Interacting Topological Superconductors and possible Origin of $16n$ Chiral Fermions in the Standard Model

Yi‐Zhuang You, Yoni BenTov, Cenke XuarXiv 2014 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

Motivated by the observation that the Standard Model of particle physics (plus a right-handed neutrino) has precisely 16 Weyl fermions per generation, we search for $(3+1)$-dimensional chiral fermionic theories and chiral gauge theories that can be regularized on a 3-dimensional spatial lattice when and only when the number of flavors is an integral multiple of 16. All these results are based on the observation that local interactions reduce the classification of certain $(4+1)$-dimensional topological superconductors from $\mathbb{Z}$ to $\mathbb{Z}_{8}$, which means that one of their $(3+1)$-dimensional boundaries can be gapped out by interactions without breaking any symmetry when and only when the number of boundary chiral fermions is an integral multiple of $16$.

The Challenge of Chiral Fermions on the Lattice

A fundamental hurdle in theoretical physics is the Nielsen-Ninomiya Theorem, also known as the Fermi doubling theorem. It states that any attempt to define chiral fermions—particles like those in the Standard Model whose left- and right-handed versions interact differently—on a discrete spatial lattice inevitably produces unwanted "mirror" fermions. These mirror fermions have opposite chirality and cancel out the chiral nature of the theory, making it impossible to simulate the Standard Model directly on a computer using standard lattice methods.

A Higher-Dimensional Solution

To circumvent this, researchers have looked toward higher-dimensional systems. By imagining our (3+1)D universe as the boundary of a (4+1)D bulk material, specifically a Topological Superconductor (TSC), one can separate the physical chiral fermions from their mirror counterparts. In this setup, the "real" fermions reside on one 3D boundary, while the mirror fermions reside on the opposite boundary.

A 4D topological superconductor slab with two 3D boundaries. The mirror sector is gapped by strong interactions, leaving a chiral gauge theory on the physical boundary.

The core challenge remains: how do we "gap out" (make massive and remove from low-energy physics) the mirror fermions without affecting the physical ones or breaking the underlying gauge symmetries?

Interaction-Induced Reduction and the Magic Number 16

The key insight of this work is that strong local interactions can fundamentally change the topological classification of these systems. In non-interacting systems, the classification of (4+1)D TSCs is typically $\mathbb{Z}$, meaning any number of fermion flavors represents a distinct phase. However, the authors demonstrate that strong interactions cause this classification to collapse from $\mathbb{Z}$ to $\mathbb{Z}_8$.

This mathematical reduction implies that a boundary can be gapped out without breaking symmetry if and only if the number of fermion flavors is a multiple of 8 (for the specific base model used, this translates to $8 \times 2 = 16$ Weyl fermions). Remarkably, this matches the 16 Weyl fermions (including the right-handed neutrino) found in each generation of the Standard Model.

Methodology: Condense and Proliferate

To prove that a boundary can be gapped symmetrically, the authors employ a "condense and proliferate" strategy. They analyze topological defects within the system, such as monopoles, vortex lines, and domain walls.

Topological defects used in the 'condense and proliferate' strategy: (a) monopoles, (b) vortex lines, and (c) domain walls.

By manually breaking a symmetry through the condensation of an order parameter and then "proliferating" these defects to restore the symmetry, they show that if the defects have a trivial spectrum (no gapless modes), the entire boundary becomes gapped and symmetric. This mechanism allows for four-fermion interactions to create a mass gap while keeping the bilinear expectation value at zero, thus preserving the gauge symmetry.

Implications for the Standard Model

The paper provides a proof-of-concept for non-abelian chiral gauge theories, specifically identifying an $SO(7) \times SU(2)$ theory that can be regularized this way. Given that $SO(7)$ contains $SO(6) \cong SU(4)$, which encompasses the Standard Model's $SU(3)$ color symmetry, this represents a significant step toward a full lattice regularization of the Standard Model.

While a complete regularization for the exact $SU(3) \times SU(2) \times U(1)$ group is still a work in progress, the emergence of the number 16 provides a compelling theoretical link between the structure of the Standard Model and the topological properties of interacting fermions.

Conclusion

By bridging condensed matter concepts like SPT phases with high-energy particle physics, this research offers a novel path to solving the Fermi doubling problem. The discovery that interactions can gap out mirror sectors in multiples of 16 suggests that the specific fermion content of our universe may be deeply rooted in the requirements for a consistent, non-anomalous lattice theory.

Summary updated

Abstract

Motivated by the observation that the Standard Model of particle physics (plus a right-handed neutrino) has precisely 16 Weyl fermions per generation, we search for $(3+1)$-dimensional chiral fermionic theories and chiral gauge theories that can be regularized on a 3 dimensional spatial lattice when and only when the number of flavors is an integral multiple of 16. All these results are based on the observation that local interactions reduce the classification of certain $(4+1)$-dimensional topological superconductors from $\mathbb{Z}$ to $\mathbb{Z}_{8}$, which means that one of their $(3+1)$-dimensional boundaries can be gapped out by interactions without breaking any symmetry when and only when the number of boundary chiral fermions is an integral multiple of $16$.
BibTeX
@misc{you2014interacting,
  author = {Yi‐Zhuang You and Yoni BenTov and Cenke Xu},
  title = {{Interacting Topological Superconductors and possible Origin of $16n$ Chiral Fermions in the Standard Model}},
  year = {2014},
  eprint = {1402.4151},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/1402.4151},
}
Figure