Incorporating Semantic Knowledge into Latent Matching Model in Search

Shuxin Wang, Xin Jiang, Hang Li, Jun Xu, Bin Wang

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel latent matching model for search that enhances accuracy by incorporating semantic knowledge (synonyms and categories) alongside click-through data. This approach significantly improves performance, especially for "tail" queries (less frequent ones) that are typically underserved by click data alone.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In search engines, the core task is to determine how relevant a document is to a given query. Traditional Information Retrieval (IR) models often rely on keyword matching, which can fail when queries and documents use different terms for the same concept (e.g., "car" vs. "automobile"). While machine learning models, particularly latent space models, have shown promise by mapping queries and documents into a shared representation space, they struggle with "tail" queries and documents. These have sparse click-through data, making it difficult to train robust models. This paper aims to bridge this gap by enriching latent matching models with external semantic knowledge.

Methods

The authors propose a latent matching model (LMM) that extends existing methods like Regularized Mapping to Latent Structures (RMLS). The core idea is to incorporate semantic knowledge into the objective function through regularization terms. This allows the model to learn a latent space where semantically related queries and documents are closer, even if they lack direct click-through evidence.

They propose two optimization algorithms to train their model:

  • Coordinate Descent: An iterative approach that updates one latent representation at a time. It's generally faster but can be computationally intensive for high-dimensional latent spaces.
  • Gradient Descent: An alternative that updates all latent representations simultaneously. It's less computationally demanding per step but may require more iterations to converge.

For acquiring semantic knowledge, they propose two methods:

  1. Synonym Mining: Automatically extracting synonym pairs from click-through data by analyzing query co-occurrence in a bipartite graph.
  2. Category/Tag Utilization: Using predefined categories or tags associated with documents (e.g., app tags) and representing them as vectors of relevant terms.

Datasets

The experiments were conducted on two large-scale datasets derived from click-through logs of a mobile app search engine.

  • Training Data: Two datasets were created: one from one week of click data and another from one month of click data. These datasets contain query-document pairs with associated clicks.
  • Test Data: Two sets of 200 queries each were sampled from a different time period than the training data. Each test set included 100 "head" (frequent) queries and 100 "tail" (infrequent) queries. Query-app pairs in the test sets were manually labeled at four levels of matching: Excellent, Good, Fair, and Bad.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Semantic Knowledge is Crucial for Tail Queries: The paper strongly demonstrates that incorporating semantic knowledge significantly boosts performance for tail queries, which are notoriously difficult to model with click data alone. This is a key takeaway for building more equitable and effective search systems.
  • Regularization as a Bridge: Using semantic knowledge as regularization terms in the objective function is an elegant way to integrate external information without requiring a complete overhaul of existing latent matching frameworks.
  • Synonyms and Categories Complement Each Other: The experiments suggest that combining both synonym information and category tags (LMM-Both) often yields better results than using either source of knowledge in isolation.
  • Latent Space Visualization: The paper includes visualizations showing how incorporating synonyms leads to better clustering of semantically related words in the latent space, providing a qualitative understanding of the model's behavior.

Key Results

  • Outperforming Baselines: The proposed LMM model consistently outperformed traditional IR models like BM25 and other latent matching models like PLS and RMLS, especially on tail queries.
  • Significant Gains with Semantic Knowledge: LMM-Synonyms and LMM-Tags showed noticeable improvements over the base LMM. LMM-Both, which combined both types of knowledge, achieved the most significant gains, with improvements over LMM being statistically significant in most cases.
  • Tail Query Improvement: The performance gains were more pronounced for tail queries than for head queries, highlighting the model's effectiveness in addressing the long-tail problem.
  • Dimensionality Trade-off: The performance generally increased with latent dimensionality, but the gains diminished after 500 dimensions, suggesting a good trade-off between effectiveness and efficiency around this point.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Quality of Semantic Knowledge: The authors acknowledge that the quality of the mined semantic knowledge can be a limitation. Noisy synonyms (e.g., "google" and "baidu" being identified as synonyms) can sometimes lead to suboptimal ranking. Future work should focus on improving the quality of mined semantic knowledge.
  • Non-linear Models: The current work focuses on linear latent matching models. The authors suggest exploring non-linear models for matching as a future direction.
  • More Knowledge Types: Incorporating additional types of knowledge, such as knowledge graphs, is also proposed as a future research avenue.
  • Parallelization: While the paper discusses parallelization strategies for their algorithms, further optimization and exploration of parallel computing for training large-scale models remain relevant.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{wang2016incorporating,
  author = {Shuxin Wang and Xin Jiang and Hang Li and Jun Xu and Bin Wang},
  title = {{Incorporating Semantic Knowledge into Latent Matching Model in Search}},
  booktitle = {AIRS},
  year = {2016},
  doi = {10.1007/978-3-319-48051-0\_3},
}

Loading related content...

Figure