Impacts of stratospheric sulfate geoengineering on tropospheric ozone

Lili Xia, Peer Nowack, Simone Tilmes, Alan Robock

Abstract

A range of solar radiation management (SRM) techniques has been proposed to counter anthropogenic climate change. Here, we examine the potential effects of stratospheric sulfate aerosols and solar insolation reduction on tropospheric ozone and ozone at Earth's surface. Ozone is a key air pollutant, which can produce respiratory diseases and crop damage. Using a version of the Community Earth System Model from the National Center for Atmospheric Research that includes comprehensive tropospheric and stratospheric chemistry, we model both stratospheric sulfur injection and solar irradiance reduction schemes, with the aim of achieving equal levels of surface cooling relative to the Representative Concentration Pathway 6.0 scenario. This allows us to compare the impacts of sulfate aerosols and solar dimming on atmospheric ozone concentrations. Despite nearly identical global mean surface temperatures for the two SRM approaches, solar insolation reduction increases global average surface ozone concentrations, while sulfate injection decreases it. A fundamental difference between the two geoengineering schemes is the importance of heterogeneous reactions in the photochemical ozone balance with larger stratospheric sulfate abundance, resulting in increased ozone depletion in mid- and high latitudes. This reduces the net transport of stratospheric ozone into the troposphere and thus is a key driver of the overall decrease in surface ozone. At the same time, the change in stratospheric ozone alters the tropospheric photochemical environment due to enhanced ultraviolet radiation. A shared factor among both SRM scenarios is decreased chemical ozone loss due to reduced tropospheric humidity. Under insolation reduction, this is the dominant factor giving rise to the global surface ozone increase. Regionally, both surface ozone increases and decreases are found for both scenarios; that is, SRM would affect regions of the world differently in terms of air pollution. In conclusion, surface ozone and tropospheric chemistry would likely be affected by SRM, but the overall effect is strongly dependent on the SRM scheme. Due to the health and economic impacts of surface ozone, all these impacts should be taken into account in evaluations of possible consequences of SRM.

Introduction

As the world struggles to meet carbon mitigation targets, "geoengineering"—specifically Solar Radiation Management (SRM)—is increasingly discussed as a potential climate stopgap. While most research focuses on how these methods affect temperature and precipitation, their impact on air quality remains a critical unknown.

Tropospheric (ground-level) ozone is a double-edged sword: it is a greenhouse gas and a potent pollutant that causes respiratory disease and billions of dollars in crop damage annually. This paper investigates whether two different ways of "dimming the sun" produce the same side effects on ozone chemistry. Specifically, it asks: if we cool the planet by injecting sulfate aerosols into the stratosphere versus simply reducing the solar constant (like a giant dimmer switch), does the air at the surface stay the same?

Methods and Experimental Design

The researchers used the Community Earth System Model (CESM) from NCAR, specifically the CAM4-chem version. This model is sophisticated because it couples comprehensive tropospheric and stratospheric chemistry with land and ocean models. The study relies on ensemble simulations using the Representative Concentration Pathway 6.0 (RCP6.0) as the baseline forcing for anthropogenic emissions (2020–2089).

Three scenarios were compared:

  1. RCP6.0: A standard "business-as-usual" climate pathway.
  2. G4SSA (Sulfate Injection): Injecting 8 Tg of $SO_2$ per year into the tropical stratosphere.
  3. G4SSA-S (Solar Dimming): Reducing the solar constant to achieve the exact same top-of-atmosphere radiative forcing as the sulfate injection.
Figure 1: Comparison of (a) net solar flux and (b) downwelling solar flux at the top of the atmosphere (TOA) for the RCP6.0, G4SSA, and G4SSA-S scenarios.

By matching the cooling effect (~0.8 K reduction globally), the authors could isolate the chemical and dynamical impacts of the sulfate aerosols themselves from the general effects of a cooler planet.

Mechanisms of Ozone Change

Even though both SRM methods cooled the Earth equally, they moved the needle on surface ozone in opposite directions. Sulfate injection lowered global surface ozone, while solar dimming raised it.

The Stratospheric Reservoir

A huge portion of our surface ozone actually drifts down from the stratosphere (Stratosphere-Troposphere Exchange, or STE). Sulfate aerosols provide a surface for "heterogeneous" chemical reactions that activate halogens (like chlorine), which aggressively destroy stratospheric ozone. This "empties the reservoir," leading to less ozone reaching the surface. In the sulfate scenario, the transport of ozone from the stratosphere to the troposphere plummeted by ~25% (~140 Tg/yr) compared to the RCP6.0 baseline. In the solar dimming scenario, this transport only dropped by ~5% (~30 Tg/yr).

The Humidity Factor

Cooling the planet makes the air drier. In the troposphere, water vapor is a major "sink" for ozone (it helps destroy it). Under solar dimming (where the stratosphere remains relatively intact), the reduction in humidity slows down this destruction, leading to a net increase in surface ozone.

Figure 6: Global average precipitation over time for the three scenarios, showing the reduction in the hydrological cycle associated with cooling.

Regional Impacts and Limitations

The effects are not uniform. Both scenarios showed ozone increases in the tropics. However, sulfate injection led to significant ozone reductions in Northern Hemisphere mid-latitudes (where many people live and crops grow), potentially offering a "pollution benefit" that solar dimming does not provide.

The authors acknowledge several caveats for future research. The model used a prescribed distribution of sulfate aerosols rather than a fully interactive microphysics model, and it did not account for how sulfate aerosols scatter UV light. This scattering would likely reduce the amount of UV reaching the troposphere, potentially leading to even lower ozone production than reported here.

Conclusion

Surface ozone and tropospheric chemistry would likely be affected by SRM, but the overall effect is strongly dependent on the specific scheme. Due to the health and economic impacts of surface ozone, these chemical consequences should be integrated into evaluations of the possible risks and benefits of geoengineering.

Summary updated

Abstract

A range of solar radiation management (SRM) techniques has been proposed to counter anthropogenic climate change. Here, we examine the potential effects of stratospheric sulfate aerosols and solar insolation reduction on tropospheric ozone and ozone at Earth's surface. Ozone is a key air pollutant, which can produce respiratory diseases and crop damage. Using a version of the Community Earth System Model from the National Center for Atmospheric Research that includes comprehensive tropospheric and stratospheric chemistry, we model both stratospheric sulfur injection and solar irradiance reduction schemes, with the aim of achieving equal levels of surface cooling relative to the Representative Concentration Pathway 6.0 scenario. This allows us to compare the impacts of sulfate aerosols and solar dimming on atmospheric ozone concentrations. Despite nearly identical global mean surface temperatures for the two SRM approaches, solar insolation reduction increases global average surface ozone concentrations, while sulfate injection decreases it. A fundamental difference between the two geoengineering schemes is the importance of heterogeneous reactions in the photochemical ozone balance with larger stratospheric sulfate abundance, resulting in increased ozone depletion in mid- and high latitudes. This reduces the net transport of stratospheric ozone into the troposphere and thus is a key driver of the overall decrease in surface ozone. At the same time, the change in stratospheric ozone alters the tropospheric photochemical environment due to enhanced ultraviolet radiation. A shared factor among both SRM scenarios is decreased chemical ozone loss due to reduced tropospheric humidity. Under insolation reduction, this is the dominant factor giving rise to the global surface ozone increase. Regionally, both surface ozone increases and decreases are found for both scenarios; that is, SRM would affect regions of the world differently in terms of air pollution. In conclusion, surface ozone and tropospheric chemistry would likely be affected by SRM, but the overall effect is strongly dependent on the SRM scheme. Due to the health and economic impacts of surface ozone, all these impacts should be taken into account in evaluations of possible consequences of SRM.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{xia2017impacts,
  author = {Lili Xia and Peer Nowack and Simone Tilmes and Alan Robock},
  title = {{Impacts of stratospheric sulfate geoengineering on tropospheric ozone}},
  booktitle = {Atmospheric},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.5194/acp-17-11913-2017},
}

Loading related content...

Figure