Interpolating log-determinant and trace of the powers of matrix bfA + tbfB

Siavash Ameli, Shawn C. Shadden

TL;DR

This paper introduces novel interpolation methods to efficiently estimate the log-determinant and trace of matrix functions involving a parameter t. These methods significantly speed up computations in machine learning and statistics by avoiding repeated, costly calculations for large matrices, achieving high accuracy with minimal interpolation points.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Many applications in statistics, machine learning, and computational physics, such as Gaussian process regression and ridge regression, require evaluating functions like log det(A + tB) and trace((A + tB)^p). These computations become computationally prohibitive when dealing with large matrices, especially when the parameter t needs to be varied over a wide range, as is common in optimization problems. Existing methods often require re-calculating these values from scratch for each new t, leading to significant computational overhead. This paper aims to bridge this gap by developing efficient interpolation techniques that can accurately approximate these functions for various t values after a small number of initial computations.

Methods

The core of the paper lies in developing heuristic interpolation methods for the functions t -> log det(A + tB) and t -> trace((A + tB)^p). The approach is built upon modifying sharp bounds derived from Schatten-type norms and anti-norms. Two main interpolation strategies are proposed:

  1. Linear Combination of Basis Functions: This method uses orthogonalized inverse-monomial basis functions. The parameters for these interpolations are determined by solving a linear system derived from a few known function values at strategically chosen interpolation points.
  2. Rational Polynomial Interpolation: This approach employs Padé approximations and Chebyshev rational functions. These methods are particularly effective for handling cases where the parameter t can be negative or close to zero, which can be problematic for other methods.

The authors also introduce a software package, imate, to implement these interpolation algorithms, supporting various underlying trace estimation techniques.

Datasets

The paper does not introduce new datasets. Instead, it uses synthetic data generated for numerical examples to evaluate the proposed methods. These examples include:

  • Gaussian Process Regression: A correlation matrix is generated using an isotropic exponential decay kernel.
  • Ridge Regression: An ill-conditioned design matrix X is generated using singular value decomposition.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Bridging Theory and Practice: The paper effectively connects theoretical inequalities (Schatten norms, generalized means) with practical computational challenges in machine learning.
  • The Power of Interpolation: Demonstrates that a few well-chosen interpolation points can yield highly accurate results for complex matrix functions, drastically reducing computational cost.
  • Tailored Interpolation Strategies: The authors highlight the importance of choosing the right interpolation method based on the domain of the parameter t (e.g., rational polynomials for negative t or near zero).
  • Software Implementation: The development of the imate Python package makes these advanced interpolation techniques accessible to practitioners.

Key Results

The proposed interpolation methods achieve remarkable accuracy and efficiency:

  • High Accuracy: With as few as 8 interpolation points, the relative error for interpolating t^-1 was around 0.1%. Using 9 points, the error dropped to less than 0.01%.
  • Significant Speedup: In the ridge regression example, the interpolation methods reduced the computational cost by two orders of magnitude for the exact trace calculations (Ttr) and one order of magnitude for the overall optimization (Ttot) compared to no interpolation.
  • Robustness: The methods demonstrated good performance across different values of p (0, -1, -2) and in various applications, including Gaussian process regression and ridge regression.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Ill-Conditioning: For the rational polynomial interpolation method (Padé approximation), the paper notes that the method can become singular at its poles. However, it suggests that rearranging interpolation points can mitigate this issue.
  • Orthogonal Basis Functions: For the orthogonalized inverse-monomial basis functions, the paper cautions against using them on very small logarithmic scales due to potential oscillations, recommending rational polynomials in such cases.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest that the interpolation scheme can be applied to other formulations involving affine matrix functions and mention its utility with massive datasets using the imate package. They also point to the potential for further applications in areas like reproducing kernel Hilbert spaces and kernel-based GCV for mixed models.

Summary updated

Abstract

We develop heuristic interpolation methods for the functions \(t\mapsto \log \det \left( \textbf{A} + t\textbf{B} \right) \) and \(t\mapsto {{\,\textrm{trace}\,}}\left( (\textbf{A} + t\textbf{B})^{p} \right) \) where the matrices \(\textbf{A}\) and \(\textbf{B}\) are Hermitian and positive (semi) definite and \(p\) and \(t\) are real variables. These functions are featured in many applications in statistics, machine learning, and computational physics. The presented interpolation functions are based on the modification of sharp bounds for these functions. We demonstrate the accuracy and performance of the proposed method with numerical examples, namely, the marginal maximum likelihood estimation for Gaussian process regression and the estimation of the regularization parameter of ridge regression with the generalized cross-validation method.
BibTeX
@article{ameli2022interpolating,
  author = {Siavash Ameli and Shawn C. Shadden},
  title = {{Interpolating log-determinant and trace of the powers of matrix bfA + tbfB}},
  journal = {Stat. Comput.},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.1007/s11222-022-10173-4},
}
Figure