Exploring the Process and Outcomes of Leading a Study Abroad Program Using Real-Time Perspectives

Kirsten Davis, Jessica Deters, Desen Özkan, James C. Davis, Homero MurziFrontiers The Interdisciplinary Journal of Study Abroad 2022 · DOI

Abstract

A study abroad program can be a transformative experience for students, but these programs rely on the support of program leaders who play a crucial mentoring role. Program leaders can also learn from their experiences abroad, but their experiences are less studied than those of students. To better prepare future program leaders, this paper describes the experiences of program leaders during a two-week study abroad program. We introduce a novel data collection approach, autonomous focus groups, to capture real-time perspectives. Through the lens of Kolb’s Experiential Learning Theory, we characterize the process of leading a study abroad program and the conceptualizations that program leaders form about students during their time abroad. Our findings provide a more nuanced view of the day-to-day experience of leading a study abroad program than previous studies, which can inform the preparation and training provided to program leaders.

Introduction: The Hidden Experience of Program Leaders

While study abroad programs are frequently celebrated for their transformative impact on students, the faculty and graduate students who lead these programs are often overlooked in research. Current literature typically focuses on student outcomes, and when program leaders are studied, researchers often rely on retrospective interviews conducted weeks or months after the program concludes. However, hindsight can be reductive, often smoothing over the "in-the-moment" uncertainty, stress, and rapid problem-solving that define the leadership experience.

This study addresses the gap by examining the real-time experiences of leaders during a short-term engineering study abroad program. The authors argue that traditional faculty training is often overly focused on logistics—such as flights and schedules—while failing to prepare leaders for the complex "cultural mentoring" and social navigation required on the ground.

Methodology: Capturing Real-Time Perspectives

To capture the organic, messy, and improvisational nature of leadership, the researchers utilized a novel qualitative technique: autonomous focus groups (AFGs). Unlike traditional researcher-led interviews, AFGs involve giving leadership teams audio recorders and reflection prompts to use during private debriefs while still abroad. This "fly-on-the-wall" approach allowed for high-fidelity conversations that captured the immediate reactions of leaders to daily challenges.

Overview of the study methodology, from leader training to data analysis across six international tracks.

The study analyzed data from the Rising Sophomore Abroad Program (RSAP), involving 17 track leaders across six international tracks, including locations such as China, Chile/Argentina, and the UK/Ireland. The resulting 10 hours of audio provided a rich dataset of 313 transcript pages for analysis.

Theoretical Framework: Adapting Experiential Learning

The researchers analyzed the data through the lens of Kolb’s Experiential Learning Theory (ELT). To better reflect the rapid pace of a two-week program, the standard four-stage cycle was adapted. Specifically, the researchers split the "Experimentation" stage into Proposed Experimentation (planning for future iterations) and Implemented Experimentation (trying a new approach the very next day).

Comparison of the original Kolb (1984) cycle and the adapted cycle used to analyze real-time leader reflections.

This adaptation allowed the team to track how leaders moved from observing a student's lack of engagement to theorizing a cause and immediately implementing a pedagogical change.

Key Insights: Leadership as Improvisation

The findings reveal that leading a study abroad program is a constant state of reassessment and improvisation. Four core themes emerged from the leader conversations:

  1. Student Engagement: Strategies to encourage students to interact meaningfully with local engineers and environments.
  2. Student-Leader Interactions: Navigating the transition from a formal classroom professor to an informal mentor.
  3. Group Dynamics: Managing social cliques and preventing student isolation.
  4. Cultural Learning: Helping students move beyond superficial comparisons to deeper cultural understanding.

Interestingly, the data showed that deep reflections on cultural learning were most frequent in tracks traveling to countries perceived as highly culturally different from the U.S. In more "familiar" locales, leaders focused more heavily on social dynamics and student behavior.

Conclusion and Implications for Training

The study demonstrates that the most significant mentoring often happens during "informal" moments—sharing meals or navigating travel delays. Leaders found that maintaining a "super calm" demeanor during crises built more trust than formal lectures.

Based on these findings, the authors suggest that future program leader training should move away from logistics handbooks and toward conversational role-plays or improv workshops. By viewing the student-leader group as a "community of practice," institutions can better prepare faculty for the unpredictable human elements of international education.

Summary updated

Abstract

A study abroad program can be a transformative experience for students, but these programs rely on the support of program leaders who play a crucial mentoring role. Program leaders can also learn from their experiences abroad, but their experiences are less studied than those of students. To better prepare future program leaders, this paper describes the experiences of program leaders during a two-week study abroad program. We introduce a novel data collection approach, autonomous focus groups, to capture real-time perspectives. Through the lens of Kolb’s Experiential Learning Theory, we characterize the process of leading a study abroad program and the conceptualizations that program leaders form about students during their time abroad. Our findings provide a more nuanced view of the day-to-day experience of leading a study abroad program than previous studies, which can inform the preparation and training provided to program leaders. Abstract in Spanish Los programas de estudio en el extranjero pueden ser una experienca transformadora para los estudiantes, sin embargo, estos programas dependen de los líderes quienes tienen un rol fundamental en la tutoría de los estudiantes. Los líderes de estos programas pueden también aprender de estas experiencias en el extranjero, aunque estas experiencias no han sido estudiadas al mismo nivel de detalle como han sido estudiadas las experiencias de los estudiantes. Para preparar mejor a los futuros líderes de estos programas, este artículo describe las experiencias de líderes en un programa de estudio en el extranjero que duró dos semanas. En este trabajo presentamos una innovadora forma de recolectar data, como son los grupos focales autónomos, donde capturamos las perspectivas de los participantes en tiempo real. Usando el lente de la Teoría de Aprendizaje Experiencial de Kolb, caracterizamos los procesos involucrados en dirigir un programa de estudio en el extranjero, así como las conceptualizaciones que los líderes del programa formaron sobre los estudiantes durante el tiempo que estuvieron de viaje. Nuestros resultados ofrecen una manera más adecuada de entender las experiencias en el día a día cuando se supervisa un programa de estudio en el extranjero, estos resultados pueden ayudar a preparar y entrenar futuros lideres de programas de estudio en el extranjero.
BibTeX
@article{davis2022exploring,
  author = {Kirsten Davis and Jessica Deters and Desen Özkan and James C. Davis and Homero Murzi},
  title = {{Exploring the Process and Outcomes of Leading a Study Abroad Program Using Real-Time Perspectives}},
  journal = {Frontiers The Interdisciplinary Journal of Study Abroad},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.36366/frontiers.v34i2.654},
}
Figure