The forming mechanism of leader empowering behavior based on goal theory

Pengbo Li, Yuqing Sun, Ming LeiAdvances 2019 · DOI

Introduction

In a rapidly changing global environment, leader empowering behavior (LEB)—the practice of sharing power and granting autonomy to subordinates—has become a cornerstone of organizational success. While extensive research has documented the positive outcomes of empowerment on employee creativity and performance, a critical question remains: what actually drives a leader to empower their team in the first place?

This research shifts the focus from the consequences of empowerment to its origins. By applying Goal Theory, the authors propose a relational model where LEB is not merely a top-down decision but a response to aligned motivations within the team.

The Problem: Beyond the "Leader-Centric" Bias

Current literature on leadership empowerment faces two primary challenges. First, there is theoretical fragmentation; existing studies often look at isolated factors like a leader's personality or organizational culture without a unifying framework. Second, there is a persistent leader-centric bias. Most models treat empowerment as a unilateral choice made by the leader, overlooking how subordinates actively influence this process through their own goals and behaviors.

The Proposed Framework: Goal Congruence as the Engine

To address these gaps, the authors introduce a model centered on Goal Congruence. They argue that empowerment is triggered when the goals of the leader, the subordinate, and the team align.

The theoretical framework of leader empowering behavior formation based on goal congruence.

The core of this mechanism involves two types of alignment:

  1. Leader-Subordinate Goal Congruence (LSGC): When a leader perceives that an employee's personal goals match their own, the perceived risk of delegating authority decreases.
  2. Team-Member Goal Congruence (TMGC): Alignment at the team level ensures that individual autonomy serves the collective mission.

As shown in the framework, these goal relationships initiate a process that affects both the leader (increasing trust) and the subordinate (increasing task commitment), ultimately manifesting as specific empowering behaviors.

Mediators and Moderators

The model identifies Trust and Commitment as the psychological bridges. Goal alignment fosters a leader's trust in a subordinate's judgment and increases the subordinate's psychological readiness to handle power. However, this process is not universal. It is moderated by:

  • Leader Traits: Factors like high power distance or a strong desire for control can inhibit empowerment even when goals align.
  • Subordinate Factors: Proactive behavior and "Demands-Abilities Fit" determine if the employee is actually prepared to utilize the granted autonomy effectively.

Methodology

The paper outlines a rigorous three-stage research design to validate this framework:

  1. Qualitative Multi-Case Study: Deep-dive interviews across 5–10 high-performing teams to identify nuances in "goal fusion."
  2. Longitudinal Dyadic Survey: Collecting data from leader-subordinate pairs at multiple time points to establish that goal alignment precedes empowerment.
  3. Comprehensive Model Validation: A large-scale survey targeting 200–250 teams in the hospitality and catering industries (e.g., Starbucks, Home Inn) to test the full structural model. These industries are ideal because individual branches operate with high local autonomy.

Implications and Future Directions

This research contributes significantly to leadership theory by providing a systematic explanation for the emergence of empowerment. For practitioners, it suggests that fostering empowerment starts with goal setting. Managers should focus on aligning individual and team objectives to create a natural environment for power-sharing.

Future research should explore whether these mechanisms hold in more technical fields like R&D, where goals may be more abstract, and across different cultural contexts where baseline attitudes toward hierarchy (Power Distance) vary.

Summary updated

Abstract

<p id="C2">With the profound changes in the external environment, how to promote leaders’ empowering behavior has been emphasized both practically and academically. However, previous researches lacks systematically theoretical analysis of the formation of leader empowering behavior, and have the tendency of "leader-centered" bias, which lead to their failure to solve the practical issues. Thus, based on goal theory, the present paper investigates the roles of leaders and subordinates comprehensively in the context of teams, and conducts theoretical and empirical researches on the forming mechanism of leader empowering behavior. Firstly, this paper will conduct a multi-case study to explore the different types of goal congruence and their processes that promote leader empowering behavior, aiming to develop a theoretical framework of the forming mechanism of leader empowering behavior. Secondly, this paper will empirically investigate the effects of these goal congruence on leader empowering behavior by collecting the longitudinal and dyadic data. Finally, we will test the forming mechanism of leader empowering behavior comprehensively. Accordingly, this research contributes to the leader empowering behavior research in terms of advancing the understanding on the forming mechanism of leader empowering behavior, and better grasping the forming rules of leader empowering behavior. In addition, this project is also helpful for enterprises to carry out the management practices more accurately.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{li2019forming,
  author = {Pengbo LI and Yuqing Sun and Ming Lei},
  title = {{The forming mechanism of leader empowering behavior based on goal theory}},
  booktitle = {Advances},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.3724/sp.j.1042.2019.01167},
}
Figure