Dynamic Modelling of the Standard Neonatal Patient Transport System using a Newton-Euler Based Formulation in the Roll Plane

Keely Gibb, Patrick Kehoe, Jason E. Hurley, Cheryl Aubertin, Kim Greenwood, Andrew Ibey, Stephanie Redpath, Adrian D. C. Chan, James R. Green, Robert G. R. LangloisProceedings of the International Conference of Control, Dynamic Systems, and Robotics 2022 · DOI

Abstract

Transport of neonatal patients between critical care units can expose patients to whole-body vibrations which may pose a risk to the vulnerable patients' health. This study characterizes and mitigates vibrations transmitted by the Neonatal Patient Transport System (NPTS) used in Ontario. A 3-degree-of-freedom planar model in the roll plane was developed using the Newton-Euler method. Simulation results for vertical motion closely match road test data, while the roll direction requires further calibration. This model serves as a first step toward a full 3D simulation for optimizing patient safety during transport.

Introduction

Transporting critically ill neonates is a high-stakes operation where physical vibrations from the ambulance floor pose a clinical risk, including potential intracranial hemorrhage. To mitigate these risks, researchers are developing high-fidelity dynamic simulations to understand how vibrations propagate through the stretcher and incubator to the infant. Building such a model requires identifying unknown system parameters like stiffness and damping, which is best achieved through simplified planar models before moving to complex 3D simulations.

Methodology

The researchers developed a 3-Degree-of-Freedom (3-DOF) planar roll model to represent the NPTS. This model simplifies the system into a rigid body (stretcher and incubator) and a point mass (the patient) moving in the roll plane.

Schematic of the 3-DOF roll plane model showing vertical displacement (q1), angular roll (q2), and patient displacement (q3).

Key technical aspects include:

  • Newton-Euler Formulation: Equations of motion were derived by balancing forces and moments and cross-validated against Lagrange’s equations.
  • Kinematic Modeling: The model tracks vertical displacement ($q_1$), angular roll ($q_2$), and the relative displacement of the patient on the mattress ($q_3$).
  • Parameter Tuning: The simulation was tuned using real-world vibration data from the Ottawa Paramedic Service (OPS), recorded during a high-speed arterial road transport using a Stryker Power-PRO stretcher and a 2.5 kg manikin.

Results and Discussion

The study successfully identified critical vibration modes and established baseline mechanical parameters.

Comparison of acceleration Power Spectral Density (PSD) between road test data and the dynamic model, highlighting the peak near 9 Hz.
  • Vertical Accuracy: The simulated vertical acceleration Power Spectral Density (PSD) closely matched road test data, particularly capturing a significant vibration mode around 9 Hz.
  • Natural Frequencies: Identified system natural frequencies were 4.11 Hz, 8.33 Hz, and 9.26 Hz.
  • Tuned Parameters: Baseline values were established for stretcher stiffness ($K = 330,000$ N/m) and mattress stiffness ($k = 8,000$ N/m).
  • Roll Deviation: While vertical motion was accurate, the roll (angular) response deviated from road data, showing a high-magnitude peak at a lower frequency than expected. This suggests the "sliding pin joint" model for the floor-to-stretcher interface requires further refinement.

Conclusion and Future Work

While the vertical model is highly accurate, the roll plane discrepancy indicates a need for more complex modeling of the stretcher's mechanical interface. Future work will focus on refining angular parameters, integrating pitch models, and eventually scaling to a full 7-degree-of-freedom 3D model to simulate multi-axis transport conditions in both ground and air ambulances.

Summary updated

Abstract

Transport of neonatal patients between critical care units can expose patients to whole-body vibrations which may pose a risk to the vulnerable patients' health. The concern for patient safety has motivated a study on characterizing and mitigating vibrations transmitted by the Neonatal Patient Transport System (NPTS) that is used in ground and air ambulances in Ontario. To supplement invehicle testing, a simulation is being developed to replicate the motion of the NPTS. The first stage of developing this model involves simulating a planar representation of the NPTS in order to identify unknown system parameters. This paper outlines the derivation of equations of motion of the NPTS in the roll plane by applying the Newton-Euler method. The acceleration power spectral density (PSD) of the simulated motion is compared against recorded road test data to aid in tuning the system parameters. Simulated results show similar frequency responses for the vertical motion of the system. However, the roll direction deviates from the measured response. Further optimization is required to calibrate and validate this model to ensure it represents the angular motion of the system and reproduces behaviour exhibited in various transport conditions.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{gibb2022dynamic,
  author = {Keely Gibb and Patrick Kehoe and Jason E. Hurley and Cheryl Aubertin and Kim Greenwood and Andrew Ibey and Stephanie Redpath and Adrian D. C. Chan and James R. Green and Robert G. R. Langlois},
  title = {{Dynamic Modelling of the Standard Neonatal Patient Transport System using a Newton-Euler Based Formulation in the Roll Plane}},
  booktitle = {Proceedings of the International Conference of Control, Dynamic Systems, and Robotics},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.11159/cdsr22.125},
}
Figure