Interoperable Blockchains for Highly-Integrated Supply Chains in Collaborative Manufacturing

Paolo Bellavista, Christian Esposito, Luca Foschini, Carlo Giannelli, Nicola Mazzocca, Rebecca Montanari

TL;DR

This paper tackles the challenge of making different blockchains talk to each other, which is crucial for the interconnected vision of Industry 4.0. They propose a novel relay scheme using Trusted Execution Environments (TEEs) to enable secure and efficient cross-blockchain communication, demonstrating its feasibility with a prototype that shows acceptable latency increases.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Industry 4.0, the ongoing digital transformation of manufacturing, relies heavily on interconnected systems, including the Industrial Internet of Things (IIoT) and Cyber-Physical Systems (CPSs). Blockchain technology is seen as a key enabler for this vision, offering secure and transparent data management. However, the Industry 4.0 landscape is inherently decentralized, with various companies operating their own independent blockchain solutions. The critical problem is that these diverse blockchain platforms, with their different architectures and consensus mechanisms, cannot easily interoperate. This lack of interoperability hinders the seamless data exchange and collaboration needed for truly integrated supply chains. While some solutions for blockchain interoperability exist, they often have security limitations or significant overhead, leaving the problem largely unresolved.

Methods

The authors propose a novel solution for blockchain interoperability based on a relay scheme enhanced with Trusted Execution Environments (TEEs). Instead of relying on sidechains or complex notary schemes, their approach uses an off-chain secure computation element. This element, essentially a specialized software component, is invoked by a smart contract on one blockchain to communicate securely with its counterpart on another blockchain.

The core innovation lies in hosting this off-chain computation within a TEE. TEEs are secure hardware enclaves that guarantee the integrity and confidentiality of the code and data they process, protecting them from the underlying operating system and other potentially malicious software. This TEE-based approach aims to provide stronger security guarantees than existing methods.

Specifically, the proposed solution involves:

  • Inter-blockchain Smart Contracts: These contracts are designed to coordinate actions across different blockchains.
  • Off-chain Relay Component: This component acts as a bridge, facilitating communication between blockchains.
  • Trusted Execution Environment (TEE): This hardware-based security feature protects the relay component, ensuring secure execution and data handling.
  • TLS and Certificates: Used for secure communication channels between TEEs on different nodes.
  • TEE-based Authentication: A novel password generation and verification mechanism is implemented within the TEE to secure access, especially for permissionless blockchains.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on a proof-of-concept implementation and experimental evaluation rather than training on specific datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • TEE as a Security Anchor for Interoperability: The paper highlights that TEEs are not just for securing individual blockchain nodes but can be a powerful tool for securing the interactions between different blockchains, a less explored area.
  • Decentralized Interoperability without Sidechains: The proposed relay scheme avoids the complexity and resource overhead associated with sidechains, offering a more streamlined approach.
  • Addressing Permissionless Blockchain Security: The TEE-based authentication mechanism is a significant contribution for securing interactions in permissionless blockchain environments, where traditional certificate-based methods are less straightforward.
  • Tolerable Latency for Security: The experimental results demonstrate that while security enhancements introduce latency, it remains within acceptable bounds for many industrial transactions, suggesting a viable trade-off.

Key Results

The authors implemented a prototype using Hyperledger Fabric and Hyperledger Sawtooth, integrated with the Open Enclave SDK. Their experimental results show:

  • Inter-Blockchain Transfers: The system successfully enabled asset transfers between the Sawtooth and Fabric blockchains.
  • Latency:
    • Cross-blockchain transfers introduced an additional latency of approximately 3 seconds and 50 milliseconds, compared to 13 milliseconds for local transfers within Sawtooth. The authors deem this tolerable for the target use case.
  • The introduction of TEE-based verification for operations like getting a wallet balance added a minimal latency of no more than 3 milliseconds on average.
  • Overhead: The usage of TEEs was reported to impose a negligible overhead.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limitations:
    • The current solution is tested with only two specific blockchain platforms (Hyperledger Fabric and Sawtooth).
  • The security of the cross-blockchain asset transfer is primarily addressed by the TEE, but the authors acknowledge that the attack surface still includes potential network misbehaviors or deviations in software specifications.
  • While latency is deemed tolerable, further research is needed to achieve optimal trade-offs between security, performance, and scalability.
  • Future Work:
    • Extend the solution to support more blockchain platforms by developing additional connectors, potentially leveraging standards like the Enterprise Ethereum Alliance's Trusted Compute Specifications.
  • Integrate with existing interoperability frameworks like Hyperledger Avalon.
  • Conduct more comprehensive benchmarking against other interoperability solutions.
  • Investigate how to seamlessly integrate new blockchains into a federation and broadcast cross-chain requests efficiently.

Summary updated

Abstract

Blockchain technology plays a pivotal role in the undergoing fourth industrial revolution or Industry 4.0. It is considered a tremendous boost to company digitalization; thus, considerable investments in blockchain are being made. However, there is no single blockchain technology, but various solutions exist, and they cannot interoperate with one each other. The ecosystem envisioned by the Industry 4.0 does not have centralized management or leading organization, so a single blockchain solution cannot be imposed. The various organizations hold their own blockchains, which must interoperate seamlessly. Despite some solutions for blockchain interoperability being proposed, the problem is still open. This paper aims to devise a secure solution for blockchain interoperability. The proposed approach consists of a relay scheme based on Trusted Execution Environment to provide higher security guarantees than the current literature. In particular, the proposed solution adopts an off-chain secure computation element invoked by a smart contract on a blockchain to securely communicate with its peered counterpart. A prototype has been implemented and used for the performance assessment, e.g., to measure the latency increase due to cross-blockchain interactions. The achieved and reported experimental results show that the proposed security solution introduces an additional latency that is entirely tolerable for transactions. At the same time, the usage of the Trusted Execution Environment imposes a negligible overhead.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{bellavista2021interoperable,
  author = {Paolo Bellavista and Christian Esposito and Luca Foschini and Carlo Giannelli and Nicola Mazzocca and Rebecca Montanari},
  title = {{Interoperable Blockchains for Highly-Integrated Supply Chains in Collaborative Manufacturing}},
  booktitle = {Sensors},
  year = {2021},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=8vm6AeTj0P},
}
Figure