Intensive Faculty-led International Multicultural Courses: Understanding the Perceptions from Students and Improving the Quality of Course Delivery by Faculty

Dorota Celińska-Kopczyńska, Roberto SwazoJournal of Education and Training Studies 2015 · DOI

Abstract

Graduate programs in counselor education traditionally utilize on-campus multicultural courses to meet accreditation mandates. This study analyzes the perceptions of 21 master’s level students who participated in an intensive faculty-led international course (IFLIC) in Guatemala. By examining student acquisition of multicultural concepts and skills, the research offers recommendations for improving international higher education delivery and implementation strategies for short-term immersion programs.

Introduction: Beyond the Classroom Walls

Developing multicultural competence is a cornerstone of counselor education. However, traditional classroom settings often struggle to bridge the gap between intellectual knowledge and genuine emotional or behavioral transformation. This "classroom walls" problem suggests that cultural empathy is difficult to cultivate through lectures alone. This paper investigates whether a short-term, high-intensity international immersion program can serve as a more effective alternative for fostering multicultural self-awareness.

Methodology

The study employed a qualitative approach with 21 master’s level counselor education students. The IFLIC model followed a rigorous three-phase structure designed to maximize cultural immersion and academic reflection.

The IFLIC course structure, detailing pre-trip, immersion, and post-trip phases.

The course components included:

  1. Pre-departure: Six on-campus sessions focusing on General Multicultural Course Content (GMCC), including culture genograms and self-reflection statements.
  2. Immersion: A 13-day trip to Guatemala involving living with local families (avoiding the "luxury hotel" model), service-learning workshops for local teachers, and visits to indigenous Mayan communities.
  3. Evaluation: Post-trip reflection using the Post-trip Reflection and Evaluation Questionnaire (PREQ) and psychometric scales like the Miville-Guzman Universality Diversity Scale (MGUDS).

Key Insights

Skills vs. Concepts

A notable finding was that students articulated specific skill acquisition (e.g., recognizing personal bias during client assessment) more clearly than conceptual growth. Conceptual gains, such as "increased awareness," remained somewhat vague, indicating a need for more structured faculty guidance to help students deconstruct complex theoretical shifts.

The Role of Linguistic Dissonance

By placing students in a non-English speaking environment without typical tourist amenities, the course intentionally created "cultural discomfort." This dissonance served as a primary catalyst for internal self-evaluation and growth.

Reciprocity and the "Knowledge-Bridge"

To avoid the pitfalls of "missionary" or "savior" mindsets, the curriculum emphasized reciprocity. Students shared professional expertise with local teachers and students while maintaining deep respect for the host culture, fostering a "knowledge-bridge" rather than a one-way charitable interaction.

Results and Impact

The immersion experience yielded significant self-reported growth:

  • Primary Concept: "Respect Towards Others who Differ from Me" was the most cited conceptual takeaway.
  • Primary Skill: "Capacity to Comprehend the Multicultural Reality of Diverse Clients" emerged as the top skill gain.
  • Learning Drivers: 50% of participants identified direct interactions with local communities as the most impactful learning factor. Furthermore, 64% noted that immersion in a non-English speaking country provided a unique understanding of the cultural adaptation process.

Conclusion and Recommendations

While the study is limited by a small sample size and self-reporting bias, it highlights the efficacy of IFLICs in counselor education. To improve future outcomes, the authors recommend enhanced "scaffolding"—specifically through pre-constructed journaling questions and structured focus groups—to help students better navigate the "reflection compass" and integrate complex multicultural theories into their professional identities.

Summary updated

Abstract

Graduate programs in counselor education have historically offered the on campus multicultural course to increase students’ diversity knowledge, skills, and cultural self-awareness in order to satisfy state, national and international accreditation mandates. This article analyzes the self-reported perceptions and experiences of 21 master’s level counselor education students who participated in an intensive faculty-led international course (IFLIC) as an alternative format to the traditional on campus multicultural course. The pedagogy and curriculum of the IFLIC format is cemented on current multicultural international methodologies of instruction. Subsequently, it presents an in-depth analysis of students’ perceptions of their acquisition of multicultural concepts and skills, as well the role of the course’s curricular and instructional components in their multicultural learning outcomes. It offers a set of recommendations based on the research findings for academic/educational/faculty developers in higher education with the ultimate goal of improving the quality of international higher education. And, it provides delivery strategies for international programs seeking effective implementation of short-term faculty-led international courses (IFLIC).
BibTeX
@article{celinskakopczynska2015intensive,
  author = {Dorota Celińska-Kopczyńska and Roberto Swazo},
  title = {{Intensive Faculty-led International Multicultural Courses: Understanding the Perceptions from Students and Improving the Quality of Course Delivery by Faculty}},
  journal = {Journal of Education and Training Studies},
  year = {2015},
  doi = {10.11114/jets.v3i4.813},
}
Figure