Carbon neutrality analysis of sewage treatment plant in China

Delin Fang, Wenjie Zhang, Zhihan Zheng, Qingnan Cai, Bin Chen2021 · DOI

Abstract

To support China's goals of reaching a carbon peak by 2030 and carbon neutrality by 2060, this study investigates the carbon emission performance of 4,346 wastewater treatment plants (WWTPs) across the nation. Utilizing operational data from 2014 to 2018, the research calculates direct and indirect emissions alongside potential carbon sinks, including energy self-sufficiency, water reuse, and sludge composting. The results indicate that while the industry is projected to reach its net carbon peak by 2027, full neutrality is expected by 2052. A consistent lag of approximately 24 years between peaking and neutrality was observed across most provinces, highlighting the long-term technological transition required for the sector.

Introduction: The Dual Challenge of Wastewater Treatment

Wastewater treatment is a critical infrastructure service that protects public health and ecosystems, yet it is also a significant contributor to greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions. WWTPs are major energy consumers and direct sources of methane ($CH_4$) and nitrous oxide ($N_2O$). As China intensifies its climate commitments, the wastewater sector must evolve from a carbon source into a carbon-neutral or even carbon-negative component of the urban environment.

Previous research has often focused on isolated energy efficiency metrics. This study addresses this gap by adopting a "generalized" definition of carbon neutrality, balancing all operational emissions against integrated carbon sinks. By analyzing provincial-level data, the study accounts for regional differences in economic development, natural resources, and agricultural needs.

Methodology and Evaluation Framework

The researchers developed a comprehensive framework to evaluate the carbon footprint of WWTPs, categorizing operations into two primary emission streams and three sequestration (sink) pathways:

  1. Emissions: Direct process emissions ($CH_4$, $N_2O$) and indirect emissions from grid electricity consumption.
  2. Sinks: Energy self-sufficiency (via Photovoltaics and Water Source Heat Pumps), water reuse (replacing carbon-intensive freshwater), and sludge composting (replacing chemical fertilizers).
Conceptual framework of carbon emissions and sinks in wastewater treatment plants.

To project future trends, the study employed exponential smoothing to simulate emissions through 2060. A unique provincial index was created to weight each region's potential for neutrality based on "natural endowments," such as sunlight hours for solar potential and available agricultural land for sludge application.

Key Insights: Regional Performance and the Methane Hurdle

The analysis revealed that methane emissions are a primary obstacle, accounting for approximately 35% of total GHG output. Provinces that effectively managed methane, such as Sichuan, Hubei, and Shandong, demonstrated significantly higher carbon neutrality levels.

Currently, carbon sinks provide meaningful but insufficient offsets: sludge composting reduces total emissions by 9.9%, while reclaimed water reuse accounts for a 3.0% reduction. The study also identified Water Source Heat Pumps (WSHP) as a highly effective but underutilized technology for capturing thermal energy from wastewater.

Results: The Path to 2052

Between 2014 and 2018, no Chinese province achieved carbon neutrality in its wastewater sector; in fact, neutrality efficiency declined as emissions growth outpaced sequestration efforts. However, simulation results provide a roadmap for the coming decades.

Projected years for reaching carbon peak and neutrality across Chinese provinces.

Nationally, the WWTP industry is expected to peak in 2027 and reach neutrality by 2052. Provincially, a striking "24-year lag" was identified: for most regions, achieving carbon neutrality will take roughly two and a half decades after reaching their initial carbon peak. Tibet is a notable exception, projected to reach neutrality much sooner after its peak due to its unique low-emission profile.

Conclusion and Strategic Recommendations

Achieving carbon neutrality in China's wastewater sector requires a shift toward a circular economy model. The study recommends the widespread adoption of advanced emission reduction facilities, specifically:

  • Renewable Integration: Increasing the installation of photovoltaic power generation devices in sunny regions.
  • Resource Recovery: Enhancing the proportion of reclaimed water reuse and improving sludge utilization for agriculture.
  • Thermal Efficiency: Expanding the use of Water Source Heat Pumps to recover energy from effluent.

By prioritizing these technological upgrades and tailoring strategies to provincial natural endowments, the wastewater sector can play a pivotal role in China's broader 2060 carbon neutrality mission.

Summary updated

Abstract

In order to achieve the carbon peak by 2030 and achieve the comprehensive goal of carbon neutrality by 2060, the research investigate the carbon emission performance of wastewater treatment plants (WWTPs) in China, and proposes suitable low-carbon strategies for WWTPs. The study utilized the operating data of 4346 WWTPs in China from 2014 to 2018, and calculated the carbon dioxide emissions and emission reductions. The carbon emissions include direct emissions (CH4 and N2O) during the treatment processes, and indirect carbon emissions embodied energy consumption. The carbon sinks comprise energy self-sufficient, energy saving by water reuse, and carbon emissions reduced by sludge composting. Research further simulated provincial carbon neutrality situation by meticulously giving each province a series of index determined by their per capita GDP, sunlight hours, per capita water sources, energy consumption of process design and agricultural land area. The results show that from 2014 to 2018, WWTPs in all provinces were still unable to achieve the target of carbon neutrality. Since the growth rate of carbon emissions is generally higher than that of carbon sequestration, the carbon neutrality efficiency has declined in the past five years. The direct carbon emissions of CH4 generally account for a relatively high proportion of all carbon emissions, and provinces with higher carbon neutrality level, such as Sichuan, Hubei and Shandong, also have a relatively low proportion of CH4 emissions. According to the simulating, we came up with the following results: nationwide, the net carbon emissions of WWTPs will reach its peak in 2027 and achieve carbon neutrality in 2052; provincially, the emissions of WWTPs will reach carbon neutrality in the time period between 2030-2060, and the timing of carbon neutrality is roughly the same as that of carbon peak; Except for Tibet with low carbon peak of WWTPs, carbon neutrality in other provinces can be achieved about 24 years after they reaching the peak of carbon emission respectively. Therefore, the study implicates more advanced emission reduction facilities of WWTPs are encouraged, such as the photovoltaic power generation devices, and suggest to increase the proportion of water reuse, and improve sludge utilization, in order to achieve the carbon neutrality goals.
BibTeX
@misc{fang2021carbon,
  author = {Delin Fang and Wenjie Zhang and Zhihan Zheng and Qingnan Cai and Bin Chen},
  title = {{Carbon neutrality analysis of sewage treatment plant in China}},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.46855/energy-proceedings-8265},
}
Figure