Inferring the Spatial Distribution of Physical Activity in Children Population from Characteristics of the Environment

Ioannis A. Sarafis, Christos Diou, Vasileios Papapanagiotou, Leonidas Alagialoglou, Anastasios Delopoulos

Abstract

Obesity affects a rising percentage of children and adolescents, decreasing quality of life and increasing risks for comorbidities. While the causes are known, obesogenic behaviors result from complex interactions with the living environment. The BigO project utilizes large-scale behavioral and environmental data to support policy making. This work proposes a novel approach for modeling expected population behavior as a function of the local environment. Using data from 156 children, we trained models to predict physical activity levels in small geographic regions with 81% accuracy. These models enable the automatic generation of heatmaps, providing public health authorities with tools to visualize the spatial distribution of behavior.

Introduction: Addressing the Obesogenic Environment

Childhood obesity is a global epidemic driven by "obesogenic" environments—surroundings that promote low energy expenditure and high calorie intake. Public health authorities aim to design "active environments" but often lack the granular data needed to understand how neighborhood characteristics translate into population behavior. Traditional monitoring methods, such as surveys, are often too small-scale, while continuous GPS tracking raises significant privacy concerns. This research addresses a critical question: Can we build a reliable model that predicts the physical activity of a population using only publicly available environmental data?

Methodology

The researchers developed a pipeline to bridge individual sensor data with aggregate environmental characteristics.

Overview of the proposed analysis approach for modeling population behavior based on environmental data.

Data Collection and Privacy

The study utilized data from the BigO project (Big Data Against Childhood Obesity), involving 156 children and adolescents (ages 9-18) in Thessaloniki, Greece. Participants provided approximately 90,890 hours of accelerometry and GPS data via smartphones and smartwatches. To protect privacy, individual residences were mapped to geohashes—rectangular grid cells measuring roughly 610m x 930m.

Feature Engineering and Modeling

Two sets of attributes were extracted:

  1. Behavioral Indicators: The average "activity counts per minute" for residents within each geohash.
  2. Environmental Attributes: Counts of four Point of Interest (POI) types (athletics/sports, fast food, public parks, and cafes/bars) extracted from OpenStreetMap and Google Maps.

A Random Forest (RF) classifier was trained to perform binary classification, predicting whether a geohash would exhibit "High" or "Low" physical activity relative to the mean. Given the dataset size of 42 unique geohashes, a Leave-One-Out (LOO) cross-validation procedure was employed.

Results and Insights

The Random Forest model achieved an overall accuracy of 81%. The model demonstrated strong precision (0.81 for both classes) and recall (0.88 for Low, 0.72 for High), making it particularly effective at identifying sedentary neighborhoods that may require intervention.

Qualitative Validation via Heatmaps

The model's predictions were used to generate heatmaps of Thessaloniki. Qualitative analysis showed that areas predicted as "High" activity (e.g., geohashes E, G, and H) correlated with high densities of parks, pedestrian streets, and sports facilities. Conversely, densely populated residential areas lacking these amenities (e.g., geohash F) were correctly flagged as "Low" activity zones.

Heatmap visualization of predicted physical activity levels in Thessaloniki, where red indicates high activity and blue indicates low activity.

The Power of Behavioral Imputation

The core insight is that the urban environment serves as a strong proxy for behavior. This allows for "behavioral imputation," where health authorities can generate comprehensive city-wide heatmaps even when sensor data is available for only a small fraction of the population. This "privacy-by-design" approach focuses on population-level averages rather than individual trajectories.

Limitations and Future Directions

While promising, the study was limited to 156 participants across 42 geohashes in a single city. Future research should expand to diverse urban fabrics (e.g., sprawling North American cities vs. dense European centers) to improve generalization. Additionally, incorporating more granular features—such as sidewalk quality, street lighting, or crime rates—could enhance predictive power. While the paper assumes a link between environment and behavior, these relationships remain complex; future iterations could explore temporal dynamics, such as seasonal changes or the impact of specific urban redevelopment projects.

Summary updated

Abstract

Obesity affects a rising percentage of the children and adolescent population, contributing to decreased quality of life and increased risk for comorbidities. Although the major causes of obesity are known, the obesogenic behaviors manifest as a result of complex interactions of the individual with the living environment. For this reason, addressing childhood obesity remains a challenging problem for public health authorities. The BigO project (https://bigoprogram.eu) relies on large-scale behavioral and environmental data collection to create tools that support policy making and intervention design. In this work, we propose a novel analysis approach for modeling the expected population behavior as a function of the local environment. We experimentally evaluate this approach in predicting the expected physical activity level in small geographic regions using urban environment characteristics. Experiments on data collected from 156 children and adolescents verify the potential of the proposed approach. Specifically, we train models that predict the physical activity level in a region, achieving 81% leave-one-out accuracy. In addition, we exploit the model predictions to automatically visualize heatmaps of the expected population behavior in areas of interest, from which we draw useful insights. Overall, the predictive models and the automatic heatmaps are promising tools in gaining direct perception for the spatial distribution of the population's behavior, with potential uses by public health authorities.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{sarafis2020inferring,
  author = {Ioannis A. Sarafis and Christos Diou and Vasileios Papapanagiotou and Leonidas Alagialoglou and Anastasios Delopoulos},
  title = {{Inferring the Spatial Distribution of Physical Activity in Children Population from Characteristics of the Environment}},
  booktitle = {EMBC},
  year = {2020},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=o8lPfFTQT8J},
}
Figure