Impacts of COVID-19 public measures on country-level trade flows: Global panel regression analysis

Sylvia Szabo, Worawat Srisawasdi, Takuji W. Tsusaka, Reuben M. J. Kadigi, James Vause, Neil BurgessmedRxiv 2021 · DOI

Abstract

As of 10 July 2021, there have been over 186 million cases of COVID-19 and more than four million deaths. The COVID-19 outbreak has also contributed to a tremendous global decline in trade flows. The rapid spread of the virus and the measures implemented by governments to contain the pandemic have had serious consequences for the world’s economies. While the pandemic has affected the international movement of people, goods, and services, there is still limited systematic research regarding the possible associations between COVID-19 measures and countries’ international trade flows. To fill this gap, we conducted regression analysis based on country-level time series data from the United Nations and World Bank datasets. The results of the random effects panel regression models show that country import and export values are positively affected by health-related policies, while there is a negative association between stringency measures and trade values. More specifically, school closing, stay-at-home requirements, and testing policy measures were found to have significant negative effects. In contrast, facial covering policies were found to have significant positive effects on countries’ import, export, and total trade values.

The Global Trade Shock

The COVID-19 pandemic triggered a historic contraction in global commerce, with volumes dropping by over 5% in 2020. This disruption was not merely a direct result of the virus but was heavily influenced by the diverse array of government interventions designed to contain its spread. Policymakers have frequently grappled with a perceived trade-off between public health and economic stability.

Comparison of 2019 and 2020 Q2 export values across selected countries, illustrating the widespread decline in trade volume.

As shown in the comparison of export values between 2019 and 2020, almost every major economy experienced a visible dip in trade during the second quarter of 2020. This study seeks to move beyond anecdotal evidence to provide a systematic, quantitative look at how specific policy clusters—stringency, health containment, and economic support—impacted these flows across 70 different countries.

Methodology and Data Sources

The research employed a Random Effects Panel Regression model to analyze data from January to August 2020. This approach allows for controlling unobserved heterogeneity between countries that remains constant over time. To ensure robustness, the authors used Variance Inflation Factor (VIF) analysis to mitigate multicollinearity and included control variables such as GDP, population density, and land surface area.

Data was synthesized from four primary global repositories:

  1. UN Comtrade Database: Monthly import and export values.
  2. WHO COVID-19 Dashboard: Daily confirmed cases and deaths.
  3. Oxford COVID-19 Government Response Tracker (OxCGRT): The source for the Stringency Index (SI), Containment and Health Index (CHI), and Economic Support Index (ESI).
  4. World Bank & UNSD: Demographic and geographic control data.
Monthly evolution of government response indices from January to September 2020, showing the varying intensity of different policy types.

Analysis of Policy Impacts

The "Health-Trade" Synergy

Contrary to the assumption that all health measures hinder the economy, the Containment and Health Index (CHI)—which includes public awareness and testing—showed a significant positive correlation with trade. Effective pandemic management appears to boost market confidence and stabilize economic activity. Specifically, CHI was associated with a +$139.8M** increase in imports and **+$98.5M in exports.

Masks as Economic Enablers

The most striking finding was the impact of facial covering policies. While lockdowns restricted the labor force, mask mandates allowed manual labor and logistics to continue under safer conditions. This policy was associated with a staggering +$726.6M** in imports and **+$1,073.7M in exports.

The Lockdown Penalty

The Stringency Index (SI) was the primary driver of trade decline, associated with a -$150.9M** decrease in imports and **-$122.5M in exports. School closures and stay-at-home requirements were the most "expensive" policies, likely due to their immediate impact on labor availability. Interestingly, the Economic Support Index (ESI) (debt relief and income support) had no statistically significant impact on trade flows, likely because these funds targeted individual consumption rather than the industries directly involved in international commerce.

Conclusion and Limitations

While providing critical insights into policy-driven trade fluctuations, the study has limitations. It focuses exclusively on international trade, excluding domestic manufacturing and tourism. Furthermore, the macro-level data may mask nuances at the individual business level. Future research should explore the impact of COVID-19 on "BioTrade" and biodiversity as the global economy transitions into a post-pandemic framework.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract As of 10 July 2021, there have been over 186 million cases of COVID-19 and more than four million died as a result of this disease. The COVID-19 outbreak has also contributed to tremendous global decline in trade flows. The rapid spread of COVID-19 and the measures implemented by governments to contain the pandemic have had serious consequences for the world’s economies. While the pandemic has affected the international movement of people, goods and services, there is still limited systematic research regarding the possible associations between the COVID-19 measures on countries’ international trade flows. To fill this gap, we conducted regression analysis based on country level time series data from the United Nations and World Bank datasets. The results of the random effects panel regression models show that, the country import and export values are positively affected by health-related policies, while there is a negative association between stringency measures and import and export values. More specifically, school closing, stay-at-home requirements, and testing policy measures were found to have significant negative effects on countries’ trade values. In contrast, facial covering policies were found to have significant positive effects on countries’ import, export and total trade values.
BibTeX
@misc{szabo2021impacts,
  author = {Sylvia Szabo and Worawat Srisawasdi and Takuji W. Tsusaka and Reuben M. J. Kadigi and James Vause and Neil Burgess},
  title = {{Impacts of COVID-19 public measures on country-level trade flows: Global panel regression analysis}},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1101/2021.07.09.21260294},
  howpublished = {medRxiv},
}
Figure