A case of mucinous ("colloid") adenocarcinoma that was difficult to diagnose by intraoperative histopathological frozen sectioning

Hirohisa Kato, Hiroyuki Oizumi, Ken Fukaya, Jun Suzuki, Hikaru Shiota, Mitsuaki SadahiroThe Journal of the Japanese Association for Chest Surgery 2011 · DOI

Abstract

Mucinous ("colloid") adenocarcinoma (MC) of the lung is an extremely rare histological subtype, accounting for only 0.24% of lung cancers. We report the case of a 70-year-old male with an 8 mm nodule in the left S10 segment. Although intraoperative frozen sectioning initially suggested a benign lesion due to the absence of clear cellular atypia, final pathological analysis confirmed a diagnosis of mucinous adenocarcinoma. The patient subsequently underwent a successful lobectomy and lymph node dissection (Stage IA). This case underscores the diagnostic pitfalls associated with mucus-rich tumors and the necessity of maintaining a high index of clinical suspicion.

Introduction

In thoracic surgery, intraoperative frozen sectioning is a critical tool for determining the extent of resection. However, certain rare malignancies, such as mucinous ("colloid") adenocarcinoma, present significant challenges to this rapid diagnostic method. MC is characterized by large extracellular mucin pools that often dwarf the actual neoplastic cell population. This high mucin-to-cell ratio can lead to false-negative results during surgery, as the sparse cancer cells are easily overlooked or misinterpreted as benign inflammatory changes.

Case Presentation

A 70-year-old male was referred to our department after a routine chest X-ray revealed an abnormal shadow in the left lung. Computed tomography (CT) identified an 8 mm nodule in the left S10 segment. Following one year of observation, the nodule remained stable, and surgery was scheduled for definitive diagnosis.

Chest CT showing an 8 mm nodule in the left S10 segment (lung and mediastinal windows).

A thoracoscopic partial resection was performed. The intraoperative frozen section (H&E stain) revealed significant mucus accumulation but lacked definitive cellular atypia, leading to an initial diagnosis of benign mucinous metaplasia.

Histopathological Analysis and Results

Subsequent permanent histopathological sections revealed the true nature of the lesion. The tumor was composed of expansive pools of extracellular mucin that destroyed the underlying alveolar architecture. Sparse clusters of neoplastic cells, identified as the goblet-cell subtype, were found floating within these mucin pools.

Histopathological image (H&E stain) showing characteristic mucin pools with sparse neoplastic cells.

Based on this final diagnosis of mucinous ("colloid") adenocarcinoma, a secondary thoracoscopic left lower lobectomy and lymph node dissection were performed two months later. The final pathological stage was determined to be pT1aN0M0, Stage IA.

Discussion

The primary diagnostic challenge in MC is the "mucus mask." When cancer cells are sparse and suspended in a voluminous pool of mucus, they may not be captured or recognized in the limited sampling of a frozen section.

Key insights from this case include:

  • Structural Clues: Unlike other mucinous lung cancers that may preserve alveolar walls, MC typically expands and destroys them, a feature that can aid in differentiation.
  • Subtype Prognosis: MC is categorized into goblet-cell and signet-cell types. The goblet-cell type found in this patient generally carries a better prognosis and lower recurrence risk.
  • Clinical Suspicion: Surgeons must maintain suspicion for MC when encountering any mucus-rich lesion. While lobectomy is the current standard, the favorable prognosis of the goblet-cell subtype raises questions for future research regarding the adequacy of sub-lobar resections for small nodules.

Conclusion

Mucinous ("colloid") adenocarcinoma is a rare but clinically significant entity. Its unique histological structure makes it prone to under-diagnosis during intraoperative exams. Clinicians must be aware of these diagnostic limitations to ensure patients receive appropriate oncological management.

Summary updated

Abstract

症例は70歳,男性.検診の胸部X線検査で左肺野の異常影を指摘された.CTで左S10に8mmの結節を認め,経過観察1年後,結節は不変のため診断および加療目的に当科へ紹介された.胸腔鏡下肺部分切除術を施行し,術中迅速病理診断では悪性所見を認めなかった.しかし,最終病理組織診断の結果,mucinous(“colloid”)adenocarcinomaの診断であったため,再手術(胸腔鏡下左下葉切除術およびリンパ節郭清)を施行した.病理病期はpT1aN0M0,IA期であった.Mucinous(“colloid”)adenocarcinomaは稀な組織型で診断が困難な場合があることを念頭におく必要があると考えられた.
BibTeX
@article{kato2011case,
  author = {Hirohisa Kato and Hiroyuki Oizumi and Ken Fukaya and Jun Suzuki and Hikaru Shiota and Mitsuaki Sadahiro},
  title = {{A case of mucinous ("colloid") adenocarcinoma that was difficult to diagnose by intraoperative histopathological frozen sectioning}},
  journal = {The Journal of the Japanese Association for Chest Surgery},
  year = {2011},
  doi = {10.2995/jacsurg.25.578},
}
Figure