Interlaboratory study assessing the analysis of supercapacitor electrochemistry data

Jamie W. Gittins, Yuan Chen, Stefanie Arnold, Veronica Augustyn, Andrea Balducci, Thierry Brousse, Elżbieta Frąckowiak, Pedro Gómez‐Romero, Archana Kanwade, Lukas Köps, Plawan Kumar Jha, Dongxun Lyu, Michele Meo, Deepak Pandey, Le Pang, Volker Presser, Mario Rapisarda, Daniel Rueda-García, Saeed Saeed, Parasharam M. Shirage, Adam Ślesiński, Francesca Soavi, Jayan Thomas, Maria‐Magdalena Titirici, Hongxia Wang, Zhen Xu, Aiping Yu, Maiwen Zhang, Alexander C. Forse

Abstract

Supercapacitors are fast-charging energy storage devices of great importance for developing robust and climate-friendly energy infrastructures for the future. Research in this field has seen rapid growth in recent years, therefore consistent reporting practices must be implemented to enable reliable comparison of device performance. Although several studies have highlighted the best practices for analysing and reporting data from such energy storage devices, there is yet to be an empirical study investigating whether researchers in the field are correctly implementing these recommendations, and which assesses the variation in reporting between different laboratories. Here we address this deficit by carrying out the first interlaboratory study of the analysis of supercapacitor electrochemistry data. We find that the use of incorrect formulae and researchers having different interpretations of key terminologies are major causes of variability in data reporting. Furthermore we highlight the more significant variation in reported results for electrochemical profiles showing non-ideal capacitive behaviour. From the insights gained through this study, we make additional recommendations to the community to help ensure consistent reporting of performance metrics moving forward.
BibTeX
@article{gittins2023interlaboratory,
  author = {Jamie W. Gittins and Yuan Chen and Stefanie Arnold and Veronica Augustyn and Andrea Balducci and Thierry Brousse and Elżbieta Frąckowiak and Pedro Gómez‐Romero and Archana Kanwade and Lukas Köps and Plawan Kumar Jha and Dongxun Lyu and Michele Meo and Deepak Pandey and Le Pang and Volker Presser and Mario Rapisarda and Daniel Rueda-García and Saeed Saeed and Parasharam M. Shirage and Adam Ślesiński and Francesca Soavi and Jayan Thomas and Maria‐Magdalena Titirici and Hongxia Wang and Zhen Xu and Aiping Yu and Maiwen Zhang and Alexander C. Forse},
  title = {{Interlaboratory study assessing the analysis of supercapacitor electrochemistry data}},
  journal = {Journal of Power Sources},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.1016/j.jpowsour.2023.233637},
}

Loading related content...

Figure