Impacts of Agricultural Expansion (1910s–2010s) on the Water Cycle in the Songneng Plain, Northeast China

Lijuan Zhang, Cuizhen Wang, Xiaxiang Li, Hongwen Zhang, Wenliang Li, Lanqi JiangRemote 2018 · DOI

TL;DR

This study quantifies the century-long impact of agricultural expansion on the water cycle in China's Songnen Plain. Using the WRF model, researchers found that while precipitation remained stable, increased agricultural activity led to significantly higher evapotranspiration, reduced runoff and infiltration, and a resulting drying trend, particularly in the central plain. This highlights the critical need for sustainable land management in this vital agricultural region.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Land use change, particularly agricultural expansion, is a major driver of global environmental shifts. While its impact on climate is well-documented, the specific, long-term effects on regional water cycles are less understood, especially in critical agricultural areas. The Songnen Plain in Northeast China, known for its fertile "Black Soil" and extensive historical land conversion from grassland to cropland, presents a prime case study. This paper aims to fill the knowledge gap by quantifying how a century of agricultural expansion has altered the water balance in this region, moving beyond general climate impacts to focus on the intricate land-atmosphere interactions of the water cycle.

Methods

The researchers employed the Weather Research and Forecasting (WRF) model coupled with the Noah Multi-Parameterization (Noah-MP) land surface model to simulate the water cycle. They focused on six key variables: precipitation (PRE), total evapotranspiration (TET), canopy transpiration (CE), canopy interception evaporation (IE), land evaporation (LE), and surface runoff and infiltration (RI). To isolate the effects of land use change, they used a fixed climatic boundary condition based on a 5-year average (2008-2012) to exclude broader climate variability from the analysis. The study simulated water balance for each decade from the 1910s to the 2010s, comparing deviations from the initial 1910s state to assess the impact of agricultural expansion. The results were further validated against historical climate reanalysis data (ERA Interim) and compared with the Palmer Drought Severity Index (PDSI) to corroborate the identified drying trends.

Datasets

  • Land Use/Land Cover (LULC) Data: Decadal LULC maps for the Songnen Plain from the 1910s to the 2010s. This included historical maps digitized from land use maps and satellite-derived LULC maps (Landsat MSS, TM, ETM+).
  • Environmental Data: Digital Elevation Model (DEM) from the U.S. Geological Survey.
  • Climate Reanalysis Data:
    • Monthly precipitation and temperature data from the European Reanalysis Interim (ERA-Interim) at a 0.5° × 0.5° grid for model validation.
  • 6-h NCEP global forecast system (GFS) final (FNL) operational global analysis data for WRF model parameterization.
  • Drought Index Data: Palmer Drought Severity Index (PDSI) derived from ERA Reanalysis data for comparison with simulated drought effects.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Decoupling Land Use from Climate Change: A crucial methodological choice was fixing the climatic boundary conditions. This allowed the study to isolate the specific impacts of land use change on the water cycle, rather than conflating them with broader climate trends, which is a common challenge in such studies.
  • Subtle Precipitation Changes, Significant Evapotranspiration Shifts: The finding that precipitation remained largely stable while total evapotranspiration increased dramatically is a key insight. This suggests that the management of water within the ecosystem, rather than the input of water, is being significantly altered by agricultural practices.
  • The "Drying Effect" Mechanism: The study clearly illustrates how agricultural expansion leads to a drying effect. Increased canopy transpiration and interception evaporation by crops draw more water from the soil, while reduced runoff and infiltration mean less water is replenished. This creates a net deficit.
  • Spatial Heterogeneity of Impacts: The central plain, despite being less intensively cultivated in some areas, showed the strongest drying trend. This is attributed to the presence of remaining wetlands, which are highly sensitive to changes in water availability and are directly impacted by surrounding agricultural expansion.

Key Results

  • Agricultural Expansion: Cropland area in the Songnen Plain increased from approximately 28% in the 1910s to 72% in the 2010s, primarily through the conversion of grasslands.
  • Precipitation: Plain-wide precipitation showed no significant trend over the past century.
  • Evapotranspiration: Total evapotranspiration (TET) significantly increased, driven by a dramatic rise in canopy transpiration (average rate of 36 mm/10a) and interception evaporation (6 mm/10a).
  • Runoff and Infiltration: Surface runoff and infiltration (RI) decreased significantly (average rate of -44 mm/10a). Land evaporation (LE) also decreased slightly (-8 mm/10a).
  • Drought Effect: The combined changes indicate a clear drying trend in the Songnen Plain, supported by stronger decreasing trends in the PDSI since the 1980s.
  • Spatial Patterns: The central plain exhibited the most pronounced drying trend, linked to the conversion of wetlands and grasslands.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Crop Type Simplification: The WRF model treated all agricultural lands as a single "cropland" category. Future work could incorporate individual crop types (corn, soybean, wheat) and their specific canopy structures and management practices for a more nuanced understanding.
  • Exclusion of Irrigation and Fertilization: The study focused on land use change and excluded the impacts of irrigation and fertilization, which can significantly alter water usage and land-atmosphere interactions. Future research should integrate these factors.
  • Water Body Dynamics: The decrease in water bodies (wetlands, lakes) was not explicitly modeled but is acknowledged as a contributing factor to water volume decrease. Future studies could investigate the variation of runoff and infiltration separately by incorporating water body extent and volume data.
  • Drought Index Limitations: While PDSI was used, the authors acknowledge its limitations and suggest exploring more advanced indices like SPI and SPEI when data become available.
  • Soil Data Granularity: Due to limited soil data availability for such a large region, runoff and infiltration were combined. More detailed soil data would allow for a more precise separation of these components.

The study underscores the urgent need for Black Soil conservation and sustainable agricultural practices to ensure the long-term productivity and food security of this vital region.

Summary updated

Abstract

Agricultural expansion is one of the primary land use changes on the Earth’s surface. The Songnen Plain in Northeast China is renowned for its Black Soil and is one of the most important agricultural regions of this country. In the last century, its population increased 20-fold and excessive areas of grassland were cultivated. Based on a series of decadal land use/land cover data sets in the plain (1910s–2010s), this study simulated the water balance in each decade using the Weather Research and Forecasting (WRF) model and assessed the water effects of centurial agricultural expansion. Six variables were simulated to explain the land-atmosphere interaction: precipitation, total evapotranspiration, canopy transpiration, canopy interception evaporation, land evaporation and land surface runoff and infiltration. Agreeing with historical climate reanalysis data, the simulated precipitation in the plain did not have a significant trend. However, the total evapotranspiration significantly increased in the study region. The canopy transpiration and interception evaporation increased and the runoff and infiltration decreased, both indicating a drought effect in soil. The drying trend varied spatially with the strongest pattern in the central plain where large areas of wetlands remain. As a consequence of agricultural expansion, the centurial drying process in the fertile Black Soil may put strong pressure on the crop productivity and food safety of this important agricultural region.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhang2018impacts,
  author = {Lijuan Zhang and Cuizhen Wang and Xiaxiang Li and Hongwen Zhang and Wenliang Li and Lanqi Jiang},
  title = {{Impacts of Agricultural Expansion (1910s–2010s) on the Water Cycle in the Songneng Plain, Northeast China}},
  booktitle = {Remote},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.3390/rs10071108},
}
Figure