Does Differentiated Leadership Threaten Who I Am? Introducing a Self-Verification Perspective to Explain the Curvilinear Effect of Differentiated Empowering Leadership

Shao‐Long Li, Shudi Liao, Fang Sun, Zhiwen GuoFrontiers in Psychology 2019 · DOI

Abstract

Based on self-verification theory, this research explores whether, how, and when differentiated empowering leadership (DEL) has curvilinear effects on relationship conflict and subsequent counterproductive work behaviors toward individuals (CWBI). Analyzing data from 297 members across 78 teams, the study found that DEL has a U-shaped effect on relationship conflict specifically in teams with high competence variance. This conflict then drives CWBI.

Introduction: The Paradox of Empowerment

In modern management, "empowerment" is often viewed as an absolute positive. However, leaders rarely empower everyone equally, often granting more autonomy to those they trust or deem more capable. This practice, known as Differentiated Empowering Leadership (DEL), has shown inconsistent effects in previous research—sometimes improving performance, other times destroying morale.

This study proposes that the missing link is Self-Verification Theory (SVT). Humans have a fundamental need for others to see them as they see themselves. When a leader's level of empowerment mismatches a member's self-view of their competence—either by over-empowering a "low-competence" individual (causing stress) or under-empowering a "high-competence" individual (causing resentment)—it creates a threat to the individual's self-concept, leading to team-wide relationship conflict.

Theoretical model illustrating the relationships between differentiated empowering leadership, team competence variance, relationship conflict, and CWBI.

Methods and Data

The researchers employed a multi-level, time-lagged survey design involving 78 construction technician teams (297 individuals) in China. Data collection occurred in three stages over four weeks to minimize common-method bias:

  1. Time 1: Members reported self-competence and perceived empowering leadership.
  2. Time 2: Members reported levels of relationship conflict.
  3. Time 3: Leaders evaluated members' Counterproductive Work Behavior toward Individuals (CWBI).

The study utilized multilevel path analytical modeling and Monte Carlo bootstrapping to test for "curvilinear mediated moderation," quantifying team-level heterogeneity using the Within-Team Coefficient of Variance (CV).

Key Insights: Identity over Fairness

The research highlights several critical dynamics within teams:

  • The "Sweet Spot" of Differentiation: A medium level of differentiation is often optimal. Extreme levels—either treating everyone identically regardless of skill or creating massive gaps between "favorites" and others—spike relationship conflict.
  • The Activation of Identity: DEL's U-shaped effect only emerged in teams with high competence variance. In teams where skills are uniform, members are less likely to use leadership behavior as a primary signal of their self-worth.
  • From Conflict to Deviance: The friction from self-verification failure translates into tangible negative behaviors (CWBI), such as unhelpfulness or speaking poorly of colleagues.

Key Results

The statistical analysis supported the moderated curvilinear hypothesis. As shown in the regression results, the interaction between differentiated empowering leadership squared and team competence variance was significant.

Regression analysis results showing the moderated effects on relationship conflict.

Key findings include:

  • Moderated Curvilinear Effect: In high competence variance teams, the relationship between DEL and conflict followed a clear U-shaped curve.
  • Downstream Impact: Relationship conflict significantly predicted CWBI (B = 0.25, p < 0.01).
  • Bootstrapping Results: The difference in the indirect effect of leadership on toxic behavior was significant when comparing high vs. low competence variance teams (95% CI = [-0.567, -0.004]).

Conclusion and Future Directions

This study shifts the focus from "fairness" to "identity" in leadership research. While conducted in a Chinese cultural context, it provides a robust framework for understanding how leadership differentiation affects team harmony. Future research should explore if these patterns hold for other leadership styles (e.g., transformational) or in different cultural settings where power distance varies.

Summary updated

Abstract

Based on the self-verification theory, this research proposed a multi-level model for exploring whether, how, and when differentiated leadership had curvilinear effects on relationship conflict within a team and further on team members' counterproductive work behaviors toward individuals (CWBI). Drawing on a sample of 297 team members nested in 78 teams, we found that differentiated empowering leadership had no direct curvilinear effects on relationship conflict. However, the results showed that the team competence variance could moderate the curvilinear relationship between differentiated empowering leadership and relationship conflict. Specifically, only in teams with high competence variance among members, differentiated empowering leadership had a U-shaped effect on relationship conflict. Moreover, differentiated empowering leadership interacted with team competence variance had a downstream effect on team members' CWBI through relationship conflict. We ended up by discussing the theoretical and practical implications of these findings.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{li2019does,
  author = {Shao‐Long Li and Shudi Liao and Fang Sun and Zhiwen Guo},
  title = {{Does Differentiated Leadership Threaten Who I Am? Introducing a Self-Verification Perspective to Explain the Curvilinear Effect of Differentiated Empowering Leadership}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Psychology},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.3389/fpsyg.2019.01903},
}
Figure