Intelligent Omni-Surfaces: Ubiquitous Wireless Transmission by Reflective-Refractive Metasurfaces

Shuhang Zhang, Hongliang Zhang, Boya Di, Yunhua Tan, Marco Di Renzo, Zhu Han, H. Vincent Poor, Lingyang Song

TL;DR

This paper introduces the "Intelligent Omni-Surface" (IOS), a novel metasurface capable of both reflecting and refracting wireless signals, thereby extending coverage to both sides of the surface. The authors propose an optimization framework to jointly design the IOS's phase shifts and the base station's digital beamforming to maximize system sum-rate, demonstrating significant performance gains over conventional IRS and cellular systems.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Modern wireless communication systems are grappling with increasing demands for high-speed data and ubiquitous connectivity, especially in challenging propagation environments. Traditional Reconfigurable Intelligent Surfaces (RIS) primarily focus on reflecting signals, limiting their service coverage to one side of the surface. This leaves users on the opposite side underserved. The paper addresses this limitation by proposing an Intelligent Omni-Surface (IOS) that can simultaneously reflect and refract signals, effectively extending wireless coverage to both sides of the surface. This dual functionality offers a more comprehensive solution for enhancing wireless communication performance and coverage.

Methods

The core of the paper lies in developing a system model and an optimization framework for an IOS-assisted communication system.

  • IOS Model: The IOS is modeled as a 2D array of reconfigurable elements, each capable of introducing discrete phase shifts. Crucially, unlike IRS, the IOS can split incident signals into reflected and refracted components, with the power ratio controlled by a parameter $\epsilon$.
  • System Model: A multi-user downlink scenario is considered, with a small base station (SBS) serving multiple mobile users (MUs) distributed on both sides of the IOS. The channel model accounts for both the direct SBS-MU link and the reflective-refractive channel via the IOS.
  • Optimization Problem: The objective is to maximize the system sum-rate by jointly optimizing the IOS phase shifts and the SBS digital beamforming. This problem is formulated as a mixed-integer non-convex optimization problem.
  • Decomposition and Algorithms: To tackle the complexity, the problem is decoupled into two subproblems:
  • Digital Beamforming Optimization at the SBS: This subproblem is solved using Zero-Forcing (ZF) beamforming and water-filling power allocation.
  • Analog Beamforming Optimization at the IOS: This involves optimizing the discrete phase shifts of the IOS elements. A two-step approach is used:
  • Continuous Phase Shift Design: An iterative algorithm (Algorithm 1) is proposed to find continuous phase shifts by optimizing each element's phase shift iteratively.
  • Discrete Phase Shift Design: A branch-and-bound algorithm (Algorithm 2) is employed to find the optimal discrete phase shifts from the available set, leveraging the continuous solution.
  • Joint Optimization: An alternating optimization approach (Algorithm 3) is used to iteratively solve the SBS digital beamforming and IOS analog beamforming subproblems until convergence.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on theoretical analysis and simulation-based evaluation.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Dual Functionality is Key: The ability of the IOS to both reflect and refract signals is the fundamental innovation, enabling ubiquitous coverage that a purely reflective IRS cannot achieve.
  • IOS vs. IRS: The IOS offers a significant advantage over IRS by serving users on both sides, leading to potentially doubled sum-rates and extended coverage.
  • Power Ratio ($\epsilon$) Matters: The power ratio between reflected and refracted signals ($\epsilon$) plays a crucial role in optimizing performance. The optimal $\epsilon$ depends on the MU distribution and the direct link strengths.
  • Discrete Phase Shifts are Challenging but Solvable: The paper highlights the difficulty of optimizing discrete phase shifts and proposes an efficient branch-and-bound approach to find near-optimal solutions.
  • Joint Optimization is Necessary: Optimizing the SBS beamforming and IOS phase shifts jointly is essential for maximizing the system's sum-rate, as they are interdependent.

Key Results

  • Significant Sum-Rate Improvement: The proposed IOS-assisted system demonstrates substantial improvements in sum-rate compared to conventional cellular systems and IRS-assisted systems. For instance, an IOS with 30x30 elements improves the average sum-rate by approximately 2.9 times compared to a cellular system, while an IRS of the same size offers about 2.3 times improvement.
  • Coverage Extension: The IOS effectively extends service coverage to MUs on both sides of the surface, a capability lacking in IRS.
  • Impact of IOS Size and Quantization: The sum-rate increases with the number of IOS elements (M) and quantization bits ($N_D$), eventually converging to a stable value.
  • Optimal Power Ratio: The optimal power ratio ($\epsilon$) is positively correlated with the ratio of MUs on the refractive side to the reflective side ($N_t/N_r$) and negatively correlated with the direct link power. For symmetrically located MUs, $\epsilon=1$ often maximizes the sum-rate when the SBS-IOS distance is much larger than the IOS-MU distance.
  • Theoretical Upper Bound: The paper theoretically shows that the downlink sum-rate of an IOS-assisted system can be up to twice that of an IRS-assisted system.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Local Optimum: The proposed optimization algorithms converge to a local optimum, not necessarily the global optimum, due to the non-convex nature of the problem.
  • Assumptions: The analysis often relies on simplifying assumptions such as ignoring small-scale fading and assuming specific channel models.
  • Practical Implementation: While the paper proposes algorithms for discrete phase shifts, the practical implementation challenges of fabricating and controlling such metasurfaces are not deeply explored.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest exploring more advanced channel estimation techniques, considering the impact of hardware impairments, and investigating the application of IOS in more complex network scenarios. Further research into achieving the theoretical upper bound of sum-rate gain over IRS would also be valuable.

Summary updated

Abstract

Intelligent reflecting surfaces (IRSs), which are capable of adjusting radio propagation conditions by controlling the phase shifts of the waves that impinge on the surface, have been widely analyzed for enhancing the performance of wireless systems. However, the reflective properties of widely studied IRSs restrict the service coverage to only one side of the surface. In this paper, to extend the wireless coverage of communication systems, we introduce the concept of intelligent omni-surface (IOS)-assisted communication. More precisely, an IOS is an important instance of a reconfigurable intelligent surface (RIS) that can provide service coverage to mobile users (MUs) in a reflective and a refractive manner. We consider a downlink IOS-assisted communication system, where a multi-antenna small base station (SBS) and an IOS jointly perform beamforming, for improving the received power of multiple MUs on both sides of the IOS, through different reflective/refractive channels. To maximize the sum-rate, we formulate a joint IOS phase shift design and SBS beamforming optimization problem, and propose an iterative algorithm to efficiently solve the resulting non-convex program. Both theoretical analysis and simulation results show that an IOS significantly extends the service coverage of the SBS when compared to an IRS.
BibTeX
@article{zhang2022intelligent,
  author = {Shuhang Zhang and Hongliang Zhang and Boya Di and Yunhua Tan and Marco Di Renzo and Zhu Han and H. Vincent Poor and Lingyang Song},
  title = {{Intelligent Omni-Surfaces: Ubiquitous Wireless Transmission by Reflective-Refractive Metasurfaces}},
  journal = {IEEE Trans. Wireless Communications},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.1109/twc.2021.3094869},
}
Figure