Information Theory With Kernel Methods

Francis R. Bach

Abstract

This paper establishes a rigorous bridge between kernel methods and classical information theory by defining entropy and divergence through covariance operators in Reproducing Kernel Hilbert Spaces (RKHS). By adapting tools from quantum information theory—specifically von Neumann entropy—to the setting of kernel matrices, the author provides a framework to estimate Shannon-like quantities from data. The proposed estimators achieve $O(1/\sqrt{n})$ convergence rates and introduce a new family of variational inference methods based on kernelized lower bounds.

1. Introduction

Information theory serves as the mathematical foundation for modern data science, yet estimating its core quantities—such as Shannon entropy and Kullback-Leibler (KL) divergence—remains a significant challenge for continuous, high-dimensional distributions. Traditional estimation methods often rely on density estimation, which suffers from the curse of dimensionality, or restrictive parametric assumptions that limit flexibility.

In parallel, kernel methods have emerged as a powerful tool for distribution comparison, most notably through the Maximum Mean Discrepancy (MMD). However, while MMD provides a distance between mean embeddings, it lacks a direct connection to the information-theoretic quantities used in optimization and inference. This research addresses this disconnect by defining "kernelized" versions of entropy and mutual information that are computationally efficient, theoretically grounded, and converge to classical Shannon counterparts in the limit.

2. Theoretical Framework

The core methodological innovation involves shifting focus from the mean element (first-order moment) to the covariance operator (second-order moment) of a distribution $p$ in an RKHS. The covariance operator is defined as: $$\Sigma_p = \int_{\mathcal{X}} \phi(x)\phi(x)^* dp(x)$$

By treating these operators similarly to density matrices in Quantum Information Theory, the author defines "Kernel Entropy" using the von Neumann entropy formula: $tr(\Sigma \log \Sigma)$. This approach allows for the definition of a Kernel KL Divergence that inherits properties from quantum relative entropy.

2.1 Key Technical Contributions

  • Integral Representations: The paper utilizes integral formulas to handle the matrix logarithm of infinite-dimensional operators, facilitating practical estimation without requiring explicit diagonalization of infinite operators.
  • Empirical Estimators: The framework demonstrates that these quantities can be estimated directly from the $n \times n$ kernel matrix $K$ of a sample, making the theory applicable to finite datasets.
  • Kernel Learning: A novel variational approach is introduced where kernel parameters (such as bandwidth) are optimized to tighten the kernel-based lower bounds relative to true Shannon values.

3. Key Insights and Ideas

Several critical properties emerge from this kernelized information-theoretic framework:

  • The Universal Lower Bound: A central finding is that Kernel KL divergence serves as a universal lower bound on the Shannon KL divergence. This property ensures that optimizing the kernelized surrogate is a "safe" operation for variational inference.
  • Bandwidth as a Bridge: The paper proves that Shannon entropy is the limit of kernel entropy as the kernel bandwidth approaches zero. This provides a unified view where kernels effectively "smooth" the information; as the smoothing vanishes, classical theory is recovered.
  • Convexity and Duality: Kernel relative entropy is shown to be jointly convex in its arguments. This allows for the application of convex duality to derive new upper bounds on log-partition functions, which are essential for Bayesian inference.
  • Submodularity: Kernel entropy preserves submodularity, a property vital for applications in feature selection and subset optimization.

4. Empirical Validation and Results

As a foundational theoretical work, the paper validates its claims using illustrative synthetic datasets, including the Torus ($[0, 1]$) for periodic behavior and the Hypercube ($\{-1, 1\}^d$) for multivariate discrete comparisons.

4.1 Convergence and Complexity

  • Convergence Rates: Empirical estimators for kernel entropy converge at a rate of $O(1/\sqrt{n})$. Notably, this rate is robust to high dimensionality, avoiding the typical slow convergence of density-based estimators.
  • Computational Cost: While basic estimation requires $O(n^3)$ due to eigenvalue decomposition of the kernel matrix, the paper demonstrates that Nyström sampling can reduce this complexity to $O(m^2n)$, where $m$ is the number of landmark points.
  • Variational Tightness: The "Kernel Learning" approach—optimizing the kernel to maximize the lower bound—significantly improves the accuracy of entropy estimates compared to using fixed, "naive" kernels.

5. Discussion and Limitations

While the framework provides a robust bridge between kernels and information theory, several areas for future work remain. The computational cost, even with Nyström approximations, remains higher than simple first-order kernel methods. Additionally, while kernel mutual information characterizes independence, it does not fully characterize conditional independence, suggesting a need for more complex conditional covariance operators.

Future research directions include extending the framework to Rényi entropies and developing large-scale implementations of Kernel Variational Inference for applied machine learning tasks.

Summary updated

Abstract

We consider the analysis of probability distributions through their associated covariance operators from reproducing kernel Hilbert spaces. We show that the von Neumann entropy and relative entropy of these operators are intimately related to the usual notions of Shannon entropy and relative entropy, and share many of their properties. They come together with efficient estimation algorithms from various oracles on the probability distributions. We also consider product spaces and show that for tensor product kernels, we can define notions of mutual information and joint entropies, which can then characterize independence perfectly, but only partially conditional independence. We finally show how these new notions of relative entropy lead to new upper-bounds on log partition functions, that can be used together with convex optimization within variational inference methods, providing a new family of probabilistic inference methods.
BibTeX
@article{bach2022information,
  author = {Francis R. Bach},
  title = {{Information Theory With Kernel Methods}},
  journal = {IEEE Transactions on Information Theory},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.1109/tit.2022.3211077},
}
Figure