Importance of quantum decoherence in brain processes

Max Tegmark

Abstract

Based on a calculation of neural decoherence rates, we argue that the degrees of freedom of the human brain that relate to cognitive processes should be thought of as a classical rather than quantum system, i.e., that there is nothing fundamentally wrong with the current classical approach to neural network simulations. We find that the decoherence time scales (approximately $10^{-13}-10^{-20}$ s) are typically much shorter than the relevant dynamical time scales (approximately $10^{-3}-10^{-1}$ s), both for regular neuron firing and for kinklike polarization excitations in microtubules. This conclusion disagrees with suggestions by Penrose and others that the brain acts as a quantum computer, and that quantum coherence is related to consciousness in a fundamental way.

Introduction

For decades, a debate has raged at the intersection of physics and neuroscience: Is the human brain a classical biological machine, or does it leverage quantum mechanics to produce consciousness? While mainstream biophysics treats neurons as classical switches, influential figures like Roger Penrose and Stuart Hameroff proposed the "Orch-OR" model. They argued that classical physics cannot explain the "binding problem"—how disparate sensations become a unified experience—and suggested that quantum coherence within cellular structures called microtubules allows the brain to function like a quantum computer.

This paper addresses the lack of quantitative rigor in this debate by asking a fundamental physical question: How long can a quantum superposition actually survive in the brain before the environment destroys it?

Methodology: The Decoherence Framework

Tegmark utilizes the framework of open system quantum mechanics. He treats the brain's cognitive degrees of freedom (the "subject") as a system interacting with a noisy "environment" consisting of ions, water molecules, and electromagnetic fields.

The core of the analysis is the comparison between two timescales:

  1. Decoherence timescale ($\tau_{dec}$): The time it takes for a quantum system to lose its coherence due to environmental interactions.
  2. Dynamical timescale ($\tau_{dyn}$): The time required for a biological process (like a neuron firing) to occur.
Phase diagram classifying systems as quantum or classical based on the ratio of dynamical and dissipation timescales to decoherence time.

If $\tau_{dec} \ll \tau_{dyn}$, the system behaves classically. Tegmark specifically models two scenarios: a superposition of a neuron being in a "firing" vs. "resting" state (involving the migration of roughly $10^6$ sodium ions), and kink-like polarization superpositions within microtubules.

Key Results

The calculations yield definitive estimates for decoherence times across various environmental interactions. In all cases, the decoherence time is found to be significantly shorter than the time required for neural activity.

Calculated decoherence times for neurons and microtubules under various environmental interactions.

As shown in the table, for a neuron, decoherence happens in approximately $10^{-20}$ seconds. Given that a neuron fires in about $10^{-3}$ seconds, the environment destroys the quantum state 17 orders of magnitude faster than the brain can utilize it. Even for microtubules, which some argued might be shielded, decoherence occurs in $10^{-13}$ seconds—still far too fast for cognitive processes.

Discussion: The "Warm and Wet" Problem

Quantum computers in laboratory settings require near-absolute zero temperatures to prevent decoherence. The brain, by contrast, is a "warm and wet" environment—a hot, dense soup of ions and water. Tegmark demonstrates that collisions with even a single neighboring ion or water molecule are sufficient to "measure" the system and collapse quantum coherence.

Because the brain is highly dissipative and energy-pumped, it behaves as a "hyper-classical" system. In this regime, quantum effects are relegated to mere noise that can be modeled with simple random number generators, rather than being the engine of cognition.

Conclusion

Because the decoherence times are at least 10 orders of magnitude shorter than the dynamical times, there is no physical basis for assuming the brain operates as a quantum computer. The results suggest that future work in neuroscience should focus on understanding how metastable global patterns of neuron firing emerge from highly dissipative, non-linear classical dynamics. While the calculations are order-of-magnitude estimates, the vast gap between quantum and classical scales makes the conclusion robust against minor modeling refinements.

Summary updated

Abstract

Based on a calculation of neural decoherence rates, we argue that the degrees of freedom of the human brain that relate to cognitive processes should be thought of as a classical rather than quantum system, i.e., that there is nothing fundamentally wrong with the current classical approach to neural network simulations. We find that the decoherence time scales ( approximately 10(-13)-10(-20) s) are typically much shorter than the relevant dynamical time scales ( approximately 10(-3)-10(-1) s), both for regular neuron firing and for kinklike polarization excitations in microtubules. This conclusion disagrees with suggestions by Penrose and others that the brain acts as a quantum computer, and that quantum coherence is related to consciousness in a fundamental way.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{tegmark2000importance,
  author = {Max Tegmark},
  title = {{Importance of quantum decoherence in brain processes}},
  booktitle = {Physical},
  year = {2000},
  doi = {10.1103/physreve.61.4194},
}
Figure