Increased memory confidence and delusions in Alzheimer’s disease: a preliminary study

Emma McLachlan, Kathy Liu, Lauren Huzzey, Neil Burgess, Suzanne Reeves, Robert HowardNeurocase 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This preliminary study suggests that individuals with Alzheimer's disease (AD) who experience delusions may have a heightened confidence in their memory recall, even for correct memories. This finding points to a potential link between impaired "metamemory" (the ability to self-evaluate memory) and the development of delusions in AD, opening avenues for new treatment strategies.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

A significant portion of individuals with Alzheimer's disease (AD) develop delusions, which are fixed false beliefs. While it's hypothesized that these delusions might stem from "false memories" (inaccurate recollections), the exact relationship, particularly concerning how people with AD perceive their own memory accuracy, remains unclear. Specifically, the concept of "metamemory" – our internal monitoring of memory – is known to be impaired in conditions like schizophrenia, where it's linked to delusions. However, how task-specific metamemory, like confidence in memory judgments, relates to delusions in AD hasn't been thoroughly investigated. This paper aims to bridge that gap by exploring whether individuals with AD and delusions exhibit differences in their memory confidence compared to those without delusions.

Methods

The researchers employed a computerized Deese-Roediger-McDermott (DRM) paradigm, a standard method for inducing and measuring false memories. Participants were presented with lists of words and later asked to identify which words they had seen before, distinguishing between actual presented words ("targets"), semantically related but unpresented words ("lures"), and unrelated words. Crucially, after each recognition decision, participants rated their confidence on a three-point scale. The study also incorporated a metamemory measure by analyzing these confidence ratings. Statistical analyses included independent-samples t-tests and Mann-Whitney tests to compare groups, followed by binary logistic regression to explore the relationship between confidence levels and the presence of delusions, controlling for potential confounding factors like sex.

Datasets

The study did not introduce new datasets. Instead, it utilized a standard computerized DRM paradigm with word lists selected from existing DRM lists of semantic associates. Participant data was collected from local memory services and the Join Dementia Research register.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Confidence in Correct Memories Matters: The most striking finding is not just increased confidence in errors, but a significant increase in confidence for correctly recalled items among individuals with delusions. This suggests a broader issue with memory self-assessment, not just a tendency to misjudge false memories.
  • Metamemory as a Potential "First Factor": The study tentatively supports the idea that impaired metamemory could be a foundational neuropsychological deficit that contributes to the formation of delusions in AD, echoing theories proposed for schizophrenia.
  • Implications for Treatment: If confidence in memory is indeed linked to delusions, it opens up possibilities for interventions that target metamemory skills, potentially helping individuals with AD to better appraise their own memories and reduce delusional beliefs.

Key Results

  • Participants with delusions in AD showed a trend towards higher hit rates, false recognition, and false memory rates, though these did not reach statistical significance.
  • A statistically significant finding emerged: individuals with delusions reported higher confidence in their correct memory responses. The percentage of high confidence correct responses was 69.7% (SD 31.0%) in the delusion group compared to 43.5% (SD 29.9%) in the control group (p = .049).
  • This association remained significant even after controlling for sex in a regression model. For every 1% increase in high confidence correct responses, participants were 5.4% more likely to be in the delusion group (Exp(β) 1.054, p = .025).

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations, most notably the small sample size (10 participants with delusions, 14 without). Despite this, they observed trends and achieved statistical significance on a key measure. They also note the challenges inherent in accurately diagnosing both AD and delusions, and the possibility that two participants with delusions might have had undiagnosed Lewy body dementia due to the presence of hallucinations.

Future work should focus on exploring these findings in a larger sample to confirm the observed associations. The authors also suggest that future studies could benefit from including measures of disease insight (anosognosia), as this has been previously linked to delusions in AD. The potential for metamemory training as a low-cost, low-risk intervention for individuals with mild AD experiencing delusions is highlighted as a promising avenue for further research and clinical application.

Summary updated

Abstract

There is uncertainty about whether delusion formation in Alzheimer's disease (AD) can be explained by false memories. "Metamemory," the ability to self-evaluate memory and identify memory errors, is impaired in people with delusions in schizophrenia. Our objective was to investigate whether false memory and metamemory were associated with delusions in AD. Participants with mild AD, with and without delusions, completed a computerized word recognition task and a metamemory measure. Group differences were compared using independent-samples t-tests or Mann Whitney tests. Significant findings were explored through binary logistic regression modeling. Participants with delusions (<i>n</i> = 10) gave more high confidence responses, significantly so for correct responses; percentage of high confidence correct responses for those with delusions (mean (SD)) was 69.7% (31.0%) and for those without (<i>n</i> = 14) was 43.5% (29.9%); <i>t</i><sub>22</sub> = -2.09, <i>p</i> = .049. This remained significant when sex was included in regression modeling; for each 1.0% increase in high confidence correct responses, participants were 5.4% more likely to have delusions (Exp(β) 1.054, 95% CI 1.007-1.105, <i>p</i> = .025). Findings provide tentative support for a link between metamemory and delusions in AD. This should be explored in a larger sample as it has potential implications for treatment.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{mclachlan2024increased,
  author = {Emma McLachlan and Kathy Liu and Lauren Huzzey and Neil Burgess and Suzanne Reeves and Robert Howard},
  title = {{Increased memory confidence and delusions in Alzheimer’s disease: a preliminary study}},
  booktitle = {Neurocase},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1080/13554794.2024.2426267},
}
Figure