Improved cycling stability in high-capacity Li-rich vanadium containing disordered rock salt oxyfluoride cathodes

Christian Baur, Ida Källquist, Johann Chable, Jin Hyun Chang, Rune E. Johnsen, Francisco Ruiz‐Zepeda, Jean-Marcel Ateba, Andrew J. Naylor, J. M. García‐Lastra, Tejs Vegge, Franziska Klein, Annika R. Schür, Poul Norby, Kristina Edström, Maria Hahlin, Maximilian FichtnerJournal of Materials Chemistry A 2019 · DOI

Abstract

Lithium-rich transition metal disordered rock salt (DRS) oxyfluorides have the potential to lessen one large bottleneck for lithium ion batteries by improving the cathode capacity. This study demonstrates that partial substitution of vanadium with titanium or iron significantly enhances cycling stability by stabilizing the material's surface and bulk structure.

Introduction

To surpass the energy density limits of current lithium-ion batteries, researchers are exploring "Li-rich" cathode materials. Disordered rock salt (DRS) oxyfluorides, such as $Li_2VO_2F$, are particularly promising due to their random internal structure which creates percolating pathways for efficient lithium-ion transport. However, these materials typically suffer from rapid capacity fading due to irreversible surface reactions with the electrolyte. This work investigates transition metal substitution as a strategy to mitigate these issues.

Methodology

The researchers synthesized $Li_2V_{0.5}Ti_{0.5}O_2F$ and $Li_2V_{0.5}Fe_{0.5}O_2F$ using a two-step mechanochemical ball milling process involving a $LiTMO_2$ intermediate. Characterization was performed using Synchrotron PXRD, HAXPES, and DFT calculations to confirm the disordered crystal structure and probe surface oxidation states.

High-resolution imaging of the disordered rock salt structure showing the atomic lattice.

Key Insights and Results

DFT calculations indicated that substituting $V^{3+}$ with $Ti^{3+}$ or $Fe^{3+}$ thermodynamically stabilizes the disordered state. HAXPES analysis revealed that these substitutions create a more robust surface passivation layer, protecting vanadium from irreversible high-oxidation states and maintaining the reversibility of the $V^{3+}/V^{5+}$ redox couple.

The experimental results demonstrated a dramatic boost in performance:

  • Stability: Capacity retention improved from 55% in unsubstituted $Li_2VO_2F$ to 81% (Ti-substituted) and 83% (Fe-substituted) after 25 cycles.
  • Efficiency: Coulombic efficiency increased from ~93% to ~97%.
  • Capacity: The Ti-substituted version achieved a discharge capacity of 285 mAh/g, significantly higher than conventional $LiCoO_2$ (~140 mAh/g).

Conclusion and Future Outlook

Despite the improvements in stability and capacity, challenges such as voltage hysteresis—which leads to energy loss as heat—remain. Future research will focus on optimizing the stoichiometry of the transition metal mix to find the ideal balance between capacity and structural stability. This work provides a robust roadmap for the development of durable, high-capacity "rock salt" cathodes for next-generation batteries.

Summary updated

Abstract

Lithium-rich transition metal disordered rock salt (DRS) oxyfluorides have the potential to lessen one large bottleneck for lithium ion batteries by improving the cathode capacity.
BibTeX
@article{baur2019improved,
  author = {Christian Baur and Ida Källquist and Johann Chable and Jin Hyun Chang and Rune E. Johnsen and Francisco Ruiz‐Zepeda and Jean-Marcel Ateba and Andrew J. Naylor and J. M. García‐Lastra and Tejs Vegge and Franziska Klein and Annika R. Schür and Poul Norby and Kristina Edström and Maria Hahlin and Maximilian Fichtner},
  title = {{Improved cycling stability in high-capacity Li-rich vanadium containing disordered rock salt oxyfluoride cathodes}},
  journal = {Journal of Materials Chemistry A},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.1039/c9ta06291b},
}
Figure