Influence of differential leadership behavior on employees’ deviant innovation: Based on dual perspectives of insider and outsider subordinates

Jie Lü, Linrong Zhang, Mengyun Wu, Muhammad Imran, Qi He, Yun ZhaoFrontiers in Psychology 2022 · DOI

Abstract

Differential leadership (DL) is a localized leadership style characterized by the unequal distribution of resources and trust between "insider" and "outsider" subordinates. This study explores how such leadership dynamics influence "deviant innovation"—creative behaviors that occur outside formal organizational channels. Utilizing evolutionary game theory and Monte Carlo simulations, the research identifies that the propensity for deviant innovation is driven by distinct psychological triggers: high risk-taking traits in insider subordinates and high internal control personalities in outsider subordinates. The findings suggest that differential treatment can paradoxically stimulate innovation across the hierarchy by leveraging the specific psychological capital of different employee groups.

Introduction

Innovation is rarely a purely linear, top-down process. Often, breakthroughs emerge from "deviant innovation" (or bootlegging), where employees pursue creative ideas without formal authorization or in violation of established norms. While traditionally viewed as a challenge to organizational order, deviant innovation is increasingly recognized as a vital source of competitive advantage.

In many organizational cultures, particularly those influenced by the "Differential Sequence Pattern," leaders do not treat all subordinates equally. This "Differential Leadership" (DL) creates a bifurcated workforce: insiders who enjoy trust and resources, and outsiders who remain at the periphery. This paper investigates how these two groups navigate the decision to innovate deviantly, using dynamic game reasoning to move beyond static survey-based research.

Methodology: Evolutionary Game Theory

To understand the decision-making process, the study employs Evolutionary Game Theory and Monte Carlo simulations. The researchers modeled an organizational network where employees decide whether to perform deviant innovation based on perceived benefits and social imitation.

The Payoff Matrix

The core of the game reasoning lies in the payoff matrix, which defines the strategic interactions between insiders and outsiders. The model considers four primary outcomes based on whether each group chooses to innovate or adhere to formal norms. These interactions are governed by the "Fermi Criterion," simulating how employees adopt strategies that appear more successful among their peers.

Payoff matrix for deviant innovative behaviors between insider and outsider subordinates.

Simulation Parameters

The study utilized a simulated network of $N$ employees with a power-law degree distribution (average degree $q=6$). By running 200 independent Monte Carlo simulations, the researchers analyzed how variables like Psychological Capital (PsyCap) and personality traits influence the probability of innovation over time.

Key Insights and Theoretical Framework

The Dual Role of Differential Leadership

The research posits that DL plays a dual role in stimulating innovation. For insiders, the motivation stems from a desire to maintain their privileged status and reciprocate the leader's trust. For outsiders, deviant innovation serves as a strategic tool to "reverse" their disadvantaged position, demonstrating value that might earn them entry into the inner circle.

Personality as the Catalyst

The leadership style alone does not guarantee innovation; specific personality traits act as the necessary "triggers":

  • Insiders and Risk-Taking: Insiders typically have more to lose. Therefore, only those with high risk-taking traits are likely to engage in deviant innovation. Without this trait, insiders prefer the safety of the status quo to protect their existing benefits.
  • Outsiders and Internal Control: For those in the outer circle, a high "internal control" personality—the belief that one can shape their own destiny—is crucial. These individuals view deviant innovation as a viable path to overcome the "outsider" label through sheer performance.

Results and Discussion

Insider Dynamics

Simulations indicate that for high-risk-taking insiders, the probability of deviant innovation correlates positively with their psychological capital. As their sense of security and resource access grows, they feel empowered to take calculated risks for the organization's benefit.

Outsider Dynamics

Conversely, for outsiders with high internal control, the probability of innovation actually increases as their perceived psychological capital decreases. This suggests a "rebound effect" where the psychological loss of being excluded drives high-agency individuals to take significant risks to change their standing within the hierarchy.

Conclusion and Practical Implications

This study demonstrates that deviant innovation is a rational response to biased leadership treatment. For managers, the takeaway is not necessarily to enforce absolute equality, but to understand the unique psychological triggers of their staff. To foster innovation, leaders should:

  1. Encourage risk-taking among trusted insiders by providing a safety net for creative failure.
  2. Identify high-agency outsiders and provide them with clear, albeit informal, pathways to improve their status through innovative contributions.

While the model is rooted in specific cultural patterns, it offers a robust framework for understanding how perceived inequality can be channeled into creative energy rather than organizational friction.

Summary updated

Abstract

Differential leadership as a localized leadership style gradually developed on the basis of the Pattern of Differential Sequence. It plays a dual role in stimulating "insider subordinates" and "outsider subordinates" through the dynamic transformation of the roles. Using the process of game reasoning, the study identifies the differing principles used by insider subordinates and outsider subordinates in implementing deviant innovative behaviors. The simulation graph presents the perceived benefits of employees performing or not performing deviant innovative behaviors as clues during the reasoning process, and implements deviant innovative behaviors for the high risk-taking trait of insider subordinates and the high internal control personality of outsider subordinates who implement deviant innovation. The theoretical derivation of behavior provides relevant references, and provides counter measures for effectively promoting employees' deviant innovative behavior in the context of differential leadership.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{lu2022influence,
  author = {Jie Lü and Linrong Zhang and Mengyun Wu and Muhammad Imran and Qi He and Yun Zhao},
  title = {{Influence of differential leadership behavior on employees’ deviant innovation: Based on dual perspectives of insider and outsider subordinates}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Psychology},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3389/fpsyg.2022.945598},
}
Figure