Inference for Probabilistic Dependency Graphs

Oliver E. Richardson, Joseph Y. Halpern, Christopher De Sa

TL;DR

This paper introduces the first practical algorithm for inference in Probabilistic Dependency Graphs (PDGs), a powerful and flexible class of graphical models. By reformulating PDG inference as a convex optimization problem solvable by interior-point methods, they achieve polynomial-time inference for PDGs with bounded treewidth, a significant advancement for this previously intractable model class.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Probabilistic Dependency Graphs (PDGs) are a highly flexible graphical model that can represent complex probabilistic relationships, including those that standard Bayesian Networks (BNs) and Factor Graphs (FGs) cannot capture, such as conflicting beliefs from multiple sources. However, despite their theoretical advantages, performing inference (i.e., answering probabilistic queries) on PDGs has been computationally intractable, limiting their practical application. This paper addresses this gap by developing the first efficient algorithm for PDG inference, making them a viable tool for real-world problems.

Methods

The core of the paper's contribution lies in transforming PDG inference into a solvable convex optimization problem. Key techniques include:

  • Convex Optimization Formulation: The authors show that PDG inference can be expressed as an exponential conic program, a class of optimization problems solvable in polynomial time.
  • Tree Decomposition: For PDGs with bounded treewidth, they leverage tree decompositions to represent the problem more compactly, reducing the computational complexity.
  • Interior-Point Methods: They utilize advanced interior-point methods, specifically those designed for exponential conic programs, to efficiently solve the optimization problems.
  • γ-semantics and 0+-semantics: The paper defines and handles two notions of PDG semantics, allowing for flexible inference based on the trade-off between structural and observational information.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on theoretical development and synthetic experiments.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • PDGs as Convex Optimization: The most significant insight is the successful reformulation of PDG inference as a convex optimization problem, unlocking efficient computational solutions.
  • Tractability for Bounded Treewidth: By combining PDG theory with tree decompositions, the authors achieve polynomial-time inference for a practically relevant subset of PDGs.
  • Inconsistency as a Byproduct: The proposed methods naturally compute the degree of inconsistency of a PDG, which is an interesting quantity in itself and has connections to model selection and diagnostics.
  • Flexibility of γ-semantics: The introduction of γ-semantics allows for a nuanced approach to inference, balancing structural and observational information, and the 0+-semantics provides a principled way to handle conflicting information.

Key Results

  • First Tractable Inference Algorithm: The paper presents the first polynomial-time algorithm for inference in PDGs with bounded treewidth.
  • Polynomial Complexity: The algorithm achieves a complexity of $\tilde{O}(N^4)$ for discrete PDGs of bounded treewidth, with theoretical analysis suggesting potential for $\tilde{O}(N^{2.872})$.
  • Empirical Outperformance: Experimental results show that their convex optimization-based methods significantly outperform black-box optimization baselines in terms of accuracy and speed for small PDGs.
  • Equivalence of Inference and Inconsistency Calculation: The paper demonstrates a deep connection, showing that PDG inference and the calculation of PDG inconsistency are equivalent problems for PDGs of bounded treewidth.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Bounded Treewidth Assumption: The primary limitation is that the polynomial-time algorithm is restricted to PDGs with bounded treewidth. While this is a common restriction in graphical models, it excludes more complex structures.
  • Parameter Sensitivity: The performance and applicability of the algorithm depend on the choice of the trade-off parameter γ and the PDG's specific parameters (β and α).
  • Future Work: The authors suggest that faster algorithms are possible, potentially by reducing the complexity of matrix operations. They also note that the remaining cases for γ (where β < γα) are of interest and might require different techniques, possibly involving convex-concave procedures. They are optimistic about developing more general inference algorithms for PDGs, drawing parallels to the progress made in Bayesian networks.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{richardson2023inference,
  author = {Oliver E. Richardson and Joseph Y. Halpern and Christopher De Sa},
  title = {{Inference for Probabilistic Dependency Graphs}},
  booktitle = {Conference on Uncertainty in Artificial Intelligence},
  year = {2023},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=XIn-DFFR2zO},
}
Figure