Insights into the secondary and tertiary structure of the Bovine Viral Diarrhea Virus Internal Ribosome Entry Site

Devadatta Gosavi, Iwona K. Wower, Irene K. Beckmann, Ivo L. Hofacker, Jacek Wower, Michael T. Wolfinger, Joanna Sztuba-Solińska

TL;DR

This study deciphers the intricate 3D structure of the Bovine Viral Diarrhea Virus (BVDV) Internal Ribosome Entry Site (IRES) RNA, a crucial element for viral translation. By combining biochemical probing with computational modeling, researchers revealed a conserved H-type pseudoknot within the IRES, essential for its function and offering potential targets for antiviral strategies.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Viruses often employ clever strategies to hijack host cell machinery for their own replication. One such strategy involves Internal Ribosome Entry Sites (IRESs), RNA sequences that allow ribosomes to initiate translation without the usual "cap" structure found at the beginning of most cellular mRNAs. This cap-independent translation is vital for the replication of many pathogenic viruses, including Bovine Viral Diarrhea Virus (BVDV), a significant cause of disease in cattle. While the importance of BVDV IRES is established, its precise three-dimensional structure, particularly the tertiary interactions that dictate its function, remained largely unknown. Understanding this structure is key to comprehending how it recruits ribosomes and initiates translation, and it could pave the way for developing novel antiviral therapies.

Methods

The researchers employed a powerful combination of experimental and computational techniques:

  • SHAPE-MaP (Selective 2'-Hydroxyl Acylation analyzed by Primer Extension and Mutational Profiling): This high-throughput biochemical method probes RNA secondary structure at single-nucleotide resolution. It works by selectively modifying unpaired nucleotides with an electrophilic reagent. These modifications are then detected during reverse transcription, leading to mutations in the resulting cDNA. Analyzing these mutation patterns reveals which nucleotides are accessible (unpaired) and which are protected (paired).
  • Computational Modeling (SuperFold, ernwin, SimRNA):
    • SuperFold: Used to predict secondary structure and base-pairing probabilities, incorporating the SHAPE-MaP data as constraints.
  • ernwin: A coarse-grained tool for sampling RNA 3D structures from known fragments, used to assess the steric feasibility of predicted tertiary interactions, specifically the pseudoknot.
  • SimRNA: A massively parallel replica-exchange Monte Carlo simulation method used to predict the tertiary structure by sampling the low-energy landscape of the RNA.
  • Comparative Genomics: This approach involved analyzing the BVDV IRES RNA sequences from multiple related pestivirus species to identify evolutionarily conserved structural elements, particularly the pseudoknot.
  • Covariance Analysis (R-scape): Used in conjunction with comparative genomics to statistically identify covarying base pairs, which are strong indicators of conserved structural elements.

Datasets

The study utilized:

  • In vitro synthesized BVDV IRES RNA transcripts: Both short (560 nts) and long (1296 nts) constructs were used for SHAPE-MaP probing. The long transcript included an EGFP cassette and an MS2 hairpin.
  • BVDV-1 strain NADL genomic RNA: This was the source for the IRES RNA constructs.
  • 13 representative viral genomes from the genus Pestivirus: These were downloaded from the NCBI GenBank database for comparative genomics analysis.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Modular Domain Structure: The BVDV IRES RNA folds into three distinct structural domains (I-III), a common feature in many IRES RNAs.
  • Crucial H-type Pseudoknot: A key finding is the identification and characterization of an H-type pseudoknot within domain III. This tertiary interaction is formed by two single-stranded regions and is critical for the IRES's functionality.
  • Steric Feasibility of Pseudoknot: Computational 3D modeling confirmed that the predicted pseudoknot is sterically feasible, meaning it can form in a physically realistic manner.
  • Evolutionary Conservation: Comparative genomics revealed that the pseudoknot motif is highly conserved across various Pestivirus species, underscoring its functional importance.
  • Structural Fluidity of Domain II: Domain II exhibits structural plasticity, capable of adopting either an extended hairpin or a Y-shaped structure, suggesting a dynamic role in translation initiation.
  • Potential for Antiviral Targets: The conserved and functionally critical pseudoknot presents a promising target for developing novel antiviral strategies against BVDV and potentially other pestiviruses.

Key Results

  • The SHAPE-MaP analysis provided a high-resolution secondary structure model of the BVDV IRES RNA, revealing three distinct domains.
  • Computational modeling confirmed the formation of an H-type pseudoknot in domain III, involving specific nucleotide regions (nts 381-387 and 410-416).
  • Comparative genomics identified statistically significant covariation in 22 base pairs across 13 Pestivirus genomes, with one such covarying pair located within the pseudoknot, strongly supporting its evolutionary conservation.
  • 3D simulations revealed that the pseudoknot can be formed when specific helices (SL IIIf and SL IIIg) are oriented at an acute angle, with nearly coaxial stacking between the pseudoknot helix and SL IIIf.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Domain II Flexibility: While the study identified structural fluidity in domain II, further investigation is needed to fully elucidate the functional implications of these alternative conformations.
  • Ribosome Interaction Studies: The paper suggests that future work could involve performing structural probing experiments in the presence of ribosomes to understand how the translational machinery interacts with and potentially alters the BVDV IRES structure.
  • Antiviral Strategy Development: The authors highlight the potential for developing therapeutic strategies targeting the BVDV IRES, analogous to those developed for HCV IRES, by identifying small molecule inhibitors or other agents that disrupt pseudoknot formation.
  • Broader Pestivirus IRES Analysis: While comparative genomics provided evidence for pseudoknot conservation, detailed structural studies of IRESs from other pestiviruses could further validate these findings and reveal species-specific nuances.

Summary updated

Abstract

The internal ribosome entry site (IRES) RNA of bovine viral diarrhoea virus (BVDV), an economically significant <i>Pestivirus</i>, is required for the cap-independent translation of viral genomic RNA. Thus, it is essential for viral replication and pathogenesis. We applied a combination of high-throughput biochemical RNA structure probing (SHAPE-MaP) and <i>in silico</i> modelling approaches to gain insight into the secondary and tertiary structures of BVDV IRES RNA. Our study demonstrated that BVDV IRES RNA in solution forms a modular architecture composed of three distinct structural domains (I-III). Two regions within domain III are represented in tertiary interactions to form an H-type pseudoknot. Computational modelling of the pseudoknot motif provided a fine-grained picture of the tertiary structure and local arrangement of helices in the BVDV IRES. Furthermore, comparative genomics and consensus structure predictions revealed that the pseudoknot is evolutionarily conserved among many <i>Pestivirus</i> species. These studies provide detailed insight into the structural arrangement of BVDV IRES RNA H-type pseudoknot and encompassing motifs that likely contribute to the optimal functionality of viral cap-independent translation element.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{gosavi2022insights,
  author = {Devadatta Gosavi and Iwona K. Wower and Irene K. Beckmann and Ivo L. Hofacker and Jacek Wower and Michael T. Wolfinger and Joanna Sztuba-Solińska},
  title = {{Insights into the secondary and tertiary structure of the Bovine Viral Diarrhea Virus Internal Ribosome Entry Site}},
  booktitle = {RNA},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.1080/15476286.2022.2058818},
}
Figure