Socioeconomic Disparities and COVID-19 Vaccination Acceptance: Experience from Israel

Gil Caspi, Avshalom Dayan, Yael Eshal, Sigal Liverant-Taub, Gilad Twig, Uri Shalit, Yair E. Lewis, Avi Shina, Oren CaspimedRxiv 2021 · DOI

Abstract

COVID-19 vaccination acceptance is critical for mitigating the pandemic. However, concerns have been raised that vaccination rates may be lower in socioeconomically disadvantaged areas. Utilizing Israel’s rapid vaccination campaign as a real-world case study, we analyzed the correlation between vaccination rates, socioeconomic status (SES), and active COVID-19 disease burden. Our analysis of 183 municipalities found that vaccination rates among the population aged 60+ significantly correlated with SES ($r=0.83$). We also established the Vaccination Need Ratio (VNR), a novel metric to help policymakers focus vaccination efforts on high-risk, low-protection areas. The findings underscore the need to target vaccination outreach specifically toward socioeconomically disadvantaged populations.

Introduction

While clinical trials demonstrate vaccine efficacy, the real-world success of any immunization campaign depends on equitable uptake. Public health experts have long hypothesized a "double hit" scenario: populations with the highest risk of infection—often due to crowded living conditions or frontline employment—may also be the least likely to receive the vaccine due to cultural barriers, misinformation, or lack of access.

Israel provided an ideal environment to test this hypothesis. During its 2021 rollout, the COVID-19 vaccine was provided free of charge to all citizens through a centralized, universal healthcare system. This allowed researchers to isolate socioeconomic factors from financial ones, determining whether wealth and education levels independently predicted vaccination acceptance among high-risk residents.

Methods

The researchers conducted a nationwide observational study covering 183 Israeli municipalities. The methodology focused on three primary components:

  • Weighted Pearson Correlation: This was used to measure the strength of the relationship between a municipality's SES and its vaccination rates, weighted by the size of the local 60+ population.
  • Bootstrapping: To ensure statistical robustness, bootstrapping was employed to calculate 95% confidence intervals for the observed correlations.
  • The Vaccination Need Ratio (VNR): The study introduced this novel metric to identify geographical "pockets of low immunity." It is calculated as: $$VNR = \frac{\text{Active Cases per 10,000 people}}{\% \text{ Vaccination of the 60+ population}}$$ A high VNR indicates a "danger zone" where high viral activity meets low vaccine protection.

Data Sources

The study integrated data from three primary sources:

  1. Israeli Ministry of Health (MOH): Real-time data on first-dose vaccinations and active COVID-19 cases (as of January 12–13, 2021).
  2. Israeli Central Bureau of Statistics (ICBS): SES rankings (deciles) based on income per capita, unemployment rates, and education levels.
  3. Demographic Data: 2019 ICBS population data used to calculate percentages for specific age cohorts (60–69, 70–79, 80–89, and 90+).

Key Results

The Socioeconomic Gradient

The study found a powerful positive correlation ($r=0.83$, 95% CI [0.79 to 0.87]) between a municipality's socioeconomic status and its vaccination rate. In high-SES areas, vaccination rates for the elderly often exceeded 80-90%, while some low-SES areas struggled to reach 40-50% during the same period.

The "Double Hit" Phenomenon

The data confirmed an inverse relationship between disease burden and protection: municipalities with higher numbers of active sick people had lower vaccination rates among the elderly ($r=-0.47$). This suggests that the virus naturally exploits the same socioeconomic gaps that hinder vaccination efforts.

VNR as a Diagnostic Tool

The VNR metric proved to be a strong indicator of socioeconomic disparity, showing a negative correlation with SES ($r=-0.80$). This demonstrates that lower-income areas have a significantly higher "need" for targeted intervention. Geographic clustering showed that high VNRs were particularly prevalent in Northern Israel and "seam zones" populated by minority groups.

Discussion and Policy Implications

The findings suggest that age-based prioritization alone is insufficient for pandemic control. Even when vaccines are free, SES remains a massive predictor of health behavior. Policymakers must move beyond age-based strategies to include geographic and risk-based targeting.

The VNR provides a clear "red flag" for health officials, highlighting where the gap between infection and protection is widest. This allows for the deployment of targeted resources—such as mobile clinics and localized messaging—to prevent regional outbreaks before they escalate.

Limitations

The study is subject to the ecological fallacy, as data was aggregated at the municipal level rather than the individual level. Furthermore, the analysis represents a snapshot of the first three weeks of the rollout and does not account for long-term trends or second-dose compliance. Finally, Israel's unique, highly centralized healthcare system may make these results difficult to replicate in countries with fragmented or private-insurance-based systems.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract COVID-19 vaccination acceptance has a key role in mitigating the pandemic. Concern has been raised that vaccination rates will be limited in demographically defined areas of lower income. Israel’s rapid vaccination campaign may allow to assess these assumptions in real-world and to devise tools for effectively focusing the vaccination efforts. We analyzed the correlation between COVID-19 vaccination rates, socioeconomic status (SES) and active COVID-19 disease burden. We carried out a nationwide study, based on data provided by Ministry of Health of COVID-19 vaccination rates in all municipalities in Israel up to January 12 th , 2021. Municipal Vaccination rates of population older than 60 significantly correlated with the socioeconomic status (r=0.83, 95% confidence interval [0.79 to 0.87]). Finally, we established a novel metric for focusing the vaccination efforts based on % vaccinations and active disease burden. In Israel, a case-model country for COVD-19 vaccinations, vaccination rates were strongly correlated with SES. The study findings demonstrate the need to directly target vaccination acceptance to socio-economically disadvantaged populations and suggest potential tools for policymakers to focus their efforts.
BibTeX
@misc{caspi2021socioeconomic,
  author = {Gil Caspi and Avshalom Dayan and Yael Eshal and Sigal Liverant-Taub and Gilad Twig and Uri Shalit and Yair E. Lewis and Avi Shina and Oren Caspi},
  title = {{Socioeconomic Disparities and COVID-19 Vaccination Acceptance: Experience from Israel}},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1101/2021.01.28.21250716},
  howpublished = {medRxiv},
}
Figure