Induced Covariance for Causal Discovery in Linear Sparse Structures

Saeed Mohseni-Sehdeh, Walid Saad

Abstract

Traditional causal discovery methods often struggle with limited data and high computational costs. This paper presents Sparse Linear Causal Discovery (SLCD), an algorithm that leverages "induced covariance" and structural matrix rank to map cause-effect relationships in sparse linear systems. By bypassing data-intensive conditional independence tests, SLCD achieves significant improvements in precision and recall over established benchmarks.

Introduction

Distinguishing between correlation and causation is a fundamental challenge in machine learning. While standard statistical models identify associations, causal discovery aims to uncover the underlying mechanisms. Existing approaches, such as constraint-based (PC, IC) and score-based (GES, BIC) methods, are often limited by high data requirements or exponential search spaces. This work addresses the specific problem of discovering causal structures in linearly sparse systems with limited observational data.

Methodology: Sparse Linear Causal Discovery (SLCD)

The proposed SLCD algorithm treats causal discovery as a structural optimization task. The core theoretical foundation is the concept of Induced Covariance. For a linear structural causal model defined by $x = Dx$, the covariance of observed data $\Sigma$ is related to the structural matrix $D$ and the variance of independent variables $\sigma$ by: $$\Sigma = D \sigma D^T$$

The algorithm identifies the optimal matrix $D$ by minimizing a loss function that integrates three components:

  1. Data Reconstruction: Ensuring $D$ accurately explains the observed values.
  2. Covariance Matching: Aligning the induced covariance with the empirical data covariance.
  3. Sparsity Constraints: Utilizing rank-minimization and trace constraints to ensure the resulting graph is sparse and acyclic, avoiding trivial solutions like the identity matrix.

Experimental Evaluation

The researchers evaluated SLCD using five synthetic datasets of varying complexity, ranging from simple structures (Dataset 1) to more complex networks with up to seven nodes (Datasets 2-5). Each dataset contained 1,000 samples. SLCD was benchmarked against PC, GES, BIC exact search, and LiNGAM.

Performance and Hyperparameter Sensitivity

SLCD demonstrated superior performance, particularly as structural complexity increased. In Datasets 2 through 4, the algorithm frequently achieved perfect recovery (precision and recall of 1.0). On average, SLCD outperformed benchmarks by 35% in precision and 41.5% in recall across the more complex scenarios.

Performance metrics across Datasets 1-4 for varying hyperparameters σ and λ.

The algorithm's performance is influenced by two primary hyperparameters: $\sigma$ (regularization parameter) and $\lambda$ (sparsity weight). Sensitivity analysis reveals that while performance varies, high accuracy is maintained across a broad range of parameter settings, indicating robustness for practical applications.

Additional performance heatmaps showing the impact of σ and λ on causal reconstruction accuracy across different datasets.

Discussion and Limitations

A notable finding is that SLCD performs better on complex structures than on extremely simple ones. In Dataset 1, where variables were simple scalar multiples, the lack of informational diversity made parent identification ambiguous. Furthermore, the current implementation assumes linear relationships.

Conclusion

SLCD offers a leaner, more efficient alternative to traditional causal discovery by exploiting the statistical signatures of structural matrices. Future work will focus on extending this framework to non-linear systems and incorporating more robust information-theoretic measures to further refine independence characterization in noisy environments.

Summary updated

Abstract

Causal models seek to unravel the cause-effect relationships among variables from observed data, as opposed to mere mappings among them, as traditional regression models do. This paper introduces Sparse Linear Causal Discovery (SLCD), a novel causal discovery algorithm designed for settings in which variables exhibit linearly sparse relationships. In such scenarios, the causal links represented by directed acyclic graphs (DAGs) can be encapsulated in a structural matrix. The proposed approach identifies the correct structural matrix by evaluating how well it reconstructs the data and how closely it satisfies the imposed statistical constraints. This method does not rely on independence tests or graph fitting procedures, making it suitable for scenarios with limited training data. Simulation results on synthetically generated datasets with known linear sparse causal structures show that SLCD consistently outperforms the PC, GES, BIC exact search, and LiNGAM-based methods, achieving average improvements of \(35\%\) in precision and \(41.5\%\) in recall. Moreover, on the real-world Sachs dataset, SLCD further surpasses these methods in the low-sample-size setting.
BibTeX
@misc{mohsenisehdeh2024induced,
  author = {Saeed Mohseni-Sehdeh and Walid Saad},
  title = {{Induced Covariance for Causal Discovery in Linear Sparse Structures}},
  year = {2024},
  eprint = {2410.01221},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2410.01221},
}
Figure