Injury Risk and Comfort Assessment Applied to AmbulanceTransportation

Daniel G. Kyrollos, Terrin Stachiw, James R. Green, Robert LangloisProceedings of the International Conference of Control, Dynamic Systems, and Robotics 2020 · DOI

Abstract

Speed humps are an effective means to moderate the speed of traffic but can have adverse effects on the circulation of emergency vehicles. This study aims to use various comfort and injury risk metrics to evaluate the effects of speed hump traversal on the comfort of the passengers. Studies of human comfort during ambulance transport typically consider the peak acceleration and the wholebody vibration dose value from ISO 2631-1. The novel application of other metrics in the ambulance transport scenario, which were derived for naval and aviation settings, provided additional insight to the human biodynamic response and comfort. The following parameters were considered in the study: peak seat acceleration, dynamic response index, peak lumbar acceleration, bandwidth-limited power-spectral density, and the average acceleration onset derivative (average jerk). In-vehicle road tests were conducted in a Type III ambulance on flat-top and sinusoidal speed humps at various traversing speeds. Results from this experiment show that speeds over 20 km/hr will result in some degree of discomfort to passengers in the ambulance. Additional experiments are needed to verify the consistency of these parameters, but this study has provided a proof of concept for further studies.

Introduction

Speed humps serve as critical traffic-calming tools but present significant operational challenges for emergency medical services (EMS). For ambulances, these humps represent discrete "shock" events rather than continuous vibrations. Such events can delay response times, complicate patient care, and pose injury risks to clinical staff. Traditional human vibration assessments, such as ISO 2631-1, are optimized for long-term exposure and often fail to capture the impact of high-amplitude, transient shocks. This study addresses this gap by applying metrics from aviation and naval engineering—specifically designed for high-intensity shocks—to the ambulance transport context.

Methods

Experimental data were collected using a Type III ambulance on a 2.7 km test circuit in Ottawa, Canada. The study evaluated two distinct speed hump geometries: sinusoidal and flat-top profiles.

Comparison of sinusoidal (a) and flat-top (b) speed hump profiles used in the study.

The ambulance traversed these humps at speeds ranging from 15 to 40 km/hr. A LORD Microstrain 3DMGX3 inertial measurement unit (IMU) was mounted to the vehicle floor to record vertical acceleration at 100 Hz. Five metrics were analyzed:

  1. Peak Seat Acceleration ($a_{peak}$): Maximum vertical thrust.
  2. Dynamic Response Index (DRI): A biodynamic model originally used for aircraft ejection seats that treats the human spine as a single-degree-of-freedom spring-mass-damper system.
  3. Peak Lumbar Acceleration (ISO 2631-5): A neural-network-based estimate of spinal response.
  4. Bandwidth-Limited Power-Spectral Density (BL PSD): Energy within the 4–10 Hz range, where the human body is most sensitive.
  5. Average Jerk: The rate of change of acceleration.
The Dynamic Response Index (DRI) model representing the human spine as a single-degree-of-freedom system.

Results and Discussion

The study identified 20 km/hr as a critical threshold for passenger comfort. Below this speed, the ride remains relatively smooth; above it, discomfort increases sharply. At 30 km/hr, vertical acceleration typically exceeds 0.4g, a level associated with significant discomfort.

Geometry played a vital role: flat-top humps generally produced lower peak accelerations and DRI values than sinusoidal humps at equivalent speeds. This suggests that hump design is a key variable for emergency routes. While DRI and Peak Lumbar Acceleration were highly correlated, they proved more sensitive to hump shape than simple peak acceleration. Interestingly, "Average Jerk" did not correlate strongly with speed, likely due to the ambulance suspension's effectiveness at higher-speed impacts compared to low-speed "heave" movements.

Regarding safety, while discomfort was high, DRI values remained near 3.0—well below the 17.7 threshold for a 10% risk of serious spinal injury. This indicates that while uncomfortable, single hump traversals at these speeds are unlikely to cause acute trauma.

Conclusion

This research demonstrates that speeds exceeding 20 km/hr over speed humps cause measurable discomfort for ambulance passengers. While peak acceleration is a robust metric, biodynamic models like the DRI offer deeper insights into spinal risk. Future work should expand the sample size, consider different vehicle types, and investigate the cumulative effects of multi-shock exposure over a paramedic's career. Additionally, the response of supine patients to horizontal shocks warrants further investigation.

Summary updated

Abstract

Speed humps are an effective means to moderate the speed of traffic but can have adverse effects on the circulation of emergency vehicles. This study aims to use various comfort and injury risk metrics to evaluate the effects of speed hump traversal on the comfort of the passengers. Studies of human comfort during ambulance transport typically consider the peak acceleration and the wholebody vibration dose value from ISO 2631-1. The novel application of other metrics in the ambulance transport scenario, which were derived for naval and aviation settings, provided additional insight to the human biodynamic response and comfort. The following parameters were considered in the study: peak seat acceleration, dynamic response index, peak lumbar acceleration, bandwidth-limited power-spectral density, and the average acceleration onset derivative (average jerk). In-vehicle road tests were conducted in a Type III ambulance on flat-top and sinusoidal speed humps at various traversing speeds. Results from this experiment show that speeds over 20 km/hr will result in some degree of discomfort to passengers in the ambulance. Additional experiments are needed to verify the consistency of these parameters, but this study has provided a proof of concept for further studies.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{kyrollos2020injury,
  author = {Daniel G. Kyrollos and Terrin Stachiw and James R. Green and Robert Langlois},
  title = {{Injury Risk and Comfort Assessment Applied to AmbulanceTransportation}},
  booktitle = {Proceedings of the International Conference of Control, Dynamic Systems, and Robotics},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.11159/cdsr20.156},
}
Figure