Improper Gaussian signaling in full-duplex relay channels with residual self-interference

Mohamed Gaafar, Mohammad Galal Khafagy, Osama Amin, Mohamed-Slim Alouini

TL;DR

This paper demonstrates that Improper Gaussian Signaling (IGS) can significantly improve the performance of full-duplex relay systems plagued by residual self-interference (RSI). Unlike traditional signaling, which fails completely as interference grows, IGS provides a form of "interference immunity," allowing communication to persist even in highly noisy environments.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Full-duplex (FD) radio is a "holy grail" for wireless networks because it allows a node to transmit and receive on the same frequency at the same time, potentially doubling spectral efficiency. However, FD faces a massive practical hurdle: Residual Self-Interference (RSI). Even with advanced cancellation techniques, the relay’s own transmission leaks back into its receiver, drowning out the weak signal from the source.

Traditionally, engineers use Proper Gaussian Signaling (PGS), where the real and imaginary parts of a signal are independent and have equal power (circular symmetry). While PGS is optimal for noise-limited channels, it performs poorly in interference-limited ones. In FD relaying, increasing relay power to reach the destination better also increases RSI, often leading to a "breakeven point" where more power actually makes the system worse.

Methods

The authors propose replacing PGS with Improper Gaussian Signaling (IGS) at the relay. In IGS, the circular symmetry is broken—the real and imaginary components can have different variances or be correlated. This is quantified by a circularity coefficient ($C_x$), ranging from 0 (Proper) to 1 (Maximally Improper).

The researchers' approach includes:

  1. Mathematical Modeling: They derived a tight upper bound for the end-to-end outage probability of a decode-and-forward FD relay system.
  2. Optimization: They proved that the outage probability is either monotonic or unimodal with respect to the circularity coefficient. This mathematical property is crucial because it means simple numerical methods (like the bisection method) can be used to find the "global optimum" signal shape.
  3. Asymptotic Analysis: They analyzed what happens when RSI becomes infinitely large to see if the system survives.

Datasets

As a theoretical communication theory paper, no external datasets were used. Instead, the authors evaluated their models using Monte Carlo simulations based on standard statistical channel models:

  • Rayleigh Fading: Used to model the wireless links between the source, relay, and destination.
  • Power Constraints: Simulations assumed a maximum power budget ($P_{max}$) and specific target transmission rates ($R$).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Interference Floor" vs. Total Failure: The most striking insight is that while PGS systems eventually hit an outage probability of 1 (total failure) as RSI increases, IGS systems approach a constant "floor." This means IGS makes the system robust against even very high levels of self-interference.
  • Unlocking Higher Power Budgets: In PGS, there is a limit to how much power a relay should use before it "blinds" itself with RSI. IGS shifts this limit, allowing the relay to utilize higher power budgets to reach the destination more reliably while tuning the "impropriety" of the signal to mitigate the resulting RSI.
  • One-Dimensional Signaling: For very high power budgets, the optimal IGS signal becomes "maximally improper" ($C_x \to 1$). This essentially means the relay transmits most of its power in only one dimension of the complex signal space, leaving the other dimension relatively "clean" for receiving the source's signal.

Key Results

  • RSI Immunity: In scenarios where RSI was high (e.g., $\pi_{rr} > 15$ dB), PGS outage probability climbed toward 100%, while the optimized IGS maintained a stable outage probability (e.g., around 10-20% depending on the target rate).
  • Power Efficiency: As shown in the paper's figures, IGS continues to decrease the outage probability as relay power increases, whereas PGS performance starts to degrade after a certain power threshold (the "breakeven point").
  • Optimization Convergence: The authors confirmed that their proposed bisection-based optimization matches exhaustive grid searches, proving that finding the optimal IGS parameters is computationally efficient for real-time systems.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Channel State Information (CSI): The optimization assumes the relay has accurate knowledge of the channel statistics. In fast-moving environments, obtaining this information might add overhead.
  • Hardware Complexity: Implementing IGS requires more sophisticated modulation and transceiver designs compared to standard PGS.
  • Scope: This work focuses on a single-antenna (SISO) relay. The authors suggest that extending this to MIMO (Multiple-Input Multiple-Output) systems or multi-relay networks would be a promising next step to further exploit spatial degrees of freedom alongside signal impropriety.

Summary updated

Abstract

We study the potential employment of improper Gaussian signaling (IGS) in full-duplex cooperative settings with residual self-interference (RSI). IGS is recently shown to outperform traditional proper Gaussian signaling (PGS) in several interference-limited channel settings. In this work, IGS is employed in an attempt to alleviate the RSI adverse effect in full-duplex relaying (FDR). To this end, we derive a tight upper bound expression for the end-to-end outage probability in terms of the relay signal parameters represented in its power and circularity coefficient. We further show that the derived upper bound is either monotonic or unimodal in the relay's circularity coefficient. This result allows for easily locating the global optimal point using known numerical methods. Based on the analysis, IGS allows FDR systems to operate even with high RSI. It is shown that, while the communication totally fails with PGS as the RSI increases, the IGS outage probability approaches a fixed value that depends on the channel statistics and target rate. The obtained results show that IGS can leverage higher relay power budgets than PGS to improve the performance, meanwhile it relieves its RSI impact via tuning the signal impropriety.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{gaafar2016improper,
  author = {Mohamed Gaafar and Mohammad Galal Khafagy and Osama Amin and Mohamed-Slim Alouini},
  title = {{Improper Gaussian signaling in full-duplex relay channels with residual self-interference}},
  booktitle = {ICC},
  year = {2016},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=gyg-HF8o01},
}

Loading related content...

Figure