Inducing Behavioral Change in Seekers of Pro-Anorexia Content Using Internet Advertisements: Randomized Controlled Trial

Elad Yom-Tov, Anat Brunstein-Klomek, Or Mandel, Arie Hadas, Silvana Fennig

Abstract

Background: The influence of pro-anorexia (pro-ana) websites is debated, with studies indicating both negative and positive effects. Online advertising has not been used so far to modify the search behavior of people seeking pro-ana content. Objective: This randomized controlled trial (RCT) examined if online advertisements (ads) can change online search behaviors of users looking for pro-ana content. Methods: Using Bing Ads, we randomly exposed searchers for pro-ana content to 10 different ads referring to the National Eating Disorders Association (NEDA), the National Institutes of Mental Health (NIMH), or MyProAna (a "less pathological" pro-ana site). We tracked past and future searches of exposed and unexposed users. Results: Exposure to ads was associated with a decrease in searches for pro-ana and self-harm content. Reductions were greatest among those referred to MyProAna (34.0% and 37.2% reduction, respectively) compared to other destinations or the control group, which saw an increase in harmful searches. Conclusions: Referring users to specific pro-ana communities might lessen maladaptive online search behavior, suggesting that appropriate pathways can redirect those preoccupied with eating disorders (EDs).

Introduction

Pro-anorexia (pro-ana) websites present a complex public health challenge by promoting eating disorders as a lifestyle choice rather than a mental illness. These communities often provide a sense of belonging and peer support that traditional medical interventions struggle to replicate. This study investigates a "harm reduction" strategy: using behavioral targeting—the same tools used by commercial advertisers—to intervene at the moment of search and nudge users toward safer alternatives.

Methods

The researchers conducted an RCT using the Bing Ads system, triggered by keywords such as Thinspiration, Proana, and Anorexia. Ten different textual ad versions were randomly assigned to one of three destinations:

  1. NEDA: National Eating Disorders Association (non-profit).
  2. NIMH: National Institutes of Mental Health (government).
  3. MyProAna: A peer-led community previously identified as being associated with "less pathological" behaviors than other similar sites.

The study tracked the search history of 25,554 impressions and 217 clicks over a two-month period (one month pre- and post-exposure), comparing them against a control group of 10,000 users who were not shown the experimental ads.

Results and Analysis

The intervention successfully disrupted harmful search patterns. While the control group increased their pro-ana searches by 57.12% during the study period, those exposed to the ads showed significant reductions.

Click-through rates (CTR) for various ad texts across the three destination websites (labeled as American Eating Disorders, CDC, and MyProAna).

As shown in the figure above, engagement varied significantly by ad tone and destination. Ads that emphasized community and empathy (e.g., "welcome to our community") achieved higher click-through rates, particularly when pointing to the MyProAna peer site. Conversely, ads with a more clinical or negative tone toward EDs were less effective at engaging the target audience.

Key Findings:

  • Peer Connection vs. Clinical Advice: MyProAna outperformed official medical sites in reducing harmful searches (34.0% reduction in pro-ana searches vs. 15.47% for official sites).
  • Priming Effect: Behavioral change was observed even in users who saw the ads but did not click them, suggesting that the mere presence of an alternative path can disrupt maladaptive cycles.
  • Treatment Seeking: Users referred to MyProAna were more likely to subsequently search for professional treatment, whereas those referred to official sites actually decreased such searches.

Discussion

The success of the MyProAna destination suggests that users in the pro-ana space value peer connection and may find "top-down" medical messaging alienating or irrelevant to their immediate needs. A harm-reduction approach that meets users where they are—providing a "less harmful" community as a stepping stone—appears more effective than immediate redirection to clinical resources.

Conclusion

This study demonstrates that online advertising can be a powerful tool for public health intervention. By leveraging empathic, non-judgmental messaging and peer-led resources, search engines can successfully redirect vulnerable users from harmful content toward healthier behavioral trajectories. Future work should focus on refining these empathic pathways to better integrate peer support with professional medical care.

Summary updated

Abstract

Background: The influence of pro-anorexia (pro-ana) websites is debated, with studies indicating both negative and positive effects, as well as significant variation in the effects of different websites for those suffering from eating disorders (EDs) and the general population. Online advertising, known to induce behavioral change both online and in the physical world, has not been used so far to modify the search behavior of people seeking pro-ana content.Objective: The objective of this randomized controlled trial (RCT) was to examine if online advertisements (ads) can change online search behaviors of users who are looking for online pro-ana content.Methods: Using the Bing Ads system, we conducted an RCT to randomly expose the searchers for pro-ana content to 10 different ads referring people to one of the three websites: the National Eating Disorders Association, the National Institutes of Mental Health, and MyProAna. MyProAna is a pro-ana website that was found in a previous study to be associated with less pathological online behaviors than other pro-ana websites. We followed participants exposed and unexposed to the ads to explore their past and future online searches. The ads were shown 25,554 times and clicked on 217 times.Results: Exposure to the ads was associated with a decrease in searches for pro-ana and self-harm content. Reductions were greatest among those referred to MyProAna (reduction of 34.0% [73/215] and 37.2% [80/215] for pro-ana and self-harm, respectively) compared with users who were referred elsewhere (reduction of 15.47% [410/2650] and 3.21% [85/2650], respectively), and with users who were not shown the ads, who increased their behaviors (increase of 57.12% [6462/11,314] and 4.07% [461/11,314], respectively). In addition, those referred to MyProAna increased their search for treatment, as did control users, who did so to a lesser extent. However, users referred elsewhere decreased their searches for this content.Conclusions: We found that referring users interested in ED-related content to specific pro-ana communities might lessen their maladaptive online search behavior. This suggests that those who are preoccupied with EDs can be redirected to less pathological online searches through appropriate pathways.Trial Registration: ClinicalTrials.gov NCT03439553; https://clinicaltrials.gov/show/NCT03439553 (Archived by WebCite at http://www.webcitation.org/6xNYnxYlw)JMIR Ment Health 2018;5(1):e6doi:10.2196/mental.8212
BibTeX
@inproceedings{yomtov2018inducing,
  author = {Elad Yom-Tov and Anat Brunstein-Klomek and Or Mandel and Arie Hadas and Silvana Fennig},
  title = {{Inducing Behavioral Change in Seekers of Pro-Anorexia Content Using Internet Advertisements: Randomized Controlled Trial}},
  booktitle = {JMIR Mental Health},
  year = {2018},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=8dFARV9dwf},
}

Loading related content...

Figure