Integrated Model for Estimating GHG Emissions from Municipal Wastewater Treatment in High-population Density Cities

Dengting Guo, Peng Jiang, Wei Yu, Saeid Baroutian, Brent R. Young2023 · DOI

Abstract

The wastewater treatment industry is a significant contributor to global greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions, yet quantifying its impact—particularly in developing nations—is often hindered by data scarcity and inconsistent system boundaries. This study introduces an "Operational Data Integrated Method" (ODIM) to estimate emissions from 4,205 wastewater treatment plants (WWTPs) across China. By combining plant-level operational data with IPCC frameworks, the research quantifies national emissions at 34.18 Mt $CO_2$-eq for 2017. The findings reveal that 64.5% of these emissions are off-site, primarily from electricity and chemical consumption. Spatial analysis shows a distinct geographic divide along the "Hu Line," with eastern regions emitting four times more than the west. These results underscore the need for process optimization, energy source shifts, and targeted $N_2O$ control to meet carbon neutrality goals.

The Challenge of Quantifying Wastewater Emissions

As global efforts to mitigate climate change intensify, the wastewater treatment industry has come under scrutiny as a top-ten global carbon source. However, estimating its footprint in developing countries like China is notoriously difficult. Standard estimation methods often rely on broad per-capita averages that overlook the diversity of treatment technologies and local operational realities.

In China, the challenge is further complicated by undisclosed databases and ambiguous system boundaries. Without accurate, plant-level data, policymakers cannot effectively identify carbon-intensive processes or design mitigation strategies. This study addresses these gaps by establishing clear boundaries and utilizing granular operational data to provide a comprehensive national assessment.

System boundaries for GHG emission estimation in municipal wastewater treatment plants, distinguishing between on-site biological emissions and off-site energy/chemical consumption.

Methodology: The Operational Data Integrated Method (ODIM)

To overcome the limitations of traditional models, the researchers developed the Operational Data Integrated Method (ODIM). Unlike models that rely on population proxies, ODIM utilizes actual operational metrics—such as the removal amounts of Total Nitrogen (TN) and Chemical Oxygen Demand (COD)—to calculate direct $N_2O$ and $CH_4$ emissions.

The study's scope encompasses:

  • On-site emissions: Direct releases from biological processes and sedimentation tanks.
  • Off-site emissions: Indirect emissions from electricity consumption (pumps, aeration) and chemical usage (e.g., Polyacrylamide).
  • Statistical Analysis: Principal Component Analysis (PCA) and Pearson correlation models were employed to investigate how city-level factors like GDP, population density, and investment correlate with carbon footprints.

Data was sourced from the 2017–2018 Statistical Yearbooks of Urban Drainage and Urban Construction, alongside regional power grid emission factors provided by the Ministry of Ecological Environment.

Key Insights and Spatial Distribution

The Electricity Burden

Nearly two-thirds (64.5%) of the industry's GHG footprint is derived from off-site sources. Aeration systems alone account for 45–75% of total energy costs at WWTPs. This identifies energy grid decarbonization and aeration optimization as the most effective "low-hanging fruit" for industry-wide emission reductions.

The Hu Line Divide and Provincial Leaders

Emissions are not distributed uniformly across China. The eastern region emits approximately four times more GHG than the western region, a divide that closely follows the "Hu Line," which distinguishes areas of high and low population density. Five provinces—Shandong, Guangdong, Jiangsu, Zhejiang, and Hebei—collectively account for over 37% of the national total.

Spatial distribution of total GHG emissions across Chinese provinces, highlighting the higher emission levels in the eastern region along the Hu Line.

Technology vs. Scale

Interestingly, the study found that the physical scale of a treatment plant has a negligible impact on emission intensity. Instead, the specific technology employed is the primary driver. For instance, Anoxic-Oxic (AO) processes demonstrated higher emission intensities compared to Oxidation Ditch (OD) or Anaerobic-Anoxic-Oxic (AAO) methods. Furthermore, on-site $N_2O$ emissions were found to be twice as high as direct $CH_4$ emissions, marking $N_2O$ control as a critical target for biological process optimization.

Conclusion and Future Directions

The national GHG emission from China's wastewater treatment sector was estimated at 34.18 Mt $CO_2$-eq in 2017, with an intensity of 0.37 kg $CO_2$-eq/capita/day. While this intensity is comparable to other developing nations, the total volume necessitates aggressive mitigation.

Future work must address the "clean water trade-off," where stricter discharge standards often lead to higher energy and chemical use, potentially increasing the carbon footprint. Balancing water quality goals with GHG mitigation remains a primary challenge. Additionally, as emerging technologies like ANAMMOX are adopted for their energy benefits, researchers must ensure they do not inadvertently increase $N_2O$ releases, solving the paradox of environmentally-friendly wastewater treatment.

Summary updated

Abstract

Wastewater treatment industry, a top ten carbon emission source, has been significantly concerned in recent years.However, unclear system boundaries and undisclosed databases make it hard to estimate the greenhouse gas (GHG) emission from the wastewater treatment industry, especially in developing countries.Quantifying the total GHG emission characteristics at national level is helpful to identify the most emitted processes and propose suitable carbon mitigation strategies.This study accurately estimated the GHG emissions from China's wastewater treatment industry by a model combined with operational data integrated methods and Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change method.Then, the spatial distribution analysis and possible influential factors of total GHG emissions were further investigated by geographic model, Pearson correlation model and principal component analysis.Results showed that the national GHG emission from the total 4,205 wastewater treatment plants (WWTPs) in China in 2017 was 34.18 Mt CO2-eq, with 64.5% emitted from the consumption of electricity and chemicals.The GHG reduction strategies need to focus on process optimization and improvement at WWTPs, especially for the energy source shift, improved aeration, and on-site N2O emission from biological treatment process.After analyzing the spatial distribution characteristics, the total emission in the eastern region was approximately four times higher than that in the western region according to the Hu Line.Gross domestic product (GDP) and the treated volume of wastewater had strong positive correlations to the total GHG emissions in most first-tier cities, while there were no significant impacts on non-first-tier cities.Additionally, the impact of wastewater treatment scale on the discharge intensity is not significant, but the impact of technology is relatively obvious.
BibTeX
@misc{guo2023integrated,
  author = {Dengting Guo and Peng Jiang and Wei Yu and Saeid Baroutian and Brent R. Young},
  title = {{Integrated Model for Estimating GHG Emissions from Municipal Wastewater Treatment in High-population Density Cities}},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.46855/energy-proceedings-10687},
}
Figure