Inequities in human papillomavirus vaccination among children aged 9–14 years old under constrained vaccine supply in China

Xiaomin Wang, Jiayi Pan, Bo Yan, Ran Zhang, Tianchi Yang, Xudong ZhouInternational Journal for Equity in Health 2024 · DOI

Abstract

Sustained health education campaigns are needed to raise awareness of the HPV vaccine, improve health literacy, and decrease over-preference for the 9-valent HPV vaccine. A mother's HPV vaccination behavior was positively associated with increased intention and actual vaccination behavior for her daughter. This study advocates for complementary cervical cancer prevention programs targeting both mothers and daughters.

Introduction

The World Health Organization (WHO) has set an ambitious global target to vaccinate 90% of girls against Human Papillomavirus (HPV) by age 15 by the year 2030. China, which bears approximately 18% of the global cervical cancer burden, faces significant hurdles in meeting this goal. Currently, the HPV vaccine is not included in China’s National Immunization Program (NIP), requiring parents to pay out-of-pocket. This study, published in the International Journal for Equity in Health, explores how socioeconomic factors and systemic supply constraints create inequities in vaccine uptake among children aged 9–14.

Methods and Data

Researchers conducted a cross-sectional survey between November and December 2022 using multistage stratified cluster random sampling. The study focused on two provinces with differing development levels: Zhejiang (a developed eastern coastal province) and Guizhou (a developing western province). Mixed-effects logistic regression models were used to analyze the data, accounting for school-level clustering.

Participant selection flowchart

The study utilized a primary dataset generated from 4,127 qualified questionnaires from parents who were the primary vaccine decision-makers for their daughters. The researchers measured four stages of the decision-making process: awareness, intention, choice of vaccine type, and actual vaccination behavior.

Key Results

The study revealed a stark gap between parental intention and actual vaccination. While 32.6% of parents intended to vaccinate their daughters, only 6.2% of the girls were actually vaccinated. A major bottleneck was the booking process: of the parents who intended to vaccinate, 62.1% attempted to book an appointment, but only 16.4% were successful.

Vaccination status and intention breakdown

Interestingly, among those vaccinated, over 75% received the domestic 2-valent vaccine. This proves that domestic supply is currently the primary driver of actual coverage, despite a strong cultural preference for higher-valency imported options.

Key Insights

  • The Socioeconomic Paradox: In most health contexts, higher socioeconomic status (SES) correlates with better health outcomes. Here, higher SES parents had significantly higher awareness and intention but lower actual vaccination rates. This is because they "held out" for the scarce imported 9-valent vaccine, while lower SES families were more likely to accept the accessible domestic 2-valent vaccine.
  • The Mother-Daughter Cluster: A mother’s own health behavior is the strongest predictor of her daughter’s vaccination status. Mothers who were vaccinated themselves were 7.18 times more likely to have vaccinated their daughters.
  • The 9-valent Trap: 58% of parents intended to choose the imported 9-valent vaccine. However, the supply is so constrained that this preference acts as a barrier to any protection at all, as parents delay vaccination indefinitely while waiting for a slot in the "Vaccine Lottery."

Conclusion and Future Work

To achieve cervical cancer elimination, the authors advocate for "paired" programs where mothers receive cervical cancer screening while daughters receive vaccinations. They also recommend that the Chinese government provide the domestic 2-valent vaccine for free through the NIP to reduce the "irrational" over-preference for 9-valent doses and ensure immediate protection for adolescent girls. Future work should expand the geographic scope beyond two provinces to capture the full diversity of China’s healthcare landscape.

Summary updated

Abstract

Sustained health education campaigns are needed to raise awareness of the HPV vaccine, improve health literacy, and decrease over-preference for the 9-valent HPV vaccine. A mother's HPV vaccination behavior was positively associated with increased intention and actual vaccination behavior for her daughter. This study advocates for complementary cervical cancer prevention programs targeting both mothers and daughters.
BibTeX
@article{wang2024inequities,
  author = {Xiaomin Wang and Jiayi Pan and Bo Yan and Ran Zhang and Tianchi Yang and Xudong Zhou},
  title = {{Inequities in human papillomavirus vaccination among children aged 9–14 years old under constrained vaccine supply in China}},
  journal = {International Journal for Equity in Health},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1186/s12939-024-02199-z},
}
Figure