Increasing Employees' Willingness to Share: Introducing Appeal Strategies for People Analytics

Valentin Zieglmeier, Maren Gierlich-Joas, Alexander Pretschner

TL;DR

People analytics (PA) offers significant benefits for organizations, but its effectiveness hinges on employees willingly sharing their data. This paper introduces a taxonomy of "appeal strategies" – beyond mere awareness – designed to motivate employees to share their data by focusing on values, benefits, and incentives, thereby bridging the gap between PA potential and employee privacy concerns.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The increasing adoption of digital workplaces and advanced people analytics (PA) tools presents a double-edged sword. While PA promises to optimize work, boost efficiency, and inform decision-making, it also raises significant privacy concerns among employees. These concerns stem from the potential for data misuse, surveillance, and a general lack of transparency about how their data is used. Crucially, many PA systems rely on employees voluntarily sharing their data. Existing approaches to encourage data sharing primarily focus on increasing employee awareness of data handling practices. However, this paper argues that awareness alone is insufficient to overcome privacy concerns and motivate sharing, especially when data isn't strictly essential for core business processes. The authors identify a gap in understanding and categorizing strategies that actively appeal to employees to share their data, moving beyond just informing them.

Methods

The authors employed a mixed-methods approach combining a systematic literature review with semi-structured expert interviews.

  • Literature Review: They conducted a targeted search across information systems (IS) and computer science (CS) fields using keywords related to disclosure decisions, workplace context, and appeal strategies. This initial search yielded 14 articles, which were then expanded through snowballing and manual additions, resulting in 30 articles for initial analysis. After applying filtering criteria (workplace-specific, individual data sharing focus, appeal strategy focus), 18 articles were thoroughly reviewed, leading to 12 relevant articles for the final analysis.
  • Expert Interviews: To complement the literature and gain practical insights, 18 experts were interviewed. These experts were recruited from LinkedIn and represented developers of PA applications, users of PA, and consultants in the PA space. The interviews were structured into three parts: general questions about their role and PA use, focused questions on applied appeal strategies, and an opportunity for additional remarks. The interviews were conducted in German and then translated.

The findings from both the literature and interviews were then used to inductively derive a taxonomy of appeal strategies.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on a systematic literature review and expert interviews, not on specific datasets for training or evaluation.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Beyond Awareness: The core insight is that simply informing employees about data handling (awareness strategies) is often insufficient to overcome privacy concerns and motivate data sharing. Employees need to see a compelling appeal to share.
  • Three Dimensions of Appeal: The authors identified three key dimensions for appeal strategies:
  • Values: These are inscribed into the design of PA tools and aim to align with users' ethical principles and foster trust and autonomy. Examples include promoting engagement and psychological ownership.
  • Benefits: These are realized during the usage phase and focus on how the PA tool directly helps the employee. Personalization, feedback on performance, time savings, and improved work efficiency are key benefits.
  • Incentives: These are external levers applied during the usage phase, often through managerial intervention. While monetary rewards are common, they can be problematic in the workplace. Other incentives include gamification and training opportunities.
  • Design vs. Usage Phase: Values are primarily addressed during the design phase (more CS focus), while benefits and incentives are more relevant in the usage phase (more IS focus). Incentives are particularly important when the tool's design cannot be influenced.
  • Reciprocity is Key: Peer-level reciprocity (e.g., seeing others share and benefit) appears to be more effective in increasing willingness to share than hierarchical organizational ownership.
  • Workplace Context Matters: Privacy concerns and acceptable appeal strategies differ significantly in the workplace compared to consumer settings due to inherent power asymmetries.

Key Results

The study resulted in the development of a taxonomy of appeal strategies for people analytics, categorized into three dimensions: Values, Benefits, and Incentives.

  • Values: Eight categories were identified, with trust and autonomy being central. Other values include engagement, psychological ownership, technical market design, perceived market morality, social cohesion, and reciprocity.
  • Benefits: These are tangible advantages for the employee. Key benefits include personalization, immediate feedback on performance, time savings, automation of tasks, improved information quality, and enhanced work efficiency. The potential to initiate change based on shared data was also highlighted as a significant benefit.
  • Incentives: While less explored in the literature and interviews, incentives include monetary rewards (though with caveats for workplace use), mental support from managers, gamification, and opportunities for individual training and coaching.

The taxonomy provides concrete examples for each dimension, drawing from both academic literature and practical insights from expert interviews.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Literature Scope: The literature review was constrained by the chosen search terms, although snowballing was used to mitigate this.
  • Interviewee Bias: The interviewed experts, while diverse, may still represent specific viewpoints.
  • Cultural Context: The study focused on Germany, meaning the findings might not be universally applicable to other cultural or legal contexts.
  • Taxonomy Novelty: The developed taxonomy is an initial version and has not yet been applied to broader company cases.

Future work suggested includes:

  • Taxonomy Validation: Applying and validating the taxonomy in different cultural settings and through focus group discussions with employees.
  • Incentive Engineering: Further exploring the explicit embedding of values and incentives into PA tools, and investigating the implications for managerial agency and employee decision-making.
  • Design-Oriented Studies: Continuing research in value-based engineering and incentive engineering to facilitate better human-IS interaction in the workplace.

Summary updated

Abstract

Increasingly digital workplaces enable advanced people analytics (PA) that can improve work, but also implicate privacy risks for employees. These systems often depend on employees sharing their data voluntarily. Thus, to leverage the potential benefits of PA, companies have to manage employees' disclosure decision. In literature, we identify two main strategies: increase awareness or apply appeal strategies. While increased awareness may lead to more conservative data handling, appeal strategies can promote data sharing. Yet, to our knowledge, no systematic overview of appeal strategies for PA exists. Thus, we develop an initial taxonomy of strategies based on a systematic literature review and interviews with 18 experts. We describe strategies in the dimensions of values, benefits, and incentives. Thereby, we present concrete options to increase the appeal of PA for employees.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zieglmeier2022increasing,
  author = {Valentin Zieglmeier and Maren Gierlich-Joas and Alexander Pretschner},
  title = {{Increasing Employees' Willingness to Share: Introducing Appeal Strategies for People Analytics}},
  booktitle = {Icsob},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.1007/978-3-031-20706-8\_15},
}
Figure