and Shanaz Begum and Michele M. Lomme and Katrine Hansen and Chih‐Wei Sung and W. Dwayne Lawrence},
  title = {{Intra-operative consult for cystic struma ovarii—An experience in an academic medical center: A study of 53 cases over 21 years}},
  booktitle = {Open},
  year = {2013},
  doi = {10.4236/ojog.2013.37a1001},
}
Figure