Interleaving Channel Estimation and Limited Feedback for Point-to-Point Systems With a Large Number of Transmit Antennas

Erdem Koyuncu, Xun Zou, Hamid Jafarkhani

TL;DR

This paper proposes a novel communication scheme for massive MIMO systems that interleaves channel training and feedback. This approach allows for achieving the same performance as systems with perfect channel knowledge, but with feedback and training overheads that are independent of the number of antennas, making it practical for large-scale deployments.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Massive MIMO systems, with their large number of antennas, promise significant performance gains through techniques like beamforming. However, realizing these gains requires accurate channel state information (CSI) at the transmitter (CSIT). Traditional methods involve training all antennas at once, followed by a single feedback phase. This becomes computationally prohibitive and requires an infeasible amount of feedback as the number of antennas grows. Existing limited feedback schemes also struggle to scale efficiently with an increasing number of antennas. The core challenge is to obtain sufficient CSI for effective beamforming without overwhelming the system with training and feedback overhead.

Methods

The paper introduces an interleaved training and feedback scheme. Instead of training all antennas simultaneously, the transmitter trains them one by one. After each antenna is trained, the receiver provides immediate feedback. This feedback can either request training of the next antenna or signal that enough information has been gathered to proceed with data transmission using a quantized beamforming vector.

Key techniques include:

  • Interleaved Training and Feedback: This is the central innovation, breaking down the traditional two-stage process into a more granular, iterative approach.
  • Variable-Rate Quantization: To further minimize feedback, the authors design quantizers that allocate more bits to more significant channel components, ensuring accuracy where it matters most for beamforming.
  • Deadzone Quantizer: A specific type of quantizer is used, which is efficient for representing beamforming vectors.
  • Rate-Allocation Algorithm: An algorithm is proposed to optimally assign quantization rates to different components of the beamforming vector, balancing distortion and feedback rate.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on theoretical analysis and simulation results based on a defined system model.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Interleaving is Key to Scalability: The interleaved approach decouples the training and feedback overhead from the number of antennas, a critical step for making massive MIMO practical.
  • Feedback Can Guide Training: The receiver's immediate feedback allows it to dynamically decide whether to continue training or to terminate the phase early, saving resources.
  • Achieving Full-CSI Performance with Limited Resources: The proposed scheme demonstrates that it's possible to achieve the performance of systems with perfect CSI, but with significantly reduced training and feedback requirements.
  • Variable-Rate Quantization Offers Significant Savings: By intelligently allocating bits to different channel components, the feedback rate can be further minimized without sacrificing performance.
  • Antenna Grouping for Latency Trade-offs: While training antennas one by one can be effective, grouping them for training can offer a better trade-off between latency and performance in certain scenarios.

Key Results

  • The proposed interleaved scheme achieves the same outage probability as a system with perfect CSI.
  • The average feedback rate and average training length are independent of the number of transmit antennas (t), depending only on the power constraint (P) and target data rate (p). This is a major breakthrough for massive MIMO.
  • For a specific interleaved antenna selection scheme (Scheme B), the training length and feedback rate are shown to saturate and be bounded, independent of t, unlike conventional methods.
  • The variable-rate deadzone quantizer (qr) reduces the total feedback rate compared to fixed-rate quantizers.
  • Simulation results confirm that the interleaved scheme outperforms antenna selection schemes in terms of outage probability and achieves significantly lower feedback rates.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Latency Costs: The paper acknowledges that interleaving introduces latency due to multiple training and feedback stages. Antenna grouping is proposed as a solution to mitigate this.
  • Per-Antenna Power Constraints: The current work assumes a total power constraint across all antennas. Future research could explore the impact of per-antenna power constraints.
  • Multi-Carrier Systems (OFDM): The authors suggest that the interleaved antenna selection scheme can be applied to OFDM systems, but note that antenna selection might need to adapt across frequencies.
  • Interleaved Beam Selection for Multi-Carrier Systems: Extending the interleaved concept to beam selection in multi-carrier systems is identified as a future research direction.
  • Converse Results: Determining fundamental limits (converse results) for general interleaved schemes to achieve vanishing outage probability with t-independent training and feedback rates remains an open problem.
  • Numerical Designs: While analytical constructions are provided, finding efficient algorithms for numerical design of interleaved schemes is highlighted as a challenging but promising area.

Summary updated

Abstract

We introduce and investigate the opportunities of multi-antenna communication schemes whose training and feedback stages are interleaved and mutually interacting. Specifically, unlike the traditional schemes, where the transmitter first trains all of its antennas at once and then receives a single feedback message, we consider a scenario, where the transmitter instead trains its antennas one by one and receives feedback information immediately after training each one of its antennas. The feedback message may ask the transmitter to train another antenna; or, it may terminate the feedback/training phase and provide the quantized codeword (e.g., a beamforming vector) to be utilized for data transmission. As a specific application, we consider a multiple-input single-output system with t transmit antennas, a short-term power constraint P , and target data rate p. We show that for any t, the same outage probability as a system with perfect transmitter and receiver channel state information can be achieved with a feedback rate of R 1 bits per channel state and via training R 2 transmit antennas on average, where R 1 and R 2 are independent oft, and depend only on p and P . In addition, we design variable-rate quantizers for channel coefficients to further minimize the feedback rate of our scheme.
BibTeX
@article{koyuncu2018interleaving,
  author = {Erdem Koyuncu and Xun Zou and Hamid Jafarkhani},
  title = {{Interleaving Channel Estimation and Limited Feedback for Point-to-Point Systems With a Large Number of Transmit Antennas}},
  journal = {IEEE Trans. Wireless Communications},
  year = {2018},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=reMys2KFKu},
}
Figure