Abstract
Many key military targets have been moved underground to improve battlefield survivability. To study the influence of explosion distance on the dynamic mechanical response of underground fortification, full-time numerical simulations were conducted using the Continuum-Discontinuum Element Method (CDEM). Four simulations at different explosion distances (5m, 10m, 15m, and 20m) were analyzed for displacement and fracture characteristics. Results show that damage weakens as distance increases; rock penetration volume dropped from 24.78 m³ at 5m to 0 m³ at 20m. Crack evolution follows a four-stage characteristic, with tensile fracture becoming the dominant mode at greater distances.
Introduction
The survivability of critical infrastructure and military assets increasingly depends on deep underground placement. However, the development of earth-penetrating projectiles has necessitated a deeper understanding of how detonation distance—or stand-off distance—affects structural integrity. Traditional continuum-based numerical models often fail to capture the complex transition from solid rock to fragmented debris following an explosion. This study utilizes a hybrid modeling approach to bridge this gap and provide quantitative insights into fortification failure.
Numerical Methodology
The researchers employed the Continuum-Discontinuum Element Method (CDEM), which integrates continuous simulation for solid states with discrete simulation for fragmentation. The model features a 15m wide, 10m high fortification with 1.8m thick concrete walls, embedded within a 200m x 250m rock mass.
The detonation of TNT was simulated using the Jones-Wilkins-Lee (JWL) equation of state at four distances: 5m, 10m, 15m, and 20m. A "crack ratio" ($\alpha$) was introduced to quantify the extent of damage by measuring the ratio of cracked interfaces to the total interface area.
Results and Discussion
Crack Evolution and Failure Modes
The study identified a distinct four-stage crack evolution process:
- Initial Shock: A rapid spike in cracking due to the primary shock wave.
- Gas Expansion: Slower growth as explosive gases expand.
- Secondary Impact: A second surge caused by collapsed concrete hitting the fortification floor.
- Equilibrium: Stabilization of the damage state.
At a distance of 5m, the structure experiences catastrophic failure through a combination of shear and tensile stresses. As shown in the displacement plots, this leads to significant rock penetration into the interior.
The Impact of Stand-off Distance
The volume of rock entering the fortification is a critical metric for survivability. At 5m, 24.78 m³ of rock breached the interior. This volume remained relatively stable at 10m but dropped sharply as the distance increased further. At 20m, the rock penetration volume reached 0 m³. While the concrete walls still exhibited tensile cracking at 20m, the structure retained sufficient bearing capacity to prevent a total breach, effectively functioning as a shelter.
Conclusion
The distance of an explosion is a primary determinant of underground fortification survivability. Increasing the stand-off distance from 5m to 20m shifts the failure mode from catastrophic shear-induced collapse to manageable tensile cracking. Future research should extend these findings to 3D models and investigate the protective benefits of steel reinforcement within the concrete walls.
Summary updated