Influence of Structure, Roughness, Microhardness and Friction Coefficient of Zinc Coating on the Tightening Torque of a Threaded Connection

В. В. Ефремов, O. S. Bondareva, O. S. Dobychina, Srikanth PillaTrenie 2023 · DOI

Introduction

In mechanical assembly, the reliability of a threaded connection is fundamentally determined by the clamping force (preload) it exerts. Engineers typically control this force by applying a specific tightening torque. However, the conversion of torque into axial tension is heavily influenced by the friction coefficients of the contacting surfaces. Zinc coatings, while essential for corrosion protection, introduce significant variability into this relationship. This study, published in the journal Friction and Wear (2023), investigates how different zinc application methods alter the mechanical and tribological properties of fasteners, ultimately affecting the required tightening torque.

The Friction-Torque Relationship

The primary challenge in fastener engineering is that "zinc-plated" is not a uniform specification. Depending on whether a bolt is hot-dipped, electroplated, or treated with thermal diffusion, its surface characteristics change. If a standard torque is applied without considering the specific coating's friction profile, the resulting joint may be under-tightened, risking loosening under vibration, or over-tightened, risking catastrophic bolt failure. This research provides empirical data to calibrate these critical torque-tension relationships for various industrial coatings.

Methodology

The researchers evaluated fasteners (sizes M3, M10, and M16) treated with six distinct zinc coating techniques:

  1. Galvanic (Electroplating): Electrochemical deposition.
  2. Thermal Diffusion: Heating parts in a zinc powder mixture.
  3. Gas-Thermal Spraying: Molten zinc applied via a gas stream.
  4. Hot-Dip (Pure Zn): Immersion in molten zinc.
  5. Hot-Dip (Galfan): Immersion in a Zn + 5% Al alloy.
  6. Zinc-Lamellar: A non-electrolytic coating consisting of zinc and aluminum flakes.

The study measured surface roughness ($R_a$), microhardness, and the friction coefficient ($\mu$) using a "finger-disk" tribometer to simulate sliding contact in threads. These values were then used to calculate nominal tightening torques and compared against the Russian industrial standard RD 37.001.131–89.

Key Findings: Hardness, Roughness, and Friction

The experimental results revealed several critical insights into the behavior of these coatings:

  • The Hardness Paradox: Thermal diffusion coatings exhibited the highest microhardness, suggesting superior wear resistance. In contrast, traditional hot-dip galvanizing produced the softest layers.
  • Surface Roughness: Gas-thermal and thermal-diffusion methods resulted in the highest surface roughness ($R_a$). Interestingly, the study found that high roughness did not always correlate linearly with higher friction, indicating that the chemical composition and the "smearing" behavior of the zinc layer also play significant roles in tribological performance.
  • Friction Extremes: Zinc-lamellar and thermal diffusion coatings showed the highest friction coefficients. Using these coatings with standard torque settings intended for galvanic bolts would likely result in insufficient clamping force.

Engineering Implications and Standards

A key objective was to determine which coatings align with existing industrial norms. The study found that only hot-dip galvanizing and gas-thermal spraying naturally met the torque requirements of the RD 37.001.131–89 standard. All other coating types require "correction factors." For high-friction coatings like zinc-lamellar, the researchers conclude that the use of additional lubricants is mandatory to reduce friction to predictable levels and ensure joint integrity.

Conclusion

The method of zinc application is a decisive factor in the mechanical performance of threaded joints. For engineers, this means that torque specifications must be tailored to the specific coating type. Future work should address how these friction coefficients evolve over multiple tightening cycles and how environmental stressors, such as salt spray corrosion, affect the torque-tension relationship after assembly.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{2023influence,
  author = {В. В. Ефремов and O. S. Bondareva and O. S. Dobychina and Srikanth Pilla},
  title = {{Influence of Structure, Roughness, Microhardness and Friction Coefficient of Zinc Coating on the Tightening Torque of a Threaded Connection}},
  booktitle = {Trenie},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.32864/0202-4977-2023-44-5-456-462},
}
Figure