Interplay between disorder and topology in Thouless pumping on a superconducting quantum processor

Yu Liu, Yu-Ran Zhang, Yun‐Hao Shi, Tao Liu, Congwei Lu, Yongyi Wang, Hao Li, Tianming Li, Cheng‐Lin Deng, Si-Yun Zhou, Tong Liu, Jiachi Zhang, Gui-Han Liang, Zheng-Yang Mei, Wei‐Guo Ma, Hao-Tian Liu, Zheng-He Liu, Chi-Tong Chen, Kaixuan Huang, Xiaohui Song, Sp Zhao, Ye Tian, Zhongcheng Xiang, Dongning Zheng, Franco Nori, Kai Xu, Heng Fan

Abstract

Topological phases are robust against weak perturbations, but break down when disorder becomes sufficiently strong. However, moderate disorder can also induce topologically nontrivial phases. Thouless pumping, as a (1+1)D counterpart of the integer quantum Hall effect, is one of the simplest manifestations of topology. Here, we report experimental observations of the competition and interplay between Thouless pumping and disorder on a 41-qubit superconducting quantum processor. We improve a Floquet engineering technique to realize cycles of adiabatic pumping by simultaneously varying the on-site potentials and the hopping couplings. We demonstrate Thouless pumping in the presence of disorder and show its breakdown as the strength of disorder increases. Moreover, we observe two types of topological pumping that are induced by on-site potential disorder and hopping disorder, respectively. In particular, an intrinsic topological pump that is induced by quasi-periodic hopping disorder has never been experimentally realized before. Our highly controllable system provides a valuable quantum simulating platform for studying various aspects of topological physics in the presence of disorder.

Introduction: Topology vs. Disorder

In condensed matter physics, topology and disorder are often at odds. Topological phases are celebrated for their "robustness"—they possess properties like quantized transport that remain unchanged even when a material is slightly disordered. However, if disorder becomes too strong, the system undergoes Anderson localization, and topological protection vanishes. Conversely, moderate disorder can sometimes induce topologically non-trivial phases where none existed, a phenomenon known as the Topological Anderson Insulator (TAI).

This study explores these boundaries using Thouless pumping, a 1D dynamic version of the Integer Quantum Hall Effect. By slowly (adiabatically) varying the parameters of a 1D lattice in a cycle, one can pump a quantized amount of charge across the chain. The researchers investigated how much disorder a topological pump can handle and whether disorder can be used to engineer topology.

Methodology: Floquet Engineering on a 41-Qubit Processor

The experiments were performed on a 1D chain of 41 frequency-tunable transmon qubits on a superconducting processor named Chuang-tzu. The team implemented the Rice-Mele (RM) model, which describes particles hopping on a lattice with alternating site energies and bond strengths.

The 41-qubit superconducting processor (a) and the experimental schemes for adiabatic pumping (b) under on-site (c) and hopping (d) disorder.

To achieve precise control, they utilized an advanced Floquet engineering technique. By modulating qubit frequencies at high speeds (~80 MHz), they could independently control on-site potentials (energy cost to sit on a qubit) and hopping couplings (ease of movement between qubits). This allowed them to drive the system through various trajectories in parameter space while injecting controlled amounts of random or quasi-periodic disorder.

Key Results

Robustness and Breakdown

In the clean limit, the system achieved near-perfect quantized pumping, with a Center-of-Mass (CoM) displacement of $\delta x \approx 1.95$ sites per cycle. The experiments confirmed that this transport is remarkably stable against weak on-site disorder. However, once the disorder strength ($V$) exceeded the system's energy gap ($\Delta_0$), the quantization decayed toward zero as the system entered a localized phase.

Disorder-Induced Topology

A major highlight of the study was the observation of topological pumping induced by disorder. In a "Double-Loop" experiment, the researchers chose a pumping path that was topologically trivial (net zero transport) in a clean system. By adding moderate random disorder, they broke the symmetry of the loops, effectively "opening" a topological window and inducing quantized transport.

Furthermore, the team realized an intrinsic topological pump induced by quasi-periodic hopping disorder. This specific type of pump, where the pattern of disorder itself creates topological protection, had never been experimentally observed before.

Observation of topological pumping induced by quasi-periodic hopping disorder, showing the quantized plateau in displacement (b) and the resulting phase diagram (c).

As shown in the figure, a clear quantized plateau in the pumped charge appears when the disorder strength is tuned within a specific range, directly proving that disorder can be a tool for creating topological phases.

Conclusion and Future Outlook

This work demonstrates that superconducting quantum processors are powerful platforms for simulating complex topological physics. While experimental results began to deviate from ideal theory after about three pumping cycles due to qubit decoherence, the high controllability of the system allows for deep exploration of the interplay between disorder and topology. Future research may involve many-body interactions or extending these simulations to higher-dimensional topological systems.

Summary updated

Abstract

Topological phases are robust against weak perturbations, but break down when disorder becomes sufficiently strong. However, moderate disorder can also induce topologically nontrivial phases. Thouless pumping, as a (1+1)D counterpart of the integer quantum Hall effect, is one of the simplest manifestations of topology. Here, we report experimental observations of the competition and interplay between Thouless pumping and disorder on a 41-qubit superconducting quantum processor. We improve a Floquet engineering technique to realize cycles of adiabatic pumping by simultaneously varying the on-site potentials and the hopping couplings. We demonstrate Thouless pumping in the presence of disorder and show its breakdown as the strength of disorder increases. Moreover, we observe two types of topological pumping that are induced by on-site potential disorder and hopping disorder, respectively. In particular, an intrinsic topological pump that is induced by quasi-periodic hopping disorder has never been experimentally realized before. Our highly controllable system provides a valuable quantum simulating platform for studying various aspects of topological physics in the presence of disorder.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{liu2025interplay,
  author = {Yu Liu and Yu-Ran Zhang and Yun‐Hao Shi and Tao Liu and Congwei Lu and Yongyi Wang and Hao Li and Tianming Li and Cheng‐Lin Deng and Si-Yun Zhou and Tong Liu and Jiachi Zhang and Gui-Han Liang and Zheng-Yang Mei and Wei‐Guo Ma and Hao-Tian Liu and Zheng-He Liu and Chi-Tong Chen and Kaixuan Huang and Xiaohui Song and SP Zhao and Ye Tian and Zhongcheng Xiang and Dongning Zheng and Franco Nori and Kai Xu and Heng Fan},
  title = {{Interplay between disorder and topology in Thouless pumping on a superconducting quantum processor}},
  booktitle = {Nature Communications},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.1038/s41467-024-55343-2},
}
Figure