Integrating BWM and modified VIKOR for age-friendly community park assessment in the context of mental health

Zhihao Zhang, Yifan Zhang, Chao LeiFrontiers in Medicine 2025 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel hybrid framework, combining the Best-Worst Method (BWM) and a Modified VIKOR approach, to assess community parks for their effectiveness in alleviating late-life depression. The study identifies key park features that contribute to mental well-being in older adults and provides a prioritized roadmap for park renovations, particularly useful in resource-constrained environments.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Late-life depression is a growing global health concern, and community parks are increasingly recognized for their potential to mitigate it. However, there's a lack of evidence detailing which specific attributes of these parks are most effective in alleviating depression among older adults. Existing park assessment tools often rely on fixed weights and may not be sensitive to the unique needs of aging populations in high-density urban settings. This study aims to bridge this gap by developing a context-specific, evidence-based evaluation framework that prioritizes park improvements for mental health benefits in the elderly.

Methods

The researchers developed a three-stage methodological framework:

  1. Literature Review & Criteria Framework: An extensive literature review identified eight key criteria for evaluating community parks concerning mental health in older adults. These criteria include: Access points, Pathways, Facilities for different activities, Open space, Amenities, Natural features, Sunlight, and Incivilities. This framework builds upon existing tools like the Neighborhood Green Space Tool (NGST) but refines it for the specific context.
  2. Best-Worst Method (BWM) for Weight Determination: To establish the relative importance of these eight criteria, 23 experts were surveyed. They used BWM to compare the "best" and "worst" criteria against each other, allowing for a robust determination of criterion weights. This method is noted for its structural simplicity and efficiency.
  3. Modified VIKOR for Evaluation and Ranking: The Modified VIKOR approach was then employed to evaluate nine community parks in Zhuhai, China. This method is chosen for its ability to balance overall performance with individual weaknesses, providing a "compromise solution." A key innovation here is the "modified" aspect, which uses normalized gap scores relative to an "aspiration level" rather than just the performance of alternatives, making it more suitable for improvement-oriented analyses. This allows for the identification of specific areas for improvement within each park.

Datasets

The study did not use traditional datasets for training machine learning models. Instead, it relied on:

  • Expert Judgment: Data was collected from 23 domain experts (urban planning, public health, environmental psychology, etc.) through questionnaires for the BWM weighting.
  • On-site Photography and Remote Auditing: Nine community parks in Zhuhai were photographed and then evaluated remotely by experts using a 10-point scale for the eight criteria. This approach is presented as a reasonable and robust evaluation method, especially for large-scale studies.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Shifting Priorities: The study reveals a significant shift in the perceived importance of park attributes for older adults' mental health compared to general environmental assessments. For instance, "Incivilities" (previously high in NGST) are less critical, while "Open space" and "Facilities for different activities" emerge as paramount.
  • Differentiated Mechanisms: The research suggests that different park attributes contribute to mental well-being through distinct mechanisms – some directly promoting relaxation (e.g., natural features), while others indirectly support it by encouraging physical activity and social interaction (e.g., activity facilities, open spaces).
  • Improvement-Oriented Evaluation: The Modified VIKOR approach, particularly with its "aspiration level" adjustment, offers a powerful tool not just for ranking parks but for diagnosing specific areas needing improvement, making it highly practical for urban planners.
  • Sunlight Matters: The inclusion and moderate weighting of "Sunlight" as a criterion highlight its emerging importance in environmental psychology for older adults, influencing mood and social interaction.

Key Results

  • Top Criteria for Depression Alleviation: Open space (16.26%), Facilities for different activities (14.27%), and Public amenities (13.50%) were identified as the most influential attributes in reducing depression risk.
  • Lower Priority Criteria: Access points (10.0%) and Pathways (10.4%) were found to be generally adequate, requiring only localized adjustments.
  • Park Rankings: The evaluation of nine parks showed notable disparities in their performance, with specific parks excelling in certain areas while lagging in others.
  • Improvement Priorities: The study provides a clear hierarchy for park renovations:
  • Highest Priority: Upgrading activity facilities, open spaces, and amenities.
  • Secondary Priority: Enhancing natural features and environmental order.
  • Tertiary Priority: Fine-tuning access points, pathways, and sunlight conditions.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Expert-Based, Not Direct Data: The study relies on expert judgment rather than direct data from older adults with depression. Future research could validate these findings through confirmatory empirical studies and experimental analysis.
  • Geographic Specificity: All experts were from mainland China and Macao. Comparative studies across different cultural and social contexts are recommended to improve external validity and generalizability.
  • Sample Size: The evaluation of only nine community park cases limits the robustness of methodological comparisons. Increasing the sample size could enable more systematic analyses of differences and applicability across various MCDM approaches.
  • Hybrid Frameworks: The authors suggest developing hybrid frameworks that integrate objective measurements with expert knowledge to enhance generalizability and operational applicability.

Summary updated

Abstract

Community park environments contribute to late-life depression alleviation through differentiated mechanisms. The BWM-Modified VIKOR framework provides an evidence-based tool for prioritizing age-friendly park renovations under limited resources. Priority should be given to upgrading activity facilities, open spaces, and amenities.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhang2025integrating,
  author = {Zhihao Zhang and Yifan Zhang and Chao Lei},
  title = {{Integrating BWM and modified VIKOR for age-friendly community park assessment in the context of mental health}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Medicine},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.3389/fmed.2025.1715370},
}
Figure