TL;DR
This paper proposes integrating decision tree learning into inductive databases (IDBs) by representing decision trees as relational tables, similar to how association rules are handled. This allows users to query decision trees using standard SQL and specify complex constraints, enabling more precise and declarative data mining.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Traditional decision tree induction algorithms often produce trees that are difficult to characterize beyond their algorithmic origin. Users typically have to accept the output of a greedy algorithm without precise control over the resulting tree's properties (e.g., size, accuracy, cost). While inductive databases (IDBs) aim to bridge the gap between data and models by storing them in a queryable format, existing IDB approaches have primarily focused on association rule mining. This paper addresses the challenge of extending this IDB paradigm to decision tree learning, allowing users to express and query for decision trees based on specific, declarative constraints.
Methods
The core of the proposed approach is to represent decision trees within a relational database schema, making them queryable via SQL. This involves:
- Tree Representation: Decision trees are broken down into components that can be stored in relational tables.
Tree_sets: Represents nodes as itemsets, similar to association rule mining, but with an added "sign" attribute to indicate the presence or absence of an item.All_trees: Stores all possible trees that can be constructed from the data.Greedy_trees: Stores trees generated by standard greedy learners.Trees_charac: Stores various characteristics of the trees, such as size, error, accuracy, and cost.- Virtual Mining Views: These tables are treated as "virtual mining views." When queried, they trigger data mining algorithms to populate the necessary tuples, allowing for efficient querying and optimization.
- Exhaustive Tree Learning (CLUS-EX): To address queries requiring the discovery of all trees satisfying specific constraints (not just one from a greedy approach), an exhaustive tree learning algorithm named CLUS-EX is proposed. CLUS-EX performs a depth-first search of the tree space, employing pruning strategies based on size and error constraints to manage the search space's complexity.
- Constraint-Based Pruning: CLUS-EX leverages constraints on tree size and error to prune the search space. For example, if a partial tree's potential error, even with optimal splits, exceeds the maximum allowed error, that branch of the search is abandoned.
Datasets
The paper mentions using "symbolic UCI [18] data sets" for evaluating the CLUS-EX algorithm. Specific datasets like "soybean," "zoo," and "audiology" are listed in Table 1.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Declarative Control over Decision Trees: The most significant insight is enabling users to specify what kind of decision trees they want, rather than just how to build them. This shifts the focus from algorithmic execution to declarative specification.
- Unified Framework for Mining: By representing decision trees similarly to association rules, the paper advocates for a unified framework within inductive databases that can handle various data mining models.
- The Need for Exhaustive Search: While greedy algorithms are efficient, they cannot guarantee finding trees that satisfy specific, complex constraints. The development of CLUS-EX highlights the necessity of exhaustive search for certain types of inductive queries.
- Pruning is Crucial: The feasibility of exhaustive search hinges on effective pruning strategies. The paper demonstrates how size and error constraints can be combined to significantly reduce the search space.
- Virtual Views for Transparency: Treating mining results as virtual views enhances transparency for the user, who interacts with tables rather than complex mining algorithms.
Key Results
The paper presents a framework and a prototype system. While specific quantitative results are not the primary focus, Table 1 shows the performance of CLUS-EX on UCI datasets. It demonstrates that:
- Pruning (using both size and error constraints) significantly reduces the search space (e.g., "Red." column shows reduction factors up to 4.8).
- Restrictive constraints are crucial for limiting the number of evaluated trees and the number of resulting trees, especially on datasets with many classes.
- The system can answer various SQL queries, such as finding trees with specific accuracy and size constraints, or trees constructed by greedy algorithms with error limits.
Limitations and Future Work
- Efficiency for Large Search Spaces: The paper acknowledges that finding all possible trees is intractable in the general case. The approach relies on sufficiently restrictive constraints to make the search feasible.
- Interactive Mining: The "log" table for storing previously computed trees and queries is proposed for efficiency, but its full integration for interactive mining (reusing results from previous queries) is a future direction.
- Incremental Learning: Reusing predictive models when the database is modified is another area for future work.
- Multi-valued Attributes: The current focus is on Boolean attributes; extending the framework to multi-valued attributes is a natural next step.
- Expressiveness of Queries: Further investigation is needed to fully understand the expressiveness of the query language and how to make complex queries easier to formulate.
- Integration of Other Models: The paper suggests extending the IDB framework to include other predictive models like Bayesian Networks, requiring new storage schemas and constrained learning algorithms.
- Predicting Classes: Directly predicting the class of new examples within the IDB framework is noted as non-trivial and requiring complicated queries, indicating a need for further development.
Summary updated